Definitely in the conversation with Koufax, Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez,

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 28, 2020
11:38:49am

Jdoc Starter

Definitely in the conversation with Koufax, Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez,

Maddux, Lefty Grove, Cy Young amd Matthewson amd Walter Johnson. I omit Clemens because he was a cheater.

Report problem with this ad

Jdoc

Bio page: Jdoc
Joined: Feb 8, 2018
Last login: May 15, 2024
Total posts: 10,491 (19 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So, is Clayton Kershaw now the greatest Pitcher of all time?

JOPE Resident Golf Fanatic

10/28/20 11:34am

Post season performance this year stepped up.

Dr MoBYU

10/28/20 11:36am

I still go with Koufax, short career and all

AZ Coug

10/28/20 11:36am

Koufax, 12 seasons 2.76 ERA 2400 strikeouts

JOPE

10/28/20 11:50am

They are close in ERA and Ks. I think these numbers separate the two

AZ Coug

10/28/20 4:37pm

In my opinion, he should be sainted. Best Jewish/non-Jewish pitcher of all time.

baldcougar

10/28/20 11:52am

He is #34 on all time list, 1st among active players

Colorado

10/28/20 11:38am

He’s the number one starter pitcher in ERA in the live ball era

JOPE

10/28/20 11:40am

Being in the NL his whole career sure helps that, though.

JDBlue

10/28/20 11:43am

His ERA is also the lowest when you adjust for ballpark and league average

JOPE

10/28/20 11:46am

Being in the weak NL West compared to the AL East day in and day out matters too

JDBlue

10/28/20 11:48am

I'm in a small minority. Greatest for me is Nolan Ryan. Childhood hero.

gangbusters

10/28/20 11:38am

Career era 3.19, on much less rest, ~5400 Inn, ~5700 K, most no-hitters.

bruincoug

10/28/20 12:04pm

Great but not greatest. This WS he got his playoff winning percentage over 50%.

endy

10/28/20 11:38am

Definitely in the conversation with Koufax, Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez,

Jdoc

10/28/20 11:38am

...and Bob Gibson.

Hawk in the 303

10/28/20 11:48am

Yes

Jdoc

10/28/20 12:45pm

Paige, Gibson, Ryan, Hubble, Feller, Marichal ...

bruincoug

10/28/20 11:51am

...and Tom Seaver.

Hawk in the 303

10/28/20 11:52am

I think Pedro is the GOAT (Pedro was a Dodger too, so we still have the GOAT!)

BoiseBlue

10/28/20 11:55am

One more world series win with him winning 2 games in that WS then yes.

DazeofBlue

10/28/20 11:41am

Definitely Top 10. Maybe top 5. Top 3 lefty for sure.

shimmy

10/28/20 11:43am

I'd say top 5 for sure but still behind Koufax and Johnson at least.

scall

10/28/20 11:46am

No, but if he plays well another 4-5 years or more, top 5 or 10 I think.

bruincoug

10/28/20 11:47am

I agree that continued longevity will help his argument

JOPE

10/28/20 11:55am

Those stats are great but he also will never be able to shake the rep of choking

cougarblue

10/28/20 11:47am

Disagree

bruincoug

10/28/20 11:48am

That statement is ridiculous

JOPE

10/28/20 11:54am

From Sportscasting.com

cougarblue

10/28/20 12:27pm

Maddux

Freeagent12

10/28/20 11:52am

He’s a good choice, it’s tough to argue against Greg Maddux

JOPE

10/28/20 11:55am

He was great, but from overlapping era, I put Ryan, then Maddux, then Johnson

bruincoug

10/28/20 12:12pm

Nolan Ryan! Come on, Man!

doctorcoug

10/28/20 1:39pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad