Aug 13, 2018
12:23:00pm
12:23:00pm
Who is the Top 15? My list of where I think BYU fandom ranks our QBs
(Note: This is based on performance at BYU as a player only)
1. Ty Detmer
2. Jim McMahon
3/4. Steve Young or Robbie Bosco
Next Tier: Steve Sarkisian/ Marc Wilson / Gifford Nielson / John Beck Sr. Season
Next Tier: Max Hall / Taysom Hill (Non-injured) / Gary Sheide
While creeping on Cougarboard for several years this is where I have believed people ranked BYU QBs throughout the years. Is this not the general idea? Because I can only pick 8-10 guys I would have placed before Max Hall.
1. Ty Detmer
2. Jim McMahon
3/4. Steve Young or Robbie Bosco
Next Tier: Steve Sarkisian/ Marc Wilson / Gifford Nielson / John Beck Sr. Season
Next Tier: Max Hall / Taysom Hill (Non-injured) / Gary Sheide
While creeping on Cougarboard for several years this is where I have believed people ranked BYU QBs throughout the years. Is this not the general idea? Because I can only pick 8-10 guys I would have placed before Max Hall.
- Bio page
- Zoobieman
- Joined
- Apr 23, 2012
- Last login
- May 2, 2024
- Total posts
- 10,512 (29 FO)
Messages
Time
8/12/18 10:26am
I didn’t think this was an unpopular opinion, maybe it is. But, I think Max Hall is one of the greats.
8/12/18 10:27am
8/12/18 10:35am
8/13/18 9:03am
8/13/18 2:05pm
8/13/18 7:42pm
8/14/18 9:44am
8/14/18 6:28pm
8/12/18 10:29am
8/12/18 10:35am
8/12/18 10:32am
8/12/18 10:34am
8/12/18 10:53am
8/12/18 10:55am
8/12/18 10:39am
8/13/18 5:07am
8/12/18 1:32pm
8/12/18 9:31pm
8/12/18 9:45pm
8/12/18 10:55am
8/12/18 11:11am
8/13/18 10:12am
8/12/18 11:48am
8/12/18 1:40pm
8/12/18 8:29pm
8/12/18 6:10pm
Can one say that Grimes is turning things around before a single ball in a real game has been snapped? I like what I am
8/12/18 11:54pm
8/13/18 7:55am
8/12/18 8:27pm
8/12/18 9:35pm
8/13/18 7:27am