Messi is the GOAT, not Pele

Report problem with this ad

Aug 9, 2022
5:51:56pm

babycarrot 3rd String

Report problem with this ad

babycarrot

Bio page: babycarrot
Joined: Sep 29, 2018
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 2,487 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Which GOAT out of these GOAT’s is the GOAT among GOAT’s?

Magneto

8/9/22 12:40pm

Jeff Gordon is not a GOAT

Sea Chicken

8/9/22 12:40pm

The King

bluelands

8/9/22 12:47pm

My wife works with the King's granddaughter and its cool seeing her social media

thewaterboy

8/9/22 12:56pm

He'd be the nascar GOAT if it weren't for that pesky Jimmie Johnson

NarfUte

8/9/22 12:51pm

I read one time that he would have won another two or three titles if they had

Charles Darwin

8/9/22 12:56pm

Jack>Tiger

Pollster

8/9/22 12:41pm

I don’t think even Jack believes that deep down

pink22

8/9/22 1:06pm

Jack disagrees.

fredetteaboutit13

8/10/22 12:58am

Jim Thorpe

BYULAWGUY

8/9/22 12:42pm

Tiger is the other kind of goat…..

OMIllionaire

8/9/22 12:42pm

You're embarrassing yourself

PrimeQuantumDeek

8/9/22 1:46pm

Hank Aaron is baseball’s GOAT

RevolutionDeathsquad

8/9/22 12:43pm

Babe Ruth transformed the game, no one really touches what he did.

fbguru

8/9/22 12:43pm

RE: POLL: Which GOAT out of these GOAT’s is the GOAT among GOAT’s?

imdocrob

8/9/22 12:43pm

Everyone knows who Gretzky is

Sea Chicken

8/9/22 12:44pm

Are you talking about Paulina? She is famous for social media and stuff. I have never heard of her grandpa.

Baron

8/9/22 12:48pm

Sorry Jerry Rice over Tom Brady. He is relative greatness to other WRs is huge.

Baron

8/9/22 12:44pm

Ben Roethlisberger would like a word

Sea Chicken

8/9/22 12:45pm

Lebron>MJ

Blueto

8/9/22 12:48pm

RE: Lebron>MJ

imdocrob

8/9/22 12:50pm

I don't think it's that close anymore

Blueto

8/9/22 12:52pm

"The Great One", I think his nickname says it all.

RC Vikings

8/9/22 12:49pm

Michael Phelps should at least be in the poll

CougarTail

8/9/22 12:50pm

Joey Chestnut

Niiineteeen84

8/9/22 12:51pm

Nata

BYUMizzou

8/9/22 12:52pm

Any list including a system QB is invalid.

TCuz

8/9/22 12:55pm

Pele is the Goat of all goats

PhilPete

8/9/22 1:01pm

Tiger doesn't have the most majors does he?

flyzag

8/9/22 1:02pm

Lewis Hamilton 🏁

zephyr

8/9/22 1:03pm

If you were going to put a NASCAR driver on the list at least pick Richard Petty

BYUMizzou

8/9/22 1:06pm

MJ isn't even the GOAT in basketball, how could he be the GOAT of GOATs?

stev

8/9/22 1:07pm

Wow! I'm surprised there isn't more for Serena, seems like she dominated tennis

TO11

8/9/22 1:07pm

RE: POLL: Which GOAT out of these GOAT’s is the GOAT among GOAT’s?

All-American Coug

8/9/22 1:09pm

Jordan --> Tiger --> Brady --> Gretzky

Vincent's Picks

8/9/22 1:14pm

Jordan ->Brady->Gretzky->Jack

flyzag

8/9/22 1:35pm

Jordan over Gretzky is crazy.

Hotlanta

8/9/22 1:39pm

Jordan changed sports. Gretzky might have in Canada as well as I'm sure he would be #1 up there. But down here in

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 2:51pm

There are people who argue that Jordan isn't the GOAT in basketball. NOBODY

downtownchrisbrown

8/9/22 3:01pm

But again, Gretzky didn't change anything for almost anyone here in the states. He didn't single handedly take a

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 3:21pm

You clearly are not a hockey fan and that’s fine. But to say Gretzky didn’t fundamentally change hockey in the US is

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:28pm

What are you even talking about? First off, I went to the Stanley Cup Finals this year, did you?

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 3:34pm

Lol what kind of an appeal to authority is that

Magathis

8/9/22 3:39pm

What kind of appeal to authority?

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 3:42pm

Your appeal to authority being because you saw a specific hockey game this year your opinion matters more.

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:45pm

It was in response to some dufus saying I am clearly not a hockey fan.

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 3:47pm

The "dufus" here is clearly the guy who thinks that Gretzky doesnt transcend his sport.

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:52pm

Again please look up the word transcend. You clearly don't know what it means.

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 4:39pm

Oh I’m sorry, I read “Gretzky didn’t change anything for almost anyone here in the US” as he didn’t change anything flr

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:44pm

No I 100% meant that Gretzky didn't change anything for almost anyone here in the U.S. I guess somehow you

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 3:50pm

And I shared an article showing that was not true. Show me an article that refutes what I said

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:53pm

Your article is literally entitled, how Gretzky changed HOCKEY in the U.S.

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 4:13pm

Sounds good. You are right I didn't factor Space Jam into the sports discussion. Because clearly Space Jam is how you

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 4:30pm

Those who argue Jordan isn't goat have fallen for CCP sponsored propaganda.

IceCreamButt

8/9/22 6:21pm

Gretzky is actually the GOAT of American hockey too just fyi.

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:15pm

Who cares? Gretzky will never be challenged. Jordan has a strong case for GOAT

Hotlanta

8/9/22 5:04pm

Apparently the people voting in this poll.

kimdaddy35

8/9/22 5:12pm

Serena dominated at a level and with a longevity that is unrivaled.

Gorgias

8/9/22 1:42pm

Usain Bolt and Michael Phelps should be options as well.

Gorgias

8/9/22 1:44pm

Wayne Gretzky currently holds 61 records. Many of which are considered "untouchable"

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 1:58pm

If Jordan is still in the running in 70 yrs, then him. Til then, its The Babe.

CosimosPrime

8/9/22 2:16pm

It's tight between MJ and the Babe. I think Pele and TB not far behind. Mt. Rush

ImuaKahuku

8/9/22 2:24pm

Kelly Slater must be on this list, IMO

Dan

8/9/22 2:28pm

Obviously Gretzky

downtownchrisbrown

8/9/22 2:54pm

I think it HAS to be someone from a team sport -

BYUDM93

8/9/22 3:00pm

This is fivethirtyeight’s take on who is the GOAT of all GOATs

JohnnyComeLately

8/9/22 3:11pm

How many Stanley Cups would Gretzky won had he stayed in Edmonton? Could they have kept that team together?

Spiff

8/10/22 10:20am

Jordan is the hugest GOAT - most famous, most influential, most legendary

Coop

8/9/22 3:25pm

Messi is the GOAT, not Pele

babycarrot

8/9/22 5:51pm

Yep missing Messi

bdizzle

8/9/22 6:11pm

Messi isn't even demonstrably better than Ronaldo, let alone Pele

Hotlanta

8/9/22 7:09pm

What?

babycarrot

8/10/22 12:01am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad