On the Simon play, the PI was called against someone (Finau I believe) who threw

Nov 11, 2019
5:27:58pm

Jesse Pinkman All-American

a block more than five yards downfield while the ball was in the air. Watching the replay at the stadium, it seemed they got that call correct.

Report problem with this ad

Jesse Pinkman

Previous username: QuickCoug
Bio page: Jesse Pinkman
Joined: Feb 6, 2002
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 20,364 (36 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Regarding the two video booth reviews that went against BYU as "confirmed".

PJMort

11/11/19 4:21pm

I think ego plays too much into reviews. Some refs clearly can't admit they

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:24pm

Doesn't the NFL do this?

PJMort

11/11/19 4:26pm

Not that I know of.

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:27pm

The NBA does.

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:28pm

ESPN at least could do this for it's games.

PJMort

11/11/19 4:29pm

As I understand, the replay official makes the replay call, not the on-field

LifeLongLakerFan

11/11/19 4:33pm

Then I need a new reason why replay officials screw it up so bad.

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:54pm

Doesn't the NHL do this to some respects? Maybe it's just for goals?

Wear Blue

11/11/19 11:31pm

I was about to post this. The Micah Simon call wasn't even close.

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:29pm

What exactly can be reviewed?

Eddie

11/11/19 4:33pm

If they were looking for a tipped pass then they didn't understand the challenge

PJMort

11/11/19 4:40pm

And if that isn't reviewable, why not? Waay more objective than things like

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:46pm

No idea - I just remember that's what the ref said at the time.

Eddie

11/11/19 4:48pm

They addressed both. I went back and watched to get the exact quote...

StantonMac

11/11/19 9:25pm

They were wrong about the line of scrimmage.

PJMort

11/11/19 10:23pm

Also- the play before they called a strange snap infraction on Empey. Weird.

PJMort

11/11/19 11:38pm

It was very close. LOS was at, or just shy of the 41, which is

StantonMac

11/12/19 12:42am

I’ve rewatched it several times. Catch was made at 20 1/2 yard line.

PJMort

11/12/19 12:57am

Agree that “confirmed” was a stretch.

StantonMac

11/12/19 8:36am

It was like they didn't understand the difference between "stands" & "confirmed"

jcase16byu

11/12/19 2:32pm

What was the end result on both those drives? I forget.

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 4:48pm

They were both on 3rd down. BYU kicked a field goal on one, and punted the other

PJMort

11/11/19 4:53pm

Then that is very frustrating (assuming the OP is right).

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 5:08pm

Where were those refs from? Lots of holding from LU never called

Coug Dude

11/11/19 4:57pm

Lots of holding by BYU went uncalled as well. Freeland was a holding machine

Jesse Pinkman

11/11/19 5:25pm

If a tree falls in the forest...

Chickendance

11/12/19 8:22am

American conference

Rat

11/11/19 6:34pm

On the Simon play, the PI was called against someone (Finau I believe) who threw

Jesse Pinkman

11/11/19 5:27pm

You can do that if the receiver catches the ball behind the LOS

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 5:34pm

It is my understanding that downfield blocking is ok IF pass is behind the LOS.

PJMort

11/11/19 5:35pm

The rule is no PI unless the passed ball "crosses the neutral zone"

jkccoug

11/11/19 5:51pm

It definitely was NOT Offensive PI then. Maybe it was not reviewable though.

PJMort

11/11/19 6:00pm

I don't think that is right. If the pass is behind the LOS you can block downfi

oldrugger

11/11/19 9:27pm

Also, how many times did they put time back

buckweave

11/11/19 5:45pm

I will continue to advocate that all refs be brought under the NCAA tent. Let

ImuaKahuku

11/12/19 6:03am

except that nobody trusts the NCAA to not screw it up.

Squeegee

11/12/19 10:19am

I thought Milne did not catch it clean. Not necessarily a bobble...but not clean

Tweege

11/12/19 7:07am

Dax Milne just used poor technique. You never pick up your feet to stay upright

StalwartBraveTrue

11/12/19 12:08pm

<< Deleted >>

Doofer13

11/12/19 7:21pm

And he DID catch it and DID get his right toe down. Am I wrong? I don't think so

PJMort

11/12/19 7:27pm

It being tipped is news to me. Looked like he caught it clean.

StalwartBraveTrue

11/12/19 11:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad