Why is Gary Sheide never mentioned? Sammy Baugh trophy winner

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 20, 2020
11:48:14am

SlantRoute Original Gangster

Why is Gary Sheide never mentioned? Sammy Baugh trophy winner

Report problem with this ad

SlantRoute

Previous username: truecoug1
Bio page: SlantRoute
Joined: Jan 31, 2008
Last login: Feb 21, 2024
Total posts: 18,188 (87 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Quarterback U

spidey24

10/20/20 11:07am

How many of those were first team All-Americans?

Indy Coug

10/20/20 11:09am

Only Sarkisian and Beck are listed as All-Americans after Detmer on BYU's

cougarfan84

10/20/20 11:12am

Lack of national awards. Post detmer we had a lot of good QBs

RalphWiggam

10/20/20 11:10am

Yeah, but Taysom deserves to be on the list

Avery

10/20/20 11:15am

Too much injury time

WallaX2

10/20/20 11:23am

Sark was an o'Brien Finalist, but not a winner.

spidey24

10/20/20 11:41am

Were any of them heisman finalists or winners of any major awards

robin

10/20/20 11:10am

It’s more that the QBs between Neilson and Detmer built the QBU reputation.

Samsonite

10/20/20 11:11am

Beck & Hall had the unfortunate timing of playing on the abyss of the mtn

NOCAL_YFAN

10/20/20 11:12am

RE: Quarterback U

spidey24

10/20/20 11:33am

It bugs me although I understand why they don’t

10/20/20 11:34am

Why is Gary Sheide never mentioned? Sammy Baugh trophy winner

SlantRoute

10/20/20 11:48am

Gary Sheide was no slouch. I've read that he broke the ground for Neilsen. Mean-

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:05pm

Or Virgil Carter for that matter?

SlantRoute

10/20/20 11:49am

For those who may not remember Virgil Carter

dratax

10/20/20 4:22pm

Think the primary factor is length of NFL career, IMO.

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:02pm

<< Deleted >>

BleedCougarBlue2

10/20/20 12:04pm

Gary was #7 in Heisman voting in 1974. Not shabby at all.

SlantRoute

10/20/20 12:05pm

Mark Wilson was also in the NFL

mncstr

10/20/20 1:07pm

I loved Marc Wilson

schofim

10/20/20 1:17pm

Right after my mission, I worked in a call center with McMahon's mom

mncstr

10/20/20 1:23pm

Only Lavell could've pulled that off and kept both QBs

icecougar

10/20/20 11:29pm

I was a little surprised when that happened

schofim

10/21/20 8:46am

...and was a 1st round pick

icecougar

10/20/20 11:27pm

As I recall, Taysom was a heisman candidate before he got injured 🙂

Hill4Heisman

10/20/20 1:08pm

NFL glory, National Championship, Heisman winner are triggers for that lineup

10/20/20 1:22pm

The BYU QB package needs to become a set of 6 2-ups

The Chelsea Dagger

10/20/20 1:24pm

I'd add Taysom since he's currently in the NFL

mncstr

10/20/20 1:29pm

Not to mention Virgil Carter who started for the Eagles, and Gary Sheide.

oldrugger

10/20/20 2:30pm

Ummm, he never played for the Eagles. Did you mean the Bengals?

BYUforlife

10/20/20 3:48pm

Also Mark Wilson.

oldrugger

10/20/20 2:30pm

Are they known?

cantwearred

10/20/20 2:47pm

I would agree. I think anyone interested in football knows Sark and Hill

spidey24

10/20/20 4:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad