I read several months ago a thought-provoking examination of the subjectivity

Apr 4, 2021
11:25:10am

Forzaitalia Contributor

and echo chamber nature of the star system. No doubt a 5 star-rated athlete is excellent, but the difference between a 3 and a 4 star can easily be nothing. It sounds as if that could be the case with Moeaki.

Report problem with this ad

Forzaitalia

Bio page: Forzaitalia
Joined: Sep 16, 2019
Last login: May 19, 2024
Total posts: 9,042 (7 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I hate to say this - but first 4 2022 commits do not resemble P5 caliber in any

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 12:51am

Well half are choosing BYU over Utah, and Colorado who are P5. I'd say that's

Rat

4/4/21 12:53am

Thanks - he seems legit - small guys with good twitch don’t often work out

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 7:28am

I think its a little too early in the recruiting cycle to be making those

wjman11

4/4/21 1:08am

Thanks - absolutely know it’s early - question is - why these commitments now?

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 7:29am

Did you factor in the Nacua transfers?

SinkingQuffa

4/4/21 2:49am

Puka has 4 years to play if he wants

YIsForBrigham

4/4/21 7:20am

That's pretty crazy. He still has to be cleared to play this year, No?

SinkingQuffa

4/4/21 12:40pm

Yes but there aren’t any indications that he won’t be

BigYfan

4/4/21 12:53pm

To get a full college career outa him seems too good to be true.

SinkingQuffa

4/4/21 12:58pm

Does he? I feel like I'm missing something

krindorr

4/4/21 2:06pm

He only played in four games in 2019. So that can be a redshirt season if he and BYU want it to be. 2020 didn’t count.

YIsForBrigham

4/4/21 2:21pm

Wow, doubt we get 4, but amazing that we could

krindorr

4/4/21 3:08pm

Were any of them Bowl games? I hear that makes a difference /s

BlueRhino

4/4/21 6:05pm

He had a season ending injury half way through the season iirc

BigYfan

4/4/21 6:16pm

No - but I didn’t factor in kids who left either. I’m really just worried this

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 7:34am

8th, 13th, 14th and unranked in the state of Utah

krindorr

4/4/21 6:33am

RE: I hate to say this - but first 4 2022 commits do not resemble P5 caliber in any

mokelembembe

4/4/21 7:20am

Thanks - maybe some if these recruits will prove to be greats.

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 7:39am

Kalani knows how to evaluate talent

Backcountry

4/4/21 8:04am

Maybe I can help ease your concerns a little...

The Number Cruncher

4/4/21 8:05am

Preach!!

(Private)

4/4/21 8:34am

Excellent - thank you so much!!!

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 9:11am

I read several months ago a thought-provoking examination of the subjectivity

Forzaitalia

4/4/21 11:25am

I remember after the 4-9 season Kalani had the lowest rated class in BYU history

donnerstag

4/4/21 8:57am

Yep. Bronco had higher rated classed. Kalani IDs and develops talent and puts

Backcountry

4/4/21 9:15am

We aren’t a P5 so.....we also have this thing called the honor code so....

LyleLanley

4/4/21 9:11am

There is no blue blood flowing in your veins. It is stupid posts like this

87cougs

4/4/21 9:14am

I am a HUGE fan. I will embrace whoever ends up here. My first memory -

Cswilliam01

4/4/21 9:23am

Couldn't disagree more, these guys are all legit talents.

bluescholar

4/4/21 9:15am

Noah Moeaki and Cannon DeVries both have P5 offers

arizonacougarfan

4/4/21 9:23am

The NCAA blackout period has been extended 14 months.. 2021/22 class got screwed

TheLost

4/4/21 9:30am

BYU is still in the mix for Hagen, Matelau, McKenzie twins, Brailsford

arizonacougarfan

4/4/21 10:00am

These players also had few D1 offers

BigYfan

4/4/21 10:08am

Kalani has a long record of evaluating talent

deliciousmocha

4/4/21 10:19am

Just relax. At this point it’s fair to just give kalani the benefit of the doubt on talent evaluation.

YIsForBrigham

4/4/21 10:42am

The same thing was said after we finished the 2018 recruiting class. People were whining that the class was only

Rise Against

4/4/21 12:34pm

Another thing to remember is that this class isn't going to have tons of offers because of Covid. Most camps were not

Posting on CougarBoard