OP picks BYU (although says it could go either way) (9-3 overall)
demon_llama picks SDSU (6-6 overall)
LavellIfIKnow picks BYU (10-2 overall)
jreid191 doesn't explicitly pick the game, but picks 9-3 overall, so hard to imagine he's picking a SDSU loss
HighHorse picks BYU
cougarfan84 says 8-4, so maybe he's picking a SDSU loss, but probably not
DraperCoug22 also picks 8-4, but no individual games, so probably not picking a SDSU loss
cougfanz also picks 8-4 but no individual games, again, probably not picking a SDSU loss
BYURider picks 11-2, so not picking a SDSU loss
jackryanslc is a Ute fan who picks 7-5, so probably not picking a SDSU loss
Short Creek Cougar picks SDSU (5-7 overall)
Benefica1 picks BYU (9-3 overall)
PhilPete is another 7-5 with no individual games
andrewg3 is a Ute fan (I think), but picks BYU (8-4 overall)
Hill4Heisman also picks 7-5 overall with no individual games
Lip Gallagher says probably 8 overall, no individual games
BYUAnime doesn't pick any games, except that Utah and UW are the toughest, but doesn't mention SDSU although he does think you guys should beat Boise
BleedCougarBlue2 says 8-4, no individual games

So of the people who actually pick the game, 5 pick BYU and 2 pick SDSU. Seven select BYU to win 8+ games, and it's hard to imagine one of the losses in that scenario is SDSU (at least, it's hard to imagine PREDICTING that at this point). Three pick 7-5 so maybe they're picking SDSU to win (or think that's more than possible). Even if you include all three of them as SDSU picks, it's 12-5 picking BYU.