Yet you lead with the dumbest of all propositions, "Start the Senior regardless with no competition to see who is the best player"

Tanner had a horrible year last year.  Absolutely aweful.  He couldn't see the field, and more importantly, he couldn't stay healthy. Why you would think he should be named a starter without competition shows how little you understand about football.

You might want to let Aaron Roderick, Kalani Sitaki, and Jeff Grimes make the  detmination after a fair competition.  If its Tanner, great, lets support him.  But if its not...lets support that player.  Even if he's  a freshman.

But after last year, lets not pretend that Tanner is the EASY answer for QB.