Apr 20, 2019
12:13:57pm
12:13:57pm
Lol, not even close to the best in his prime. Pedro, Johnson, and Koufax all had 2 seasons better
than Maddux's best season by bWAR.
Maddux's best season by ERA+ was 271. Pedro's was 291 (!!!).
By WAR7 (only picking each pitcher's best 7 years), Clemens kills Maddux, and Johnson and Pedro both narrowly beat Maddux too.
Maddux was a great, great pitcher. But his best argument is longevity, not pretending his prime was the absolute best out of all these guys.
Maddux's best season by ERA+ was 271. Pedro's was 291 (!!!).
By WAR7 (only picking each pitcher's best 7 years), Clemens kills Maddux, and Johnson and Pedro both narrowly beat Maddux too.
Maddux was a great, great pitcher. But his best argument is longevity, not pretending his prime was the absolute best out of all these guys.
- Previous username
- TCuz13
- Bio page
- TCuz
- Joined
- Mar 1, 2014
- Last login
- May 22, 2024
- Total posts
- 58,783 (19,281 FO)
Messages
Time
He also had one of the worst walk rates of all time. Too wild to be considered the best. The 7 no-nos are incredible,
4/20/19 1:03am
4/20/19 7:13am
4/20/19 1:15am
4/20/19 1:55am
4/20/19 10:00am
4/20/19 7:01am
4/20/19 2:22am
4/20/19 6:09am
4/20/19 7:27am