Only Sarkisian and Beck are listed as All-Americans after Detmer on BYU's

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 20, 2020
11:12:45am

cougarfan84 All-American

Only Sarkisian and Beck are listed as All-Americans after Detmer on BYU's

website. But neither of them were consensus All-American like Detmer, Young, McMahon.

Report problem with this ad

cougarfan84

Bio page: cougarfan84
Joined: Apr 3, 2003
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 19,211 (2,485 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Quarterback U

spidey24

10/20/20 11:07am

How many of those were first team All-Americans?

Indy Coug

10/20/20 11:09am

Only Sarkisian and Beck are listed as All-Americans after Detmer on BYU's

cougarfan84

10/20/20 11:12am

Lack of national awards. Post detmer we had a lot of good QBs

RalphWiggam

10/20/20 11:10am

Yeah, but Taysom deserves to be on the list

Avery

10/20/20 11:15am

Too much injury time

WallaX2

10/20/20 11:23am

Sark was an o'Brien Finalist, but not a winner.

spidey24

10/20/20 11:41am

Were any of them heisman finalists or winners of any major awards

robin

10/20/20 11:10am

It’s more that the QBs between Neilson and Detmer built the QBU reputation.

Samsonite

10/20/20 11:11am

Beck & Hall had the unfortunate timing of playing on the abyss of the mtn

NOCAL_YFAN

10/20/20 11:12am

RE: Quarterback U

spidey24

10/20/20 11:33am

It bugs me although I understand why they don’t

10/20/20 11:34am

Why is Gary Sheide never mentioned? Sammy Baugh trophy winner

SlantRoute

10/20/20 11:48am

Gary Sheide was no slouch. I've read that he broke the ground for Neilsen. Mean-

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:05pm

Or Virgil Carter for that matter?

SlantRoute

10/20/20 11:49am

For those who may not remember Virgil Carter

dratax

10/20/20 4:22pm

Think the primary factor is length of NFL career, IMO.

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:02pm

<< Deleted >>

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:04pm

Gary was #7 in Heisman voting in 1974. Not shabby at all.

SlantRoute

10/20/20 12:05pm

Mark Wilson was also in the NFL

mncstr

10/20/20 1:07pm

I loved Marc Wilson

schofim

10/20/20 1:17pm

Right after my mission, I worked in a call center with McMahon's mom

mncstr

10/20/20 1:23pm

Only Lavell could've pulled that off and kept both QBs

icecougar

10/20/20 11:29pm

I was a little surprised when that happened

schofim

10/21/20 8:46am

...and was a 1st round pick

icecougar

10/20/20 11:27pm

As I recall, Taysom was a heisman candidate before he got injured 🙂

Hill4Heisman

10/20/20 1:08pm

NFL glory, National Championship, Heisman winner are triggers for that lineup

10/20/20 1:22pm

The BYU QB package needs to become a set of 6 2-ups

The Chelsea Dagger

10/20/20 1:24pm

I'd add Taysom since he's currently in the NFL

mncstr

10/20/20 1:29pm

Not to mention Virgil Carter who started for the Eagles, and Gary Sheide.

oldrugger

10/20/20 2:30pm

Ummm, he never played for the Eagles. Did you mean the Bengals?

BYUforlife

10/20/20 3:48pm

Also Mark Wilson.

oldrugger

10/20/20 2:30pm

Are they known?

cantwearred

10/20/20 2:47pm

I would agree. I think anyone interested in football knows Sark and Hill

spidey24

10/20/20 4:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad