My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 18, 2019
3:42
:36
pm
pilot17
Walk-on
Wow. This a very good list.
I agree with almost every ranking. I know people disagree with where you put Taysom and Riley but I think you got ‘em both in the right spots +/- a rank or two.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
pilot17
Bio page
pilot17
Joined
Nov 9, 2012
Last login
May 2, 2024
Total posts
700 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Top 25 BYU QB's ever
Dynasty1
8/18/19 2:07pm
Berry & enganann maybe??
idacoug
8/18/19 2:08pm
List is too long
Indy Coug
8/18/19 2:10pm
The guys outside the obvious top 15 or so need some love to
Dynasty1
8/18/19 2:14pm
That’s what makes it fun. We’ve done the top 10 thing lots already
JollyGreenGiant
8/18/19 4:04pm
Putting Riley over Zach is ridiculous. Even at this point in their careers.
SandYFan
8/18/19 2:10pm
Zach has a small sample size but will surely pass him up this year. Riley did
Dynasty1
8/18/19 2:11pm
Good Grief. Zach hasn't done anything yet
shakarocks
8/18/19 4:01pm
ZW is already twice the QB Nelson was
puntersarepeople
8/18/19 2:17pm
Beck should be ahead of Hall.
Captain Insano
8/18/19 2:18pm
This list isn't who the most talented is (otherwise Young would be #1) but who
Dynasty1
8/18/19 2:20pm
Beck was the better QB, without question.
SandYFan
8/18/19 2:22pm
His senior year. But I would argue Hall had a better four year career.
Soy Celeste
8/18/19 3:54pm
Max had a better career with a better team around him. Beck was the better QB. It’s easy to say, “Well Hall did great
mvtoro
8/18/19 7:05pm
If this, if that. Also, almost all of those guys you listed were underclassmen
Left Shark Coug
8/18/19 7:12pm
Exactly. Take away all of the circumstance, who they happened to play with, and how others contributed to wins/losses.
mvtoro
8/18/19 7:16pm
If that’s your criteria, than Detmer should be ahead of McMahon.
mvtoro
8/18/19 7:13pm
Yup
shakarocks
8/18/19 4:01pm
I’d move Doman into the top 10. Problem is he only had 1 season to start
Odysseus
8/18/19 2:22pm
<< Deleted >>
ataylor
8/18/19 2:35pm
Eldon Fortie was the first BYU first team All American. How can he not be
Bullrider
8/18/19 2:39pm
I thought Fortie was a RB?
LifeLongLakerFan
8/18/19 2:43pm
They called him a single wing qb. The snap from the center came to him.
Bullrider
8/18/19 2:47pm
He's kind of a tweener because his passing stats are basically non-existent
Dynasty1
8/18/19 2:59pm
14 is ranked way too high.
crazY
8/18/19 2:48pm
No way, that's one that I'm pretty confident that I got right. Nobody below him
Dynasty1
8/18/19 3:01pm
I think its a perfect spot.
Gerald-DeGroot
8/18/19 3:19pm
Christian Stewart is too low. I'd take him over anyone 15 and lower on that list.
SpiffCoug
8/18/19 3:05pm
Agreed- nuts that Christian Stewart rated below Mangum
nova_coug_fan
8/18/19 3:36pm
Mangum is the worst BYU QB in the history of the program as far as stats and W/L
Gerald-DeGroot
8/18/19 3:18pm
Mangum at least had wins vs Nebraska, Boise State, Arizona, and Wisconsin
BrutustheBrash
8/18/19 3:40pm
The defense and the running game carried him in those games.
SandYFan
8/18/19 3:42pm
But what memorable games did Heaps win?
BrutustheBrash
8/18/19 3:51pm
It’s a valid point.
Gerald-DeGroot
8/18/19 4:06pm
I'm not propping Heaps up.
SandYFan
8/18/19 7:36pm
Yup.
Gerald-DeGroot
8/18/19 4:05pm
True. I’d take Stewart over Mangum in a blink
JollyGreenGiant
8/18/19 4:02pm
Same.
Gerald-DeGroot
8/18/19 4:05pm
Taysom would’ve cracked the top 5 without the terrible injury luck.
messi
8/18/19 3:40pm
Wow. This a very good list.
pilot17
8/18/19 3:42pm
Zach cracks the top 10 before his career is through
icecougar
8/18/19 3:49pm
What??? No Bobby Jensen??!
icecougar
8/18/19 3:51pm
There are a lot of problems with this list
shakarocks
8/18/19 4:02pm
Go on......what would you have done different?
Dynasty1
8/18/19 4:58pm
Too low on the list: Sark, Hancock, Walsh, Hill, and ZW
Unibro
8/18/19 5:04pm
Who does Sark leapfrog?
BrutustheBrash
8/18/19 7:20pm
I’d have him ahead of Max and behind Beck
Unibro
8/18/19 11:48pm
heaps?
CougarLucas
8/18/19 6:19pm
Frankly, if we're including current QB's like ZW, I'd put Jaren Hall ahead of
jaba166
8/18/19 8:10pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad