Funny... same excuse used against BYU when they suck! Which is it?

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Feb 23, 2020
4:12:57pm

jpal1397 All-American

Funny... same excuse used against BYU when they suck! Which is it?

Some don’t go on missions and some who do (Zac Seljaas) never refined his game once he came back. Married with children is an advantage in college? Why don’t more kids do it then? Mix school, practice, games, finals, wife time, and up all night with an infant and that produces the best outcome for a RM? Seriously?

Report problem with this ad

jpal1397

Bio page: jpal1397
Joined: Aug 1, 2002
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 9,430 (221 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU age/maturity advantage due to missions, if you think it's not an advantage

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:47pm

You're right. Teams should send their players into the peace corp for 2 years.

2/23/20 2:49pm

They should, so long as they can play ball every morning for an hour or so

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:52pm

missionaries aren't playing ball every day. Some even rarely do rarely

fattycoug

2/23/20 2:56pm

Even if they did play every day which obviously they don’t,

The Dude Abides

2/23/20 3:15pm

We all know you’re a lair now. So go away. We don’t mind banter but if youre

SouthernBlueBlood

2/23/20 2:58pm

How did I diminish the two years of service? Missionaries are encouraged to stay

salamishitake

2/23/20 4:08pm

Served in Utah?

Bin01015

2/23/20 6:08pm

<< Deleted >>

jes2332

2/23/20 3:01pm

Played basketball like 3-5 times my entire mission.

Bin01015

2/23/20 3:01pm

Who are these 25 year old seniors you speak of?

jes2332

2/23/20 3:02pm

Lol. You are so full of crap. You're making stuff up

shimmy

2/23/20 9:53pm

IF IT WAS SUCH AN ADVANTAGE...

BYU4eVeR

2/23/20 2:49pm

Nah, the elite teams are cool just leaving advantages lying around untapped.

Mitty

2/24/20 7:02pm

If a mission was an advantage, other schools would make their athletes go.

idcougarfan

2/23/20 2:50pm

I don’t think it’s an advantage for most sports/positions (linemen may be the

Scratch

2/23/20 2:52pm

A player that redshirts, gets another year due to medical stuff

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:57pm

27 years old? How long do you think 2 years is?

Alpi Gusto

2/23/20 3:10pm

And the same scenario leads to a 25 year old player non rm. Big whoop

LiveCoug

2/23/20 6:32pm

Which seniors have redshirted in any way? 23 for a RM senior.

ochobeeguy

2/23/20 6:45pm

Ah- clearly you’re not a return missionary

SouthernBlueBlood

2/23/20 2:51pm

LOL, dudes on my mission played every day, and I went to a developing country

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:53pm

Now you’re making me mad because either you’re a liar or you went to a mission

SouthernBlueBlood

2/23/20 2:55pm

the Zags??? This doesn't have anything to do with them

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:06pm

Haha most missionaries won’t get up at 6:30 like they are supposed to. Yet you

The Dude Abides

2/23/20 3:31pm

Hmmm doesn’t sound like missions I’m familiar with. Ball every day? Nah

BYUfan92

2/23/20 2:59pm

My companions and I absolutely did. Every morning

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:15pm

Then you were a bad missionary

Beggar

2/23/20 3:54pm

Cool. So they shot some hoops. Not nearly the kind of reps

2/23/20 5:00pm

So you also are buddies with a lot of former BYU players?

No touching

2/23/20 6:17pm

It’s a special mission where all college basketball players get assigned

SouthernBlueBlood

2/23/20 6:24pm

It's just a shame they can't have them practice as they do at BYU. Though evidently it's pretty close to that level.

No touching

2/23/20 6:45pm

Which mission where you in, and what years?

BYUfan92

2/23/20 6:58pm

Crickets lol

rggee

2/23/20 8:59pm

Yeah......nope

rggee

2/23/20 3:06pm

Ha, what a liar

vegas guey

2/23/20 3:08pm

Where? My sons are in central and South America and have played bball a handful

BYU Grounds

2/23/20 3:15pm

Doubling down, huh?

svenot

2/23/20 3:38pm

<< Deleted >>

Odysseus

2/23/20 2:52pm

Lol. You just compared an RM 23 year old to NBA players with multiple years

LiveCoug

2/23/20 2:53pm

No I didn't, or at least that wasn't my intention

salamishitake

2/23/20 4:04pm

You need to compare 24 to 22. Not 24/25/26 to 19 and early 20.

LiveCoug

2/23/20 4:44pm

But 24 year old lebron didn’t take 2 years off of bball

2/23/20 5:02pm

RE: BYU age/maturity advantage due to missions, if you think it's not an

Squeegee

2/23/20 2:53pm

Yeah I never get comments like these.

Bell of the Ball

2/23/20 2:53pm

their bodies are drastically different

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:55pm

In a business where you are past your prime at 35 a year is HUGE

Bell of the Ball

2/23/20 2:57pm

you are kind of proving my point there

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:10pm

RE: you are kind of proving my point there

Bell of the Ball

2/23/20 3:20pm

I disagree ... those mission years is where college athletes develop the most.

Avery

2/23/20 2:54pm

Yoeli is 22, Seljaas is 22, Toolson is 23, Haws is 24

jes2332

2/23/20 2:55pm

Tillie is 22 next week. Gilder is 24. Woolridge is 23

LiveCoug

2/23/20 2:58pm

Kispert is 21 next week

LiveCoug

2/23/20 3:00pm

Which player falls in that category: Yoeli? Jake? Zach?

BYU'01

2/23/20 2:57pm

it absolutely helps to have those guys in college basketball

salamishitake

2/23/20 2:59pm

You’re lost was about RM’s now you’re talking seniors without missions. Which

SouthernBlueBlood

2/23/20 3:03pm

Nice circular logic

BYU'01

2/23/20 4:10pm

who says I broke mission rules?

salamishitake

2/23/20 4:21pm

Sometimes it’s an advantage, sure.

shimmy

2/23/20 2:57pm

that's all I'm saying

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:33pm

Probably you should go back and read your OP, because that's not all you're saying.

No touching

2/23/20 3:55pm

nah. you went beyond

shimmy

2/23/20 7:09pm

Ask Pope, Sitake, Rose, Bronco, etc if they would would prefer continuity over

bluesloth

2/23/20 2:59pm

Logistically it is absolutely a problem for coaches

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:03pm

They recruit RMs because we primarily recruit LDS players and a lot of them

bluesloth

2/23/20 3:05pm

Dude you’re a Utah fan, you have nothing to contribute here

cougfan03

2/23/20 3:01pm

I'm a Utah fan so I don't get to have opinions about stuff?

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:05pm

Of course you get to have opinions. And your wrong opinions will be contested

LiveCoug

2/23/20 3:05pm

which is just fine, but that isn't what coufan03 did

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:09pm

No, he said nothing HERE. On CougarBoard, not Uteboard.

Squeegee

2/23/20 3:10pm

Did you try posting that riveting take on your own little site?

vegas guey

2/23/20 3:12pm

Your season is over, why do you care about BYU basketball?

cougfan03

2/23/20 3:53pm

Um no

BYU Grounds

2/23/20 3:36pm

I love how it’s only an advantage when BYU is successful.

che flaco

2/23/20 3:09pm

Everyone has access to this "advantage", so it's not an advantage

The Dark Knight

2/23/20 3:09pm

I'm not whining about BYU having an unfair advantage

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:11pm

That's like saying "practicing three pointers is an advantage"

The Dark Knight

2/23/20 4:53pm

I thought your username was salami sh!t take at first, would be fitting.

fldnstrm

2/23/20 3:09pm

Nah, it's just a play on announcers pronouncing Kalani's name so horribly wrong

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:12pm

Glad to see this post not deleted. Ive been suspended for less.

Rooney

2/24/20 3:14am

Board name checks out (the last two syllables).

COACHdrn

2/23/20 3:11pm

Out of our starting 5-6 (only Haws served for 2 years) your argument doesn’t

BYUFootballisBack

2/23/20 3:12pm

that's absolutely true for this year's team

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:16pm

So what years team then? Because we’ve sucked for a long time...

2/23/20 5:04pm

Change your tag line to “anyone who doesn’t think it’s an advantage to have a

BYUFootballisBack

2/23/20 3:17pm

Now that I can agree with. But the mission adds nothing to that argument.

BYUHawk

2/23/20 3:20pm

BOOM! ROASTED

2/23/20 5:04pm

I love it when these complaints resurface. It means BYU is good again.

GRCoug

2/23/20 3:13pm

I'm not complaining about anything

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:15pm

You still haven’t answered who the 25, 26 year old players are

jes2332

2/23/20 3:18pm

This year? You are absolutely right

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:57pm

This is in the basketball category and we are clearly talking about basketball

jes2332

2/23/20 4:32pm

I hope it's a huge advantage.

Belboz

2/23/20 3:18pm

Ute trolls gonna troll. Surprised mods let you get away with that board name.

Lieutenant America

2/23/20 3:20pm

of course we do, nobody is claiming that it's unfair, or that it shouldn't be

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:34pm

GO!!!!!!

LDTemplar

2/24/20 12:58pm

How’s that worked out for FB? Worst take of the year so far.

2/23/20 3:21pm

It made big difference for me in my athletic career.

zephyr

2/23/20 3:22pm

RE: BYU age/maturity advantage due to missions, if you think it's not an

cougman02

2/23/20 3:31pm

I am a usc fan and booster, and recently a BYU fan because my son is a student

cougman02

2/23/20 3:34pm

Thank your son for choosing BYU. Thank you for supporting him.

idcougarfan

2/23/20 4:25pm

THIS. So much this. Thank you for your perspective. And we are glad to have your

2/23/20 5:09pm

Eric Mika wouldn't have left after his So. year if it wasn't for his mission

ayfan

2/23/20 3:37pm

absolutely, I'm not arguing that it's better for their long term pro careers

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:53pm

There have got to be at least a dozen examples of BYU players whose careers were

che flaco

2/23/20 3:40pm

I can agree with that, I'm not claiming it's better for everyone

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:54pm

Dumb. Just dumb. And insanely wrong.

Yohy

2/23/20 3:44pm

RE: BYU age/maturity advantage due to missions, if you think it's not an

eddog

2/23/20 3:48pm

I served a mission in Europe and played a total of 3 times. I would have played every week if it had been possible, but

No touching

2/23/20 3:49pm

This is one of the worst takes this board has ever seen.

crazY

2/23/20 3:54pm

Nobody is claiming that serving a mission gives you an athletic advantage

salamishitake

2/23/20 3:56pm

That isn't that much considering the ages. Plus mental and physical toughness in

cougman02

2/23/20 4:09pm

Two years of extra maturing do provide an advantage

salamishitake

2/23/20 4:22pm

No matter how many times you try to frame it, missions do not provide an

crazY

2/23/20 5:18pm

This might be the best argument. Looking at all of BYU’s best players in fb and

2/23/20 5:05pm

It’s especially true in Yoeli’s case.

Brisco

2/23/20 4:05pm

Funny... same excuse used against BYU when they suck! Which is it?

jpal1397

2/23/20 4:12pm

yeah, that's not the argument I am making

salamishitake

2/23/20 4:24pm

There are all types of advantages in college sports

Housemartin

2/23/20 4:25pm

So why have we been average or below average the last 9 years?

Traveshamockery

2/23/20 4:26pm

Then why do so many schools tell recruits they don’t want them to serve missions

2/23/20 4:53pm

Who is 24 let alone 25 or 26?

ochobeeguy

2/23/20 6:39pm

Very few of the greats that have come through our BBall and FBall programs

chazen

2/24/20 11:25am

Go away, yewt!

LDTemplar

2/24/20 12:50pm

Missions do not help maintain muscle, endurance, or athleticism.

MajorZeus

2/24/20 1:21pm

Your post shows you have no idea what you're talking about.

jdub

2/24/20 3:40pm

Funny how Gonzaga didn’t mention the mission thing when they beat us by 25

jpal1397

2/24/20 10:14pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad