Why not do it like boxing? Have 3 judges make a call. 2-1 majority wins.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 21, 2019
8:44:12am

dYrtbYkerYder All-American

Why not do it like boxing? Have 3 judges make a call. 2-1 majority wins.

Report problem with this ad

dYrtbYkerYder

Bio page: dYrtbYkerYder
Joined: Sep 27, 2006
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 22,819 (136 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

One reason I don’t see NFL PI being reviewable any time soon...

2018grad

1/21/19 6:57am

Maybe make it reviewable in the last 5 minutes of a 1 score game

the_byu_flash

1/21/19 7:03am

I agree that would fix this issue, but what if it stops a 3rd down conversion

2018grad

1/21/19 7:06am

You make PI only reviewable if challenged.

Left Shark Coug

1/21/19 7:06am

But if coaches are getting challenges correct, they don’t run out. You’re right

2018grad

1/21/19 7:10am

Sounds like they need to fix how they do reviews, not limit the number.

1/21/19 7:12am

Do you know how reviews work in the NFL? It sounds to me like you don't

UberDeek

1/21/19 7:23am

Nope. Never even watched a game before.

2018grad

1/21/19 7:44am

This is what the CFL does.

1/21/19 7:10am

Just have an official in the booth who can overturn obvious blown calls

PHXSUNS31

1/21/19 7:09am

Maybe, but seems hard to have a designated group or ref managers

2018grad

1/21/19 7:13am

All it takes is one person sitting in the booth watching the game

PHXSUNS31

1/21/19 8:34am

Sorry I meant during regular season when there’s 8 games at same time

2018grad

1/21/19 8:44am

The NFL makes billions of dollars, they can hire 15 additional refs

PHXSUNS31

1/21/19 1:44pm

Why not do it like boxing? Have 3 judges make a call. 2-1 majority wins.

1/21/19 8:44am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad