Not sure what you mean by "maybe not the exact spot". The only way any wron spot

Sep 19, 2019
10:03:11pm

fattycoug All-American

Doesn't give them the first down is if it was actually shorter than they gave them. Any spot farther forward is a first down

Report problem with this ad

fattycoug

Bio page: fattycoug
Joined: Sep 9, 2002
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 69,511 (11,077 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Back to the USC game and refs- The call that bothered me the most

BigYfan

9/19/19 12:23pm

Bad spots happen. It’s on the coaches to ask for a replay

Fifty Shades of Blue

9/19/19 12:26pm

And they did and the refs still missed it.

basman

9/19/19 12:27pm

Eh, I feel that going for the first down was a bad coaching decision

Mattattack159

9/19/19 3:11pm

especially trying to run a play that needs an element of surprise to be effective...

icecougar

9/19/19 5:53pm

Plenty of things the coaches did wrong, without saying they were wrong for not

here's to hoping

9/19/19 4:38pm

The call that bothered me the most was the Pittman TD because he pulled Dayan down

Indy Coug

9/19/19 12:27pm

Objectively, there was enough hand fighting that it looked like Dayan caused him

RyneK

9/19/19 12:32pm

In the refs defense

A_blue_car

9/19/19 12:39pm

They also called it later in the game

cougaman

9/19/19 3:47pm

The thing I don’t understand about the play is why it was ruled a TD?

che flaco

9/19/19 12:52pm

Another ref came in and said he was forced out. Simple as that.

cougaman

9/19/19 3:48pm

My understanding is that by rule the ref must announce that there is no flag on

BYUCLA

9/19/19 5:40pm

But made a point to announce the Time out situation 2x on the 4th down.

pegushin

9/19/19 5:58pm

After re-watching the game, Pittman grabbed Dayan all game long.

firstclass

9/19/19 1:04pm

RE: Back to the USC game and refs- The call that bothered me the most

JuicyJam

9/19/19 12:28pm

On TV at least, this called looked like it was accurate. Maybe not the exact spot, but Dayan didn't look like he made it

TheLoneCougar

9/19/19 12:37pm

I didn't believe he got it, until I saw this:

RyneK

9/19/19 12:39pm

Wow good point, that angle makes it appear that he got it.

TheLoneCougar

9/19/19 12:46pm

It doesn't appear that way. It is that way.

RyneK

9/19/19 12:49pm

I don't think there was an angle that showed he didn't get it

BigYfan

9/19/19 2:40pm

Yeah, he got it

Pony Zale

9/19/19 12:51pm

That angle appears he got the first down by a yard at least

Remigius

9/19/19 1:18pm

Because of the idiot ref who had 8 players in his way starting with such a bad

cougaman

9/19/19 3:50pm

How is it definitive. You have no idea when his knee is down.

gww687

9/19/19 10:25pm

There is a shot from the skycam that helps. Looks like he made it.

oldrugger

9/19/19 3:54pm

Not sure what you mean by "maybe not the exact spot". The only way any wron spot

fattycoug

9/19/19 10:03pm

Meaning where they put the ball wasn't exactly where Dayan's forward progress led to.

TheLoneCougar

9/20/19 9:17am

Calls went both ways but missed because of a whistle

rexallenut

9/19/19 2:19pm

I thought CB - Ike had a really good explanation.

Mr Verde

9/19/19 2:31pm

I thought there were two bad misses.

bluegato

9/19/19 2:34pm

I’m more bothered that KS/JG thought they could actually get it

BYUHgrad

9/19/19 3:16pm

But the replay shows they got it

Remigius

9/19/19 4:33pm

A horrible or terrible shot that goes in

BYUHgrad

9/20/19 8:18pm

No one could see that ball or spot accurately. It was a crap shoot. Wish they

gww687

9/19/19 4:00pm

False.

RyneK

9/19/19 4:25pm

Do replay officials not have access to sky cam angle

Remigius

9/19/19 4:36pm

They have access. There is now way to tell when and if his knee goes down

gww687

9/19/19 10:26pm

They marked him at the six yard line

Remigius

9/20/19 7:08am

You are seeing what you want to see. Had the ball been spotted at the 6, it does

gww687

9/20/19 7:08pm

Maybe Dayans knee was down

NorthernCougFan

9/19/19 4:52pm

Maybe it was, but the point is the near-side ref spotted it 1.5 yards further

osbooks

9/19/19 5:02pm

because maybe he saw the knee down

icecougar

9/19/19 5:55pm

He had no view whatsoever of Dayan, the knee or the ball. The were a handful of

Posting on CougarBoard