Not a bust, but I still hate Mike Nolan for going with Alex over Aaron Rodgers.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 19, 2021
10:40:15am

Jay Kay Truly Addicted User

Not a bust, but I still hate Mike Nolan for going with Alex over Aaron Rodgers.

Rankles me just thinking about it

Report problem with this ad

Jay Kay

Previous username: Josef K
Bio page: Jay Kay
Joined: Jan 12, 2011
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 30,122 (262 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Alex smith was not a draft bust

BigYfan

4/19/21 10:19am

he sucks

4/19/21 10:21am

As a Yewt, yes. As an NFL QB, no.

Richard McCoy Jr.

4/19/21 10:23am

as the first round pick for my 49ers he did not deliver

4/19/21 10:25am

Understood.

Richard McCoy Jr.

4/19/21 10:31am

Agreed. And re: Jamarcus Russell, that has to be one of the bigger wastes of talent in history

slappy

4/19/21 10:22am

99-67 record as a starter. Had Harbaugh not benched him for Kaepernick he might be a Super Bowl champ too.

RdF3

4/19/21 10:24am

How are you feeling about Mac Jones on the 9ers?

RyneK

4/19/21 10:25am

There is no way the moved up to pick him

BigYfan

4/19/21 1:58pm

He was a much better NFL QB than the legend Ty Detmer. You can't refute his career.

Bonoman

4/19/21 10:26am

Ty's NFL expectations weren't nearly as high as Smith's

mwcoug

4/19/21 10:34am

#1 pick vs 9th round pick #230

STL

4/19/21 10:38am

Meh, unremarkable career. Perhaps better than a mere journeyman but that's it.

rocker

4/19/21 10:27am

He was a starting QB his whole career. That's pretty remarkable

Alpi Gusto

4/19/21 10:31am

"Alex Smith has had a successful, if unremarkable, career in the NFL . . .

rocker

4/19/21 10:56am

He has a higher career passer rating than Dan Marino & Brett Favre.

RdF3

4/19/21 10:29am

Not fair to compare passer ratings from different eras

bluelands

4/19/21 10:47am

I was very surprised to see he's #27 all-time in passing yards.

Scratch

4/19/21 10:30am

If he were entering the draft this year, he'd still be a top 5 pick.

ReyOso

4/19/21 10:34am

Not a bust, but I still hate Mike Nolan for going with Alex over Aaron Rodgers.

Jay Kay

4/19/21 10:40am

I'm not convinced Rodgers would've been good in San Fran. They were inept at the time cycling through multiple OC's.

RdF3

4/19/21 10:43am

To people like yourself I say go back and watch the 2003 cal-usc game on YouTube

Jay Kay

4/19/21 10:46am

Who says he is a draft bust?

LifeLongLakerFan

4/19/21 12:54pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad