Maybe but I question bringing too many new guys in

Mar 21, 2023
2:41:10pm

puntersarepeople Truly Addicted User

There is something to be said for continuity and culture. IMO don’t take a schollie until you actually have somebody walking through that door

Report problem with this ad

puntersarepeople

Bio page: puntersarepeople
Joined: Jan 1, 2018
Last login: May 25, 2024
Total posts: 33,317 (14 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The case against Trey Stewart and Noah Waterman

52Cougar

3/20/23 2:31pm

I think one of the great developments of college sports messageboards is advocating the firing of individual players

Indy Coug

3/20/23 2:34pm

The portal has changed everything

52Cougar

3/20/23 2:37pm

The case to keep them:

StantonMac

3/20/23 2:37pm

Trey has two more years.

52Cougar

3/20/23 2:38pm

“Unlikely to get anyone better in the portal” ?

gmoney7

3/20/23 2:55pm

BYU has had very good transfer success in the recent past: Barcello, Haarms,

Thrill

3/20/23 2:58pm

Will be hard to beat these numbers in the portal

gmoney7

3/20/23 3:02pm

That’s true but you’re expecting us to land 4 transfers and not have anyone leav

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 3:05pm

I think expectations ARE high and should be if you don't want a 12th place

Thrill

3/20/23 3:29pm

You played yourself

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 6:29pm

LOL: you are arguing for 2 dudes scoring a combined 6 ppg with the better of

Thrill

3/20/23 9:51pm

LOL go look at the back of the bench for every team in the Big12

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 9:56pm

but it does increase the possibility of getting more than one good transfer...

icecougar

3/21/23 2:32pm

Maybe but I question bringing too many new guys in

puntersarepeople

3/21/23 2:41pm

Trey is a player you want in your locker room, but little reason to play him

VirginiaPeanut

3/20/23 2:38pm

Stewart - I think we knew what we were getting with him. If all he does is defend, and take it directly to the rim when

Bob Vance

3/20/23 2:39pm

BYU has 2 schollies open now. Not sure why you run those two.

Turnpike Lane

3/20/23 2:39pm

That's the thing though, Waterman showed he can't shoot

Heath Squashwell

3/20/23 6:13pm

if we add another PG and a big with those 2 schollies and both are impact type..

icecougar

3/21/23 2:36pm

Many teams have a defensive specialist/rebounder who isn’t a scorer. Keep Trey.

RossoNeri

3/20/23 2:52pm

No reason to run them out

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 2:53pm

How can you underrate a guy who scored 5 ppg and shot 36%?

Thrill

3/20/23 3:03pm

Most people on here say he never played well

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 3:18pm

2 out of 34 games is not enough.

Thrill

3/20/23 9:52pm

Obviously 🙄

puntersarepeople

3/20/23 10:01pm

He had a rough conference slate, sure, but held up fine in the non conference

Kdubb

3/21/23 8:03am

The 2 cases are not the same. Both can't shoot & commit too many fouls. Trey is

Forzaitalia

3/20/23 3:14pm

We need to have a Waterman bobblehead night though. I'd lineup for one of those

Chefcurry

3/20/23 3:19pm

The case for Trey Stewart: Anson Winder

Coop

3/20/23 3:20pm

Anson Winder was a FAR better shooter then Trey is. Not a good comparison.

Lance71

3/20/23 4:40pm

He shot 29.8% from 3 his freshman season and 25% from 3 as a soph

Coop

3/20/23 4:47pm

That's more than double what Trey has shot.

Lance71

3/20/23 4:49pm

Trey also had 22 steals in 275 minutes this year.

dwhitebud

3/20/23 5:00pm

I'm not arguing Trey shouldn't be on the team. Only Winder is not a good comp

Lance71

3/20/23 5:27pm

Really bad is not FAR better than terrible

Coop

3/20/23 5:38pm

And Trey is a far better athlete than Winder w similar length.

SinkingQuffa

3/20/23 7:27pm

<< Deleted >>

jdh895

3/20/23 4:41pm

I love you guys who think you know more than the coaches.

rockyrd

3/20/23 9:44pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad