It’s a valid point.

Report problem with this ad

Aug 18, 2019
4:06:21pm

Gerald-DeGroot All-American

It’s a valid point.

Report problem with this ad

Gerald-DeGroot

Previous username: GoCougarsKris
Bio page: Gerald-DeGroot
Joined: Jun 24, 2004
Last login: Feb 17, 2021
Total posts: 47,510 (2,199 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Top 25 BYU QB's ever

Dynasty1

8/18/19 2:07pm

Berry & enganann maybe??

idacoug

8/18/19 2:08pm

List is too long

Indy Coug

8/18/19 2:10pm

The guys outside the obvious top 15 or so need some love to

Dynasty1

8/18/19 2:14pm

That’s what makes it fun. We’ve done the top 10 thing lots already

JollyGreenGiant

8/18/19 4:04pm

Putting Riley over Zach is ridiculous. Even at this point in their careers.

SandYFan

8/18/19 2:10pm

Zach has a small sample size but will surely pass him up this year. Riley did

Dynasty1

8/18/19 2:11pm

Good Grief. Zach hasn't done anything yet

shakarocks

8/18/19 4:01pm

ZW is already twice the QB Nelson was

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 2:17pm

Beck should be ahead of Hall.

Captain Insano

8/18/19 2:18pm

This list isn't who the most talented is (otherwise Young would be #1) but who

Dynasty1

8/18/19 2:20pm

Beck was the better QB, without question.

SandYFan

8/18/19 2:22pm

His senior year. But I would argue Hall had a better four year career.

Soy Celeste

8/18/19 3:54pm

Max had a better career with a better team around him. Beck was the better QB. It’s easy to say, “Well Hall did great

mvtoro

8/18/19 7:05pm

If this, if that. Also, almost all of those guys you listed were underclassmen

Left Shark Coug

8/18/19 7:12pm

Exactly. Take away all of the circumstance, who they happened to play with, and how others contributed to wins/losses.

mvtoro

8/18/19 7:16pm

If that’s your criteria, than Detmer should be ahead of McMahon.

mvtoro

8/18/19 7:13pm

Yup

shakarocks

8/18/19 4:01pm

I’d move Doman into the top 10. Problem is he only had 1 season to start

Odysseus

8/18/19 2:22pm

<< Deleted >>

ataylor

8/18/19 2:35pm

Eldon Fortie was the first BYU first team All American. How can he not be

Bullrider

8/18/19 2:39pm

I thought Fortie was a RB?

LifeLongLakerFan

8/18/19 2:43pm

They called him a single wing qb. The snap from the center came to him.

Bullrider

8/18/19 2:47pm

He's kind of a tweener because his passing stats are basically non-existent

Dynasty1

8/18/19 2:59pm

14 is ranked way too high.

crazY

8/18/19 2:48pm

No way, that's one that I'm pretty confident that I got right. Nobody below him

Dynasty1

8/18/19 3:01pm

I think its a perfect spot.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/18/19 3:19pm

Christian Stewart is too low. I'd take him over anyone 15 and lower on that list.

SpiffCoug

8/18/19 3:05pm

Agreed- nuts that Christian Stewart rated below Mangum

nova_coug_fan

8/18/19 3:36pm

Mangum is the worst BYU QB in the history of the program as far as stats and W/L

Gerald-DeGroot

8/18/19 3:18pm

Mangum at least had wins vs Nebraska, Boise State, Arizona, and Wisconsin

BrutustheBrash

8/18/19 3:40pm

The defense and the running game carried him in those games.

SandYFan

8/18/19 3:42pm

But what memorable games did Heaps win?

BrutustheBrash

8/18/19 3:51pm

It’s a valid point.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/18/19 4:06pm

I'm not propping Heaps up.

SandYFan

8/18/19 7:36pm

Yup.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/18/19 4:05pm

True. I’d take Stewart over Mangum in a blink

JollyGreenGiant

8/18/19 4:02pm

Same.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/18/19 4:05pm

Taysom would’ve cracked the top 5 without the terrible injury luck.

messi

8/18/19 3:40pm

Wow. This a very good list.

pilot17

8/18/19 3:42pm

Zach cracks the top 10 before his career is through

icecougar

8/18/19 3:49pm

What??? No Bobby Jensen??!

icecougar

8/18/19 3:51pm

There are a lot of problems with this list

shakarocks

8/18/19 4:02pm

Go on......what would you have done different?

Dynasty1

8/18/19 4:58pm

Too low on the list: Sark, Hancock, Walsh, Hill, and ZW

Unibro

8/18/19 5:04pm

Who does Sark leapfrog?

BrutustheBrash

8/18/19 7:20pm

I’d have him ahead of Max and behind Beck

Unibro

8/18/19 11:48pm

heaps?

CougarLucas

8/18/19 6:19pm

Frankly, if we're including current QB's like ZW, I'd put Jaren Hall ahead of

jaba166

8/18/19 8:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad