I don't know if that's the coaches fault for calling him to run, or his fault for bailing on pass plays. But dude scored 2 TD's - one running and one passing. His QBR was double Romney's - primarily due to having the TD.
Hall played well enough to win, all things considered. Defense failed. Oldroyd failed. Just a crappy game. I think if Hall had been in to finish, BYU wins.