If a tree falls in the forest...

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2019
8:22:10am

Chickendance Walk-on

And no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 12, 2019 at 8:22:10am

Message modified by Chickendance on Nov 12, 2019 at 8:33:30am

Report problem with this ad

Chickendance

Bio page: Chickendance
Joined: Jun 16, 2019
Last login: Dec 12, 2023
Total posts: 13 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Regarding the two video booth reviews that went against BYU as "confirmed".

PJMort

11/11/19 4:21pm

I think ego plays too much into reviews. Some refs clearly can't admit they

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:24pm

Doesn't the NFL do this?

PJMort

11/11/19 4:26pm

Not that I know of.

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:27pm

The NBA does.

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:28pm

ESPN at least could do this for it's games.

PJMort

11/11/19 4:29pm

As I understand, the replay official makes the replay call, not the on-field

LifeLongLakerFan

11/11/19 4:33pm

Then I need a new reason why replay officials screw it up so bad.

SandYFan

11/11/19 4:54pm

Doesn't the NHL do this to some respects? Maybe it's just for goals?

Wear Blue

11/11/19 11:31pm

I was about to post this. The Micah Simon call wasn't even close.

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:29pm

What exactly can be reviewed?

Eddie

11/11/19 4:33pm

If they were looking for a tipped pass then they didn't understand the challenge

PJMort

11/11/19 4:40pm

And if that isn't reviewable, why not? Waay more objective than things like

jkccoug

11/11/19 4:46pm

No idea - I just remember that's what the ref said at the time.

Eddie

11/11/19 4:48pm

They addressed both. I went back and watched to get the exact quote...

StantonMac

11/11/19 9:25pm

They were wrong about the line of scrimmage.

PJMort

11/11/19 10:23pm

Also- the play before they called a strange snap infraction on Empey. Weird.

PJMort

11/11/19 11:38pm

It was very close. LOS was at, or just shy of the 41, which is

StantonMac

11/12/19 12:42am

I’ve rewatched it several times. Catch was made at 20 1/2 yard line.

PJMort

11/12/19 12:57am

Agree that “confirmed” was a stretch.

StantonMac

11/12/19 8:36am

It was like they didn't understand the difference between "stands" & "confirmed"

jcase16byu

11/12/19 2:32pm

What was the end result on both those drives? I forget.

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 4:48pm

They were both on 3rd down. BYU kicked a field goal on one, and punted the other

PJMort

11/11/19 4:53pm

Then that is very frustrating (assuming the OP is right).

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 5:08pm

Where were those refs from? Lots of holding from LU never called

Coug Dude

11/11/19 4:57pm

Lots of holding by BYU went uncalled as well. Freeland was a holding machine

Jesse Pinkman

11/11/19 5:25pm

If a tree falls in the forest...

Chickendance

11/12/19 8:22am

American conference

Rat

11/11/19 6:34pm

On the Simon play, the PI was called against someone (Finau I believe) who threw

Jesse Pinkman

11/11/19 5:27pm

You can do that if the receiver catches the ball behind the LOS

The Y's Insider

11/11/19 5:34pm

It is my understanding that downfield blocking is ok IF pass is behind the LOS.

PJMort

11/11/19 5:35pm

The rule is no PI unless the passed ball "crosses the neutral zone"

jkccoug

11/11/19 5:51pm

It definitely was NOT Offensive PI then. Maybe it was not reviewable though.

PJMort

11/11/19 6:00pm

I don't think that is right. If the pass is behind the LOS you can block downfi

oldrugger

11/11/19 9:27pm

Also, how many times did they put time back

buckweave

11/11/19 5:45pm

I will continue to advocate that all refs be brought under the NCAA tent. Let

ImuaKahuku

11/12/19 6:03am

except that nobody trusts the NCAA to not screw it up.

Squeegee

11/12/19 10:19am

I thought Milne did not catch it clean. Not necessarily a bobble...but not clean

Tweege

11/12/19 7:07am

Dax Milne just used poor technique. You never pick up your feet to stay upright

StalwartBraveTrue

11/12/19 12:08pm

<< Deleted >>

Doofer13

11/12/19 7:21pm

And he DID catch it and DID get his right toe down. Am I wrong? I don't think so

PJMort

11/12/19 7:27pm

It being tipped is news to me. Looked like he caught it clean.

StalwartBraveTrue

11/12/19 11:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad