What about what schools take away their offer after they have committed? Byu has

Feb 18, 2018
12:34:41pm

BYUFootballisBack Starter

Same thing in my opinion. Sure it's a commitment but if they just changed the word would that change anything in your opinion? Is it because they use the word committed instead of intend or plan?

Report problem with this ad

BYUFootballisBack

Previous username: oddsewer
Bio page: BYUFootballisBack
Joined: Apr 29, 2007
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 14,000 (722 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If I were a parent I would be furious if my child decommited

BlueVU

2/18/18 12:02pm

I would only be furious if he decommited from BYU. If he decommited from

IceCreamButt

2/18/18 12:05pm

TNT is guessing BlueVU feels the same

TNT

2/18/18 12:08pm

Nope.

BlueVU

2/18/18 12:53pm

I guess that means you weren't a taysom hill fan...

So it goes...

2/18/18 4:21pm

Ooooo, buuurn!

Betruewhiteandblue

2/18/18 4:30pm

Hill was lied to by Harbaugh...

jsjohnson1278

2/18/18 11:28pm

Maybe they didn't have doubt until they saw the dumpster

johnnycarson

2/18/18 12:05pm

Have you ever changed companies?

mosterlow

2/18/18 12:05pm

How often do you commit to stay with a company?

BlueVU

2/18/18 1:02pm

Exactly, once you sign a scholarship it’s a year commitment only, not 4

mosterlow

2/18/18 1:41pm

Most P5 conferences now offer 4-year scholarships, not year to year.

displacedute

2/18/18 3:25pm

No they are not, kids should be allowed to transfer for multiple reasons

mosterlow

2/18/18 3:31pm

All P5 scholarships are guaranteed.

displacedute

2/18/18 3:38pm

You are correct with conditions, and those conditions can be enforced if needed

mosterlow

2/18/18 4:04pm

Most people are even with their company every two weeks

Coug98

2/18/18 3:30pm

What if he decommitted from Utah State and committed to BYU, would you feel the

RC Vikings

2/18/18 12:05pm

Yes

BlueVU

2/18/18 1:02pm

Nature of the game, BYU got several high profile transfers

ColumbusCoug

2/18/18 12:07pm

Recruiting is like dating

BrutustheBrash

2/18/18 12:07pm

*sniff* that hurts

TNT

2/18/18 12:09pm

I think this is the correct answer. Schools, even BYU moves on at times.

coolblue

2/18/18 4:46pm

Kids see their parents “decommit” from marriage all the time.

dadofkhec

2/18/18 12:13pm

But they aren’t thrilled about it

pegushin

2/18/18 12:52pm

Just like with divorce they can find another option.

BlueVU

2/18/18 12:56pm

Probably because they never knew what commitment was to begin with...

BYU4eVeR

2/19/18 10:00am

It’s not that simple. My son is a division 1 committed athlete. . .

El Paso Coug

2/18/18 12:27pm

I agree with what you’re saying, but

coug719

2/18/18 2:06pm

What's wrong with window shopping?

Dissenter

2/19/18 9:30am

I call BS , if you think BYU pressured a 15 year old to "commit now" or never

BYU4eVeR

2/19/18 10:04am

Why is this is response to my post? I never said anything about BYU. More info

El Paso Coug

2/19/18 1:35pm

You are being too literal

Modiolus

2/18/18 12:30pm

What about what schools take away their offer after they have committed? Byu has

BYUFootballisBack

2/18/18 12:34pm

Zadock got hosed

Coogar2

2/18/18 1:39pm

Zadock is at a JC

Cougtruth

2/18/18 2:46pm

“A man is only as faithful as his options” - Chris Rock

Zach Morris

2/18/18 12:43pm

Woah. Heavy

TNT

2/18/18 12:54pm

<< Deleted >>

Ulysses14

2/18/18 12:59pm

Ridiculous. Embarrassing. I assume you won't be so

Plato

2/18/18 12:59pm

<< Deleted >>

BlueVU

2/18/18 1:19pm

amen to this

BountifulCoug5

2/18/18 1:08pm

You are joking. We are talking about a teenager. Give the kid a break.

MajorZeus

2/18/18 1:16pm

RE: If I were a parent I would be furious if my child decommited

billyrust

2/18/18 1:22pm

If I were a parent I'd be ecstatic if my kid got a full-ride to Bama, USC or OSU

vagabonder

2/18/18 1:28pm

The commitments should be viewed as "right now in leaning toward BYU. A lot can

Ulysses14

2/18/18 1:30pm

That's a really dangerous way to live. I hope you reconsider your mindset.

ekiben

2/18/18 1:38pm

Really? Isn’t this a better time to change your mind than

DrBYU

2/18/18 1:42pm

Decommiting is completely within the rules and culture of college sports. The school isn't willing to commit to the

HarlemCoug

2/18/18 1:58pm

It’s a two way street. It’s not just on the kid, and schools drop offers all the time, leaving kids without options they

macaroni

2/18/18 1:59pm

That is absurd. If your daughter is engaged to be married

BLT-Coug

2/18/18 2:30pm

Things change!

Denesheo

2/18/18 2:38pm

That's a little harsh. It's their future, not yours.

TRUE_BLUE_COUGY

2/18/18 2:41pm

Your're treating this like a divorce from a loving spouse,

bigjohn

2/18/18 2:57pm

How do you feel about RMs transferring to BYU post-mission?

displacedute

2/18/18 3:24pm

Thank you for not having children.

Doc Buff

2/18/18 4:19pm

Its a good thing your not a parent then...

TheLost

2/18/18 4:29pm

As a parent you would want what is the best situation for you kid despite any

mudpupper

2/18/18 5:57pm

Yet Bluevu’s the guy that begs McKee/Covey/Fehoko etc to change to BYU

Swishfromdeep3

2/18/18 6:14pm

Spoken like a child who's had everything go 100% his way in life...

ClackamasCoug

2/18/18 8:05pm

you are ridiculous....

BYU4eVeR

2/19/18 10:05am

That's a poor thought process. Situations change. It's unwise to stick with

BigBrotherUte

2/18/18 10:07pm

Agreed. No such word as "decommitted".

ArchbishopMitty

2/18/18 11:30pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad