Very very few can outperform index funds over the long haul.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 25, 2020
2:10:34pm

Ozymandias All-American

Very very few can outperform index funds over the long haul.

Report problem with this ad

Ozymandias

Previous username: imanihonjin
Bio page: Ozymandias
Joined: Oct 9, 2006
Last login: May 6, 2024
Total posts: 28,172 (1,279 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Continue with Vanguard mutual funds or go back to American Funds?

byuguns55

1/25/20 12:50pm

What funds? Why was it bad advice?

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 12:53pm

I have their retirement target 2040 fund and Wellesley, and not bad advice

byuguns55

1/25/20 12:58pm

Then choose different funds at Vanguard.

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 1:10pm

That's good advice...which I've heard before...just needed to hear it again

byuguns55

1/25/20 1:11pm

It is hard to believe that with all of the options available at Vanguard that

Ozymandias

1/25/20 12:53pm

what would you recommend at Vanguard that is similar to AF's Growth Fund or

byuguns55

1/25/20 12:59pm

Take a look at VASGX. Is that similar to what you have with AF?

mottman

1/25/20 1:06pm

Seems like what I'm looking for...thanks!

byuguns55

1/25/20 1:10pm

Your asset allocation seems pretty different given your examples.

Blue Cat

1/25/20 1:26pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

1/25/20 12:56pm

Exactly. If you’re worried about what happened last year, you are worrying about the wrong thing.

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 12:57pm

just the last 2-3 years, but I get your point

byuguns55

1/25/20 12:59pm

20-30 years is what matters.

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 1:10pm

DFA funds, with tilts towards dimensions of higher expected returns, outperform index funds in the long term.

RdF3

1/25/20 1:23pm

That’s actually not a true statement.

BYU_Hoops

1/25/20 1:55pm

People act like it's impossible to pick stocks. It's done successfully every day

1/25/20 2:03pm

Very very few can outperform index funds over the long haul.

Ozymandias

1/25/20 2:10pm

Yeah but not by the same person everyday. Especially over the long term. But please keep stock picking and trading.

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 2:15pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

1/25/20 3:10pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

1/25/20 3:04pm

My financial advisor is having us move some things from American Funds to Polen Capital

TwinsRight

1/25/20 1:00pm

He probably needs some turn over transaction fees.

kotacoug

1/25/20 2:06pm

Exactly. He’s a commissioned salesman, not a financial advisor.

Mr. Belding

1/25/20 2:15pm

Do you think the advice is bad? Or is it how he gets paid that you don’t like?

TwinsRight

1/25/20 5:14pm

It is the moral hazard that is created based on how he gets paid.

Ozymandias

1/25/20 5:21pm

I hate American Funds. My company uses them for our 401k, but I have all of my

1/25/20 1:02pm

I'll see your CS and tell you to look into Vanguard

byuguns55

1/25/20 1:05pm

Didn’t this thread start with you asking if you should leave Vanguard?? LOL

KSwiss

1/25/20 10:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad