Interesting that we all looked at the slo mo, and the thumbs up and down are split. Close.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 5, 2019
7:37:35am

No touching All-American

Report problem with this ad

No touching

Previous username: AlanF
Bio page: No touching
Joined: Dec 23, 2014
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 8,694 (96 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Ty’Son was in bounds.

the_byu_flash

9/4/19 7:17pm

We have to get neutral refs

Borg

9/4/19 7:21pm

1) that's not why it was missed. It's just a tough call. 2) NOONE gets

fattycoug

9/4/19 9:43pm

Visiting team supplies refs. BYU supplied them last year.

CallingDingo

9/4/19 11:10pm

These little misses are really starting to add up.

8man

9/4/19 7:21pm

P12 officiating

mudpupper

9/4/19 7:25pm

No kidding.

Benfica1

9/5/19 4:28pm

Why wouldn’t that have been reviewed?

BW84

9/4/19 7:23pm

Exactly. Don’t whistle the play dead. Look at review if it’s obviously so close.

Betruewhiteandblue

9/4/19 10:13pm

He was out. His foot lands inbounds but looks like it slides just into the chalk.

No touching

9/4/19 7:26pm

I think you are right

thebruce

9/4/19 7:29pm

It didn’t look like it (to me) on the slow mo

More of a Jazz Fan

9/4/19 7:39pm

Me neither. It didn't look like his foot slid at all.

BYUJoJo

9/4/19 9:02pm

Looks like there is always some green between foot and line.

Benfica1

9/5/19 4:29pm

That's incorrect.

Lip Gallagher

9/4/19 7:41pm

I'm not sure who is arguing his foot slid inward. In any case, it's close, and I don't think you can fault the ref.

No touching

9/4/19 7:46pm

Read that backwards. But he didn't go out either way. And no, you definitely

Lip Gallagher

9/4/19 7:50pm

I see green between his cleat and the sideline. Maybe only half an inch but its there...

icecougar

9/4/19 8:07pm

Nope. Inbounds.

YSMACK

9/4/19 9:01pm

This video intentionally doesn't show the other angles used in replays.

ToasterChive

9/4/19 9:32pm

Yup the other view showed he clearly stepped out

rggee

9/4/19 9:55pm

The other angles are likely wrong due to the angle

puntersarepeople

9/5/19 7:19am

Interesting that we all looked at the slo mo, and the thumbs up and down are split. Close.

No touching

9/5/19 7:37am

He's in. There is space between the line and foot.

Benfica1

9/5/19 8:00am

there are 100's of these incidents during every game. You could easily find holds, blocks in backs, targeting etc by

BlueFrog

9/4/19 7:28pm

True. The difference is that this call stopped a play from happening. It's one

SUAVO

9/4/19 7:43pm

blocks in backs...you mean like in Covey's 40 yd punt return?

icecougar

9/4/19 8:02pm

Yes, but I mean there's 100s of those a game right?

Grit for Brains

9/4/19 8:22pm

yep. if not more. every play there is a penalty somewhere that is going uncalled

BlueFrog

9/4/19 9:59pm

yep. for sure that was one that was missed

BlueFrog

9/4/19 9:58pm

This one was at a critical time, but I agree and it was about as close as

WizeGuise

9/4/19 8:16pm

This is why dissecting all these calls after the game is pretty and childish

Machiavelli

9/4/19 8:51pm

But you can't find incorrect in bounds and out of bounds calls. And when you ...

COACHdrn

9/4/19 9:03pm

Inbounds.

Cougarclaw

9/4/19 7:31pm

Don't think that does anything to change 2 pick 6's or giving up 8 yards per

Skeptical Optimist

9/4/19 7:32pm

Did he say that it did?

SUAVO

9/4/19 7:48pm

It does a ton. Sports is about momentum,if that play is called right BYU has 1st

palangi

9/4/19 9:33pm

We lost. The refs made some bad calls. Time to move on

DieHarder

9/4/19 7:32pm

nothing to move on to until we play the next game and get something new to...

icecougar

9/4/19 8:01pm

I can hardly wait

DieHarder

9/4/19 8:28pm

Hopefully it’s a win

puntersarepeople

9/4/19 9:03pm

Ty'Son should have gotten the ball on 3rd down either way... That is close

cougaman

9/4/19 7:35pm

Watch AFR they show this play from multiple angles, and it never was raised.

Sport sci

9/4/19 10:08pm

It looks like #20 had him stopped anyway

franklyvulgar

9/4/19 7:36pm

After the first

jaredm

9/4/19 7:39pm

Dang, we always lose to Utah unfairly. Every. time.

D.T. Survivor

9/4/19 9:03pm

The proof is in the video tapes. LOTS of bad calls when we play Utah.

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:42pm

Is that not a play that Sitake could have had reviewed?

Greg Kite's 'stache

9/4/19 9:07pm

We've unfortunately been saying this too many times the past few years.

COACHdrn

9/4/19 9:12pm

First coaches don't challenge for reviews. Second, out of bounds and the whistle

palangi

9/4/19 9:37pm

Coaches can challenge in college football. They get one, if they win it, they

fredgarvin

9/4/19 10:03pm

Didn’t the ESPN guys say the replay booth wasn’t PAC-12?

CallingDingo

9/4/19 9:12pm

That’s on the replay crew. Ridiculous that wasn’t looked at and overturned

jkccoug

9/4/19 9:36pm

Nothing to overturn, it was a running play not a catch, so whistle blows play

palangi

9/4/19 9:39pm

They showed another angle during the play and his toes were clearly out.

ochobeeguy

9/4/19 9:38pm

What better angle is there than straight down the sideline from in front of...

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:58pm

The one that zoomed in on the shoe and showed it on the line.

ochobeeguy

9/5/19 9:47am

We didn't lose because of the refs but every single questionable call went

Ash

9/4/19 9:58pm

Moss’ facemask was a joke.

CallingDingo

9/4/19 11:09pm

His stiff arm where he pulled the defenders facemask down? That was an easy call

palangi

9/4/19 11:45pm

But it was the first facemask called against a RB in the history of football.

ochobeeguy

9/5/19 9:52am

The rule requires twisting or pulling. A shove does not qualify

CallingDingo

9/5/19 4:14pm

Hence the word PULL in the post you just replied to.

cougaman

9/5/19 4:32pm

No pull. None whatsoever

CallingDingo

9/5/19 4:38pm

I see the defenders head jerk forward after he pulls his arm away. I can see why

cougaman

9/5/19 4:47pm

Actually, it was the correct call. He grabbed and pulled.

Benfica1

9/5/19 5:02pm

"In" bounds. End of discussion. Shafted again by the refs. If we had....

BleedCougarBlue2

9/4/19 10:57pm

The game is over, btw

qom

9/5/19 5:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad