Tanner was the only one of those who had any experience whatsoever...

Report problem with this ad

Jul 22, 2018
7:11:29am

HighHorse Lysander Spooner Fan

and he was the one who got the reps in fall camp. None of the others had been coached to take over the team.

Report problem with this ad

HighHorse

Bio page: HighHorse
Joined: Apr 23, 2002
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 74,414 (4,297 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

<< Deleted >>

Cashmeousside

7/22/18 1:24am

I'd bet a ton of money it will be Mangum

Mrs Featerbottom

7/22/18 3:04am

I'm going with Hoge. Quick feet always win. I agree with the OP, he'll be out

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

7/22/18 7:47am

Which is why coaches would be crazy to go with him

GOR

7/22/18 12:04pm

Mangum is injured prone too. Put the best QB in even if it's 2 or 3 games.

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

7/22/18 12:32pm

I'd bet money it won't be Critchlow.

dYrtbYkerYder

7/22/18 4:22am

I agree with you. I don’t see why people think critchlow has a chance

zerome4sooners

7/22/18 6:48am

So listening to the QB trainer podcast the other day, he said that TM failed to

thecthdox

7/22/18 6:17am

It’s hard for me to understand the negativity around Mangum

CommodoreCoug

7/22/18 6:43am

Tanner was the only one of those who had any experience whatsoever...

HighHorse

7/22/18 7:11am

Just like Taysom in 2016. Looked a lot worse than in prior years

CommodoreCoug

7/22/18 7:31am

I didn't think he looked worse in 2016, not sure what the stats say.

HighHorse

7/22/18 7:46am

Stats say he was way worse

viper

7/22/18 9:12am

The Taysom who spent multiple off seasons recovering from surgeries instead...

CougarThug

7/22/18 8:59pm

This. And honestly I thought Critchlow looked just as good.

GOR

7/22/18 12:06pm

Yeah, at no time during the season did Tanner look good to me.

HighHorse

7/22/18 3:08pm

I thought Hoge looked good in the USU game till he got hurt

Florwood

7/22/18 7:39am

He threw 9 passes in that game. Insufficient sample size

CommodoreCoug

7/22/18 7:58am

He was leading 21-something and driving...what could have been in that game.

Florwood

7/22/18 10:26am

He had just thrown a pick 6

palangi

7/22/18 12:59pm

Wasn't it off someone's helmet? Kinda flukey

GOR

7/22/18 1:46pm

Lip Gallagher

7/22/18 2:09pm

It was kinda flukey and a bad throw

Coop

7/22/18 2:40pm

Hoge threw a pick 6 against USU. never good

Coogar2

7/22/18 5:37pm

Critchlow doesn’t have a big arm, and his release is slow

Coop

7/22/18 7:11am

So “shorter than people think” is that there are 3 contenders and not 4? Why say

Lolo

7/22/18 7:26am

He also lessoned running the ball being a nice to have kind of thing

Pretorian

7/22/18 7:33am

Good point, I didn’t pick up on that

Cashmeousside

7/22/18 8:26am

I think Mangum struggled because we didn’t have a coach dedicated to QB’s.

Ned Schneebly

7/22/18 7:46am

I think the reality is that TFD should have been the QB coach

Adrielle

7/22/18 5:55pm

I think it’s 2. Mangum and Hoge

PhilPete

7/22/18 7:54am

Yes and behind closed doors it's been narrowed down to one...

HighHorse

7/22/18 8:06am

This. I think Mangum has the edge due to experience

CougarsFanSince80s

7/22/18 11:28am

The best thing for the program would be Mangum being an effective starter this

akmewg

7/22/18 8:44am

Even if Wilson(or Hall) were in the top 3.......

mokelembembe

7/22/18 9:45am

I see Critchlow transferring, but Hoge would only have his senior year left. His

Lance71

7/22/18 12:05pm

Hoge will be the backup QB this year and the starter if Mangum goes down.

HighHorse

7/22/18 3:09pm

I’m betting Mangum. There’s a lot that he did wrong last season but it appears..

Sambothegreat

7/22/18 4:03pm

The coaches have acknowledged multiple times that Hoge's health is questionable.

Posting on CougarBoard