Detmers biggest mistake last year was this.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 23, 2018
7:54:27pm

youngbuck All-American

Detmers biggest mistake last year was this.

I have been watching BYU football for forty years. Never saw a quarterback more unprepared to start

Report problem with this ad

youngbuck

Bio page: youngbuck
Joined: Feb 4, 2002
Last login: Oct 1, 2019
Total posts: 2,166 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Starting Senior QB = winning season - even when starting QB named before fall

Coogar2

6/23/18 4:37pm

You start the best player. Not someone because they are a senior.

Dangerous

6/23/18 5:14pm

Seriously, who was a legit challenger to Tanner starting last yeat

Coogar2

6/23/18 5:49pm

Who knows, but Mangum was not good last year. You don’t play someone

Dangerous

6/23/18 6:07pm

Apparently Kalani didn't know either and that is the problem

Coogar2

6/23/18 6:34pm

You think you're so much smarter than the coaches on staff,

hammergm

6/23/18 10:06pm

I did not say start the senior regardless

Coogar2

6/23/18 11:33pm

Maybe its bologna, Maybe its hogwash,

hammergm

6/24/18 1:33pm

Ty was the problem. He is no longer here. Whether the replacement is better, TBD

molodyets

6/23/18 11:34pm

Ty contributed to the problem. So did Kalani and he is still at BYU

Coogar2

6/23/18 11:41pm

I’m super excited for Mangum to start this year

youngbuck

6/23/18 7:52pm

Starting a senior usually means you've setup a proper pipeline.

mudpupper

6/23/18 6:47pm

Absolutely. Agree entirely

Coogar2

6/23/18 11:26pm

Also - all the players you listed had good junior seasons. They maybe wouldn’t

Dangerous

6/23/18 5:19pm

I am fine with competing to start. But not with

Coogar2

6/23/18 5:51pm

What excuses?

hammergm

6/23/18 10:13pm

Bingo 100% correct

kahuna

6/24/18 2:24am

Tell that to Alabama

Kingfisher

6/23/18 5:36pm

Who did Bama start in game one?

Coogar2

6/23/18 5:45pm

Not a senior. Jalen hurts is who they started.

Kingfisher

6/23/18 5:59pm

Yep started the returning starter in game one and didn't wait

Coogar2

6/23/18 6:19pm

Okay. His freshmen year he started. The second series

Kingfisher

6/23/18 7:13pm

A sophomore.

Kingfisher

6/23/18 6:00pm

In 2010 Nebraska had Zak Lee, who was the starter the year before and

Holy Driver

6/23/18 6:09pm

I agree with starting the best player. I disagree with Kalani's excuse for last

Coogar2

6/23/18 6:22pm

Detmers biggest mistake last year was this.

youngbuck

6/23/18 7:54pm

There wasn’t anyone else ready to start at QB last year

Coogar2

6/23/18 11:37pm

I think John Walsh left after his Junior year.

ptcougr

6/23/18 6:20pm

Thanks for the reminder.

Coogar2

6/23/18 6:24pm

In nearly all those cases they started two years. The best success for BYU

Nat Gas Man

6/23/18 9:49pm

Which one of those senior QBs struggled as much as Mangum their Jr year?

D.T. Survivor

6/23/18 11:25pm

Which one produced like Tanner as a frosh

Coogar2

6/23/18 11:42pm

That’s not a trend I feel good about

D.T. Survivor

6/23/18 11:47pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad