I may be in minority but using seminary teacher recommendations is silly.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 8, 2021
3:16:01pm

Gibbcoug All-American

I may be in minority but using seminary teacher recommendations is silly.

Did they graduate or not. That is all that should matter.

Report problem with this ad

Gibbcoug

New username: Taccoug
Bio page: Gibbcoug
Joined: Aug 14, 2016
Last login: May 31, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Is there an ACT score that puts a kid in the "almost guaranteed acceptance"...

bluecheese

4/8/21 1:17pm

34+

LiveCoug

4/8/21 1:19pm

We had a German exchange student live with us in HS. Got a 35.

bluecheese

4/8/21 1:23pm

Maybe your next kid will be less disappointing.

OPINIONS

4/8/21 1:20pm

She's not a disappointment. She was disappointed, not surprised to not get in.

bluecheese

4/8/21 1:21pm

Based on what I've seen and talked to other parents about, 33/34+

The Old Y

4/8/21 1:20pm

No. The essays are heavily weighted for acceptance. A 30 plus ACT would be a

kotacoug

4/8/21 1:24pm

Doesn't heavy weight on the essays just mean

4/8/21 1:34pm

those were totally an afterthought when I applied (20 years ago now)

Mayor of Cougartown

4/8/21 3:19pm

What I have seen is no there is not. ACT doesn’t matter much anymore which is

ChiCityCoug

4/8/21 1:24pm

It matters but isn’t overly weighted.

kotacoug

4/8/21 1:25pm

My niece- 4.0 GPA, 31 ACT, class president, valedictorian, seminary council

4/8/21 1:56pm

Just wrong and weird. My kids haven't bothered applying due to the stories

Gibbcoug

4/8/21 1:59pm

I love it when people list seminary council or seminary class president

4/8/21 2:03pm

Shouldn't they be at a school like BYU?

bluecheese

4/8/21 2:05pm

no

4/8/21 2:07pm

please explain why not?

Mayor of Cougartown

4/8/21 2:10pm

I see it the same as Laurel Class president

4/8/21 2:13pm

Seminary class president actually means that you most likely are a good

kotacoug

4/8/21 2:18pm

Whether you or I think it is important or not doesn't matter. Most

4/9/21 2:16pm

that would be a really dumb reason not to get in

4/9/21 2:20pm

by 26 GPA, do you mean 26 ACT or 2.6 GPA?

The Shazad

4/8/21 2:04pm

Whoops. 26 ACT. Corrected it.

4/9/21 2:18pm

that ticks me off. I'm not married yet nor have kids so i haven't followed the

4/8/21 3:40pm

It's weird. My own daughter didn't apply but I think she probably would have

4/9/21 2:40pm

The best part about the high standard for acceptance at BYU

USMCdad

4/8/21 2:06pm

ummm ok. Even at half tuition scholarships BYU is still cheaper than everybody

Mayor of Cougartown

4/8/21 2:09pm

My son had multiple full tuition offers and a few full offers

USMCdad

4/8/21 2:46pm

one daughter had full ride offers from schools in CA (residence), but chose BYU

calcio

4/8/21 2:59pm

Absolutely, and that’s the point of my post, not to downgrade BYU

USMCdad

4/8/21 3:16pm

My son got a scholarship to ASU... the fees, dues and parking came out close to

kotacoug

4/8/21 2:20pm

My son went that route as well but graduated with very little debt

USMCdad

4/8/21 2:44pm

This is something that often goes ignored.

MetaLearner

4/8/21 3:00pm

Probably not. I think it all depends on seminary teacher recommendations

Princepete

4/8/21 3:11pm

I may be in minority but using seminary teacher recommendations is silly.

Gibbcoug

4/8/21 3:16pm

I hope you are not in the minority. There is such a wide range of seminary teach

4/8/21 3:22pm

Ya, I think it's incredibly stupid as well but just a correlation I've noticed

Princepete

4/8/21 5:39pm

We had a kid in our stake denied to byuI due to seminary teacher.

Gibbcoug

4/8/21 5:59pm

yikes, that is like 99.7% acceptance rate

4/8/21 6:35pm

I got in with a 24 act, but I was a transfer student.

2Blue4U

4/8/21 4:17pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad