People here actually still believe Kalani has a higher ceiling despite having a

Report problem with this ad

Apr 8, 2020
3:48:11pm

Mr. Scoobs All-American

worse AVERAGE finish than Bronco's FLOOR. Bar hasn't been this low at BYU in 4+ decades.

Report problem with this ad

Mr. Scoobs

Previous username: Alm
Bio page: Mr. Scoobs
Joined: Sep 8, 2011
Last login: Apr 26, 2024
Total posts: 12,051 (184 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Ok- time for a controversial post.

PJMort

4/8/20 3:44pm

People here actually still believe Kalani has a higher ceiling despite having a

Mr. Scoobs

4/8/20 3:48pm

Bronco's floor was 6 wins at BYU, so a technically false statement

donnerstag

4/8/20 3:51pm

2005 finish=55. 2016-2019 finishes = 36, 112, 63, 67.

Mr. Scoobs

4/8/20 3:55pm

There were also 11 less FBS teams in 2005

donnerstag

4/8/20 4:33pm

Fans will never be the experts at objective comparisons.

Mr. Scoobs

4/8/20 4:39pm

That’s true..... Kalani got an extension after mediocrity

wilsdad

4/8/20 7:47pm

Who thinks that? I think KS is in way over his head and the program's tanking

Lifi

4/8/20 4:40pm

Sad face because it looks to be true.

ArcticKat

4/8/20 5:24pm

Silly.

Beetdiggercoug

4/8/20 6:37pm

Doesn’t KS have 2 previous HCs in his staff? He’s not over his head

Pretorian

4/9/20 5:41am

And with all that HC experience we still got Toledo and Hawaii?

ArcticKat

4/9/20 8:25am

Just because kilane is a terrible doesn't mean Bronco was good.

TheWoodman

4/9/20 6:28am

Have you noticed what Bronco has done at UVA?

Pretorian

4/9/20 8:02am

While Bronco is a very good coach, I think it was time for him to move on

mudpupper

4/8/20 3:51pm

Oh, nice dodge padawan- did you think BYU needed a new/better coach?

PJMort

4/8/20 3:57pm

I did. I'll own it. Bronco is fine, and if he's the best we can ever hope to do,

SandYFan

4/8/20 4:02pm

He’s not and it’s not even debatable. LaVell Edwards was.

ataylor

4/8/20 4:05pm

I mean for the future. I've been repeatedly told that Bronco is the best we

SandYFan

4/8/20 4:13pm

If your coach is winning 9-10 games per year, forcing him out is a bad idea.

PJMort

4/8/20 4:14pm

Well, 8-9 is more accurate. And the talent he was recruiting was consistently

SandYFan

4/8/20 4:16pm

And yet he still won 8-9 games with that "declining" talent.

TheLoneCougar

4/8/20 4:19pm

And zero special seasons since 2009. I would like more.

SandYFan

4/8/20 4:24pm

KS hasn't provided ANY special seasons thus far. Bronco is lightyears ahead of KS, but I think this is more a BYU issue.

TheLoneCougar

4/9/20 7:33am

Problem is most are not equally demanding of Kalani.

Mr. Scoobs

4/8/20 4:20pm

Like I said- those people should sit this one out.

PJMort

4/8/20 4:24pm

Some people get it.

Goatnapper'96

4/8/20 4:27pm

How some were discontent with Bronco yet somehow we apologize for Kalani

mudpupper

4/8/20 7:24pm

Bronco got owned in the rivalry game

MarylandFan

4/9/20 5:59am

Bronco is a Taysom hill injury (or two) away from the special season everyone

Pretorian

4/9/20 5:46am

Same story for many teams years in year out

MarylandFan

4/9/20 6:01am

What matters more than what I thought is Bronco thought BYU needed a new coach.

Art Director

4/9/20 9:46am

They didn’t knock the ball out of the park but blundered?

Pretorian

4/9/20 5:43am

Annnnnd.......?

Borg

4/8/20 4:02pm

That’s all. 😉

PJMort

4/8/20 4:08pm

That's not how that works. I wanted Bronco gone, and I never thought the next

SandYFan

4/8/20 5:04pm

Nope. You were wrong. Sorry. Flagrant 2. You must go sunbathe like Jake at Pepp.

PJMort

4/8/20 5:38pm

<< Deleted >>

Gerald-DeGroot

4/8/20 6:01pm

It was time for Bronco to move on. He has proven he’s a good coach though.

Gerald-DeGroot

4/8/20 6:03pm

Bronco needed to leave, but mant of us didn't want Sitake. Proving we are good

oldrugger

4/8/20 6:39pm

RE: Bronco needed to leave, but mant of us didn't want Sitake. Proving we are

africacoug

4/8/20 6:54pm

Lol....exactly!!!

Ygrad

4/8/20 8:03pm

Never saw a good candidate, but a new staff, none of which had ever coaches the

oldrugger

4/9/20 1:25am

It doesn't prove anything unless you can prove who you did want was actually

Lip Gallagher

4/8/20 10:27pm

i didn't want Bronco to go but I am sure he was sick of the fans that were ...

BYU Grounds

4/8/20 7:12pm

i really liked Bronco

kiyoshige

4/8/20 7:28pm

I am dumb who is DS?

BYU Grounds

4/8/20 7:36pm

Derik Stevenson

kiyoshige

4/8/20 7:44pm

Hopefully you're joking about DS

kooogar

4/8/20 8:25pm

Spot on mort!! Sit out on coaching comments, period!

Ygrad

4/8/20 8:05pm

PJMort to 1/2 of CB:

Coug Man in Florida

4/8/20 8:52pm

I never wanted to move on from Bronco, and I am very skeptical of this coaching

cougaman

4/8/20 9:02pm

Agreed, never wanted Bronco gone either, but not a fan of current coaches.

here's to hoping

4/9/20 7:58am

I was ok with Bronco leaving on his own, which he did. I didn't Kalani near the top of any list to replace Bronco.

SpiffCoug

4/8/20 9:05pm

Nice to have an occasional post from the silent majority. Thank you

MaxxPower

4/8/20 10:14pm

I doubt that the "silent majority" is enamored with the worst coach in 50 years

reddead

4/9/20 9:00am

Were you born in 2005?

Lip Gallagher

4/9/20 10:05am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

4/8/20 11:00pm

Same goes for the Tanner over Taysom whiners. Their QB opinion is invalid.

dYrtbYkerYder

4/8/20 11:04pm

How many of you thought we would never be able to hire a good coach again in Bball?

HighHorse

4/9/20 6:18am

Good point. Make Pope the football coach.

ArcticKat

4/9/20 8:23am

What about those of us who wanted Bronco gone, but didn't want Sitake?

reddead

4/9/20 8:57am

How some CBers react when faced with clear facts that they were wrong.

PJMort

4/9/20 12:08pm

Sorry, but it’s not a binary world. There are more than two coaches out there

zerome4sooners

4/9/20 2:34pm

Again, who did you want instead?

Posting on CougarBoard