We don’t need extra games for 6-6 teams. We only want BYU in that game because

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2018
11:31:41am

ataylor All-American

it exists, but we’d all be better off with a 12-16 team playoff and maybe a second NIT-ish playoff.

Report problem with this ad

ataylor

Bio page: ataylor
Joined: Apr 20, 2009
Last login: May 16, 2020
Total posts: 33,802 (2,404 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The fact that there is a Cheese-It Bowl is evidence enough that college football

ataylor

11/12/18 11:25am

If private sponsors did not pay advertising dollars to promote college sports,

cwilke1

11/12/18 11:29am

We don’t need extra games for 6-6 teams. We only want BYU in that game because

ataylor

11/12/18 11:31am

I would not be better off this season as a BYU fan, because I have one less game

cwilke1

11/12/18 11:35am

6-6 teams shouldn’t be playing post-season football. Full stop.

ataylor

11/12/18 11:36am

I used to think this way, but why does it matter if they do?

benny1982

11/12/18 11:39am

Because the alternative is much better, especially for teams like BYU who are on

ataylor

11/12/18 11:43am

Okay, so your real point is against the bowl system in general, not just

benny1982

11/12/18 11:47am

I think the fact that 6-6 teams are in bowls underscores the ridiculousness of

ataylor

11/12/18 11:50am

Yeah, that's where we disagree. I don't think having fewer bowls does

benny1982

11/12/18 11:53am

It doesn’t affect the other bowls directly, but it cheapens the system,

ataylor

11/12/18 12:05pm

A tournament would be fairer and give more access to outsiders, but football

cwilke1

11/12/18 11:52am

You shorten the season then. It’s not rocket science.

ataylor

11/12/18 11:52am

Having a playoff and having bowl games are not mutually exclusive

MapCoug

11/12/18 12:53pm

I hope your love of BYU football outweighs your bowl snobbishness and that you

cwilke1

11/12/18 11:39am

I’ll support them, but it’s ridiculous that we’re celebrating mediocrity with a

ataylor

11/12/18 11:40am

I'm more excited that our young team gets to continue practicing all month.

mulletino

11/12/18 11:46am

We don’t need to play meaningless bowl games in order to let teams practice.

ataylor

11/12/18 11:51am

Actually, the team is not allowed official practices without a bowl game.

mulletino

11/12/18 11:56am

And I’m saying that needs to go.

ataylor

11/12/18 11:58am

Cool. I prefer another 21-22 full practices prior to spring ball.

mulletino

11/12/18 12:03pm

Personally, I'd prefer that they allow every team the extra practices,

benny1982

11/12/18 12:05pm

Seems fair.

mulletino

11/12/18 12:10pm

That’s what I’m saying as well, if that wasn’t clear.

ataylor

11/12/18 12:26pm

Who says a bowl game has to be considered a celebration of a season?

cwilke1

11/12/18 11:50am

Because that’s how it’s treated and incentivized for players, coaches, and ADs.

ataylor

11/12/18 11:52am

100% agree. Bowls were originally created as a reward for a great season

Michael McQuain

11/12/18 11:41am

I do sort of miss the days of 2 loss teams missing bowls.

Belboz

11/12/18 11:54am

Why not?

BYUMissouriCoug

11/12/18 4:31pm

It perpetuates the worst post-season system in sports, pro or amateur.

ataylor

11/12/18 7:32pm

but it nicely compensates for that with the most compelling regular season of

cwilke1

11/12/18 7:35pm

I don’t think a playoff — implemented correctly — would change that much.

ataylor

11/12/18 7:47pm

maybe an 8 team regular season tournament would not reduce it, but a 16 team

cwilke1

11/12/18 7:52pm

Any perceived decrease in regular-season “excitement” would be made up for with

ataylor

11/12/18 8:00pm

the system is unfair. Its an imperfect world. But college football is the only

cwilke1

11/12/18 8:22pm

College football doesn’t have a variety of how a championship can be decided

ataylor

11/12/18 10:55pm

I did not say college football itself has a variety, but rather that college

cwilke1

11/13/18 9:40am

Idk bout you but I'm alot more invested in the nmst game knowing there is a bowl

BYUMissouriCoug

11/12/18 8:05pm

I’m more interested to see if the team can string a few wins together, and

ataylor

11/12/18 8:24pm

I get what you're saying, more isn't always better

BYUMissouriCoug

11/12/18 8:31pm

How do two random 6-6 teams playing affect you? Just don't watch.

molodyets

11/12/18 4:55pm

They don’t, and I won’t unless it’s BYU, but I still think the whole system is

ataylor

11/12/18 7:34pm

As much as I understand why groups take corporate sponsorships (free money),

MasterLump

11/12/18 11:29am

I hate every time they say The Rose Bowl Game presented by Northwestern Mutual

MasterLump

11/12/18 11:30am

Did you say the same when Tostitos sponsored the fiesta bowl?

Beggar

11/12/18 12:46pm

Not quite the same thing, but also silly.

ataylor

11/12/18 2:54pm

This is actually an amazing bowl. It was the Cactus Bowl until this year.

andrewg3

11/12/18 1:34pm

6-6 teams don’t play in amazing bowl games.

ataylor

11/12/18 2:55pm

I didn't say they did.

andrewg3

11/13/18 9:26am

They can call it whatever they want if they fill the schools pockets

Pretorian

11/12/18 2:34pm

There was a fantastic article a while back in SI that outlined whose pockets get

ataylor

11/12/18 2:57pm

I had to look it up. Never heard of it before. Redbox is another level of stupid

Posting on CougarBoard