Yeah - all I'm saying is that this isn't a simple black & white question.

Report problem with this ad

May 23, 2022
4:38:20pm

Eddie Truly Addicted User

There are multiple variables at play - and we likely don't know all of the variables.

Report problem with this ad

Eddie

Bio page: Eddie
Joined: Dec 12, 2002
Last login: May 3, 2024
Total posts: 43,979 (900 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I guarantee you guys wouldn't be so cavalier about this if it was football.

Ham

5/23/22 11:19am

BYU has a lengthy history of fans embracing coaches' sons, so it's a shame if Amari doesn't come.

Indy Coug

5/23/22 11:20am

IMO it is definitely a bad sign if she can't get her daughter.

JuicyJam

5/23/22 11:23am

Different situation, because her daughter has already committed elsewhere.

StantonMac

5/23/22 12:55pm

I don't think this says anything at all about Coach Whiting's recruiting skills

Tricky

5/23/22 3:03pm

I honestly hope she can separate being a coach from being a parent.

Eddie

5/23/22 3:12pm

Even while she is the BYU coach I hope her first loyalty is to her family

Tricky

5/24/22 3:33pm

Just logging in. Are we really still talking about this?

cougfanblue

5/23/22 11:26am

RE: Just logging in. Are we really still talking about this?

shimmy

5/23/22 11:42am

If I were the coach and I tried to get my son at BYU, he'd probably commit to

GRCoug

5/23/22 11:26am

Is it cavalier or respecting the coach who is all about honoring commitments and

DJROSS

5/23/22 11:27am

Then fire the principals

akbarishiwatsu

5/23/22 1:06pm

The circumstances are such now that a change of commitment would be

TunaNoCrust

5/23/22 4:31pm

yep. you're right.

v1k0u6

5/23/22 11:28am

I bet folks would care a lot more about getting $20 if it was $1,000,000!!!

BGRTHNUMEGO

5/23/22 11:31am

So, your point is...womens basketball is different than football?

Goliath

5/23/22 11:33am

I still want her to come, but I'd also understand it just as well if it was football. Luckily, coaches "get it" more

shimmy

5/23/22 11:38am

This is true. Coaches and athletes look at this a lot differently than fans do.

GRCoug

5/23/22 11:42am

What in the world does that even mean?

Ham

5/23/22 1:56pm

Truth!

Ethman

5/23/22 11:40am

So.....what are we going do about it? Bunch our panties more?

StarMan

5/23/22 11:42am

More? Checking panties now!!

Pergamino

5/23/22 11:44am

...and when Randy and Robbie Reid played for BYU, many fans didn't like it.

Belboz

5/23/22 11:45am

Problems were in the specifics, I think. But Amari

SinkingQuffa

5/23/22 11:50am

Amber is the new coach

WallaX2

5/23/22 11:59am

That’s a great point!!

Pergamino

5/23/22 12:00pm

Yeah. The other one.

SinkingQuffa

5/23/22 12:35pm

Randy's final 5 were BYU, Stanford, UCLA, Providence and North Carolina.

ochobeeguy

5/23/22 2:55pm

I remember that getting a LOT of pub back in the day. I guarantee

SinkingQuffa

5/23/22 4:57pm

We didn't think they were good enough. Perhaps we were wrong then but

Archaea

5/23/22 12:19pm

BYU fans wanted Ryan Cuff to play instead Randy Reid. Cuff finished at Weber St.

dYrtbYkerYder

5/23/22 2:00pm

Cuff was a poison

Archaea

5/23/22 2:04pm

Robbie was definitely good enough.

Eddie

5/23/22 2:24pm

And if they hadn't, then BYU would have been absolutely horrible.

ochobeeguy

5/23/22 2:51pm

It's pretty complex, to be honest.

Eddie

5/23/22 1:47pm

So is mom never going after players with a commitment? She'll be disadvantaged.

ochobeeguy

5/23/22 2:58pm

No idea.

Eddie

5/23/22 3:00pm

Re: her comment on BYUSN about commitment, it was in the context of Judkins’

NewMexiCoug

5/23/22 4:04pm

Yeah - all I'm saying is that this isn't a simple black & white question.

Eddie

5/23/22 4:38pm

Someone is seriously underestimating what I’ll be cavalier with and/or about

Alan Garner

5/23/22 7:03pm

Maybe she thinks her daughter is overrated.

BlueHair

5/23/22 8:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad