do you honestly think any running back on BYU's team would start of Moss? Ty'son was like the third or 4th running back on a mediocre SEC team. Moss is one of the two or three leading candidates from the Pac12 to be in the heisman race.

I will admit that there is at least a discussion to be had with 5-10 players on BYU's team.

Corbin Kaufusi absolutely would have started at Utah last year. He's the only player that made me think, oh yeah, that guy is better than what we currently have, and now he's gone... Takitaki may not have started because Barton and Hansen were so good, but he was every bit as good as those two. He absolutely would have been the guy to come in on obvious passing downs at least.

One of the names you guys bring up a lot is Dayan. I just don't see it. He had 31 tackles last year, zero sacks, and zero INT.  31 tackles for a safety is not great. It's not terrible, he is fine, but it isn't great. Our starter last year had more solo tackles than Dayan had Solo+assists... and he had two picks.

From this year's team I would say the only one that would for sure get regular snaps is Tonga. He may or may not start ahead of Penisini, but he would at least be in the rotation.