Nobody knows the answer to that before it happens. Just like Utah didn't know it until Rising got the chance.

Report problem with this ad

Mar 30, 2023
2:01:01pm

SingleStrapBackpack Truly Addicted User

Report problem with this ad

SingleStrapBackpack

Bio page: SingleStrapBackpack
Joined: Mar 19, 2013
Last login: Jun 15, 2024
Total posts: 36,944 (507 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kedon Slovis vs Charlie Brewer

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 1:58pm

Nobody knows the answer to that before it happens. Just like Utah didn't know it until Rising got the chance.

SingleStrapBackpack

3/30/23 2:01pm

Utah doesn’t know how to coach QB’s. I trust that A-Rod will do well with Slovis

CopperLix

3/30/23 2:07pm

Agreed. That’s why I think Slovis pans out

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 2:12pm

Hmm ARod coached all those under performing Ute QBs. Ludwig coached the one

Utefaninenemyland

3/30/23 3:05pm

"made the pro-bowl" needs the biggest asterisk in the world

LeonMarek

3/30/23 3:06pm

That is reserved for 1984

Utefaninenemyland

3/30/23 3:11pm

No, it's reserved for Utah's 2008 national championship

akbarishiwatsu

3/30/23 4:03pm

I love jealousy from a fan who's team doesn't have a "Natty"

slatecoug

3/30/23 7:52pm

How can there be an asterisk if its consensus? Lol

andrewg3

3/30/23 10:26pm

Yeah throwing more INTs than TDs gets you in the Pro Bowl nowadays because

CameronG

3/30/23 3:13pm

A-Rod and Brother Beck, with two witnesses....

Kolobrdm

3/30/23 3:17pm

Retzlaff looks small, listed at 200 but I don't know if he's that big. I like

pinolero

3/30/23 2:09pm

Slovis is going to lead us to an undefeated National Championship in 2023, but

IdahoCoug

3/30/23 2:11pm

Certainly some similarities, but I'll wait and see how they treat Slovis in the

Corn Pop

3/30/23 2:11pm

Differences: Brewer didn't fit Andy Ludwig's offense, Slovis fits Arod's

1984coug

3/30/23 2:12pm

The counter

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 2:14pm

Counter your counter

LeonMarek

3/30/23 2:19pm

Counter to the counter of my counter

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 2:26pm

Counter to the counter of my counter to your counter

LeonMarek

3/30/23 2:28pm

That’s a solid counter

Blue Ridge

3/30/23 2:47pm

RE: That’s a solid counter

RGGeemer

3/30/23 3:25pm

That gif was what we call low hanging fruit.

IdahoCoug

3/30/23 3:31pm

Utah's offense has always needed a mobile QB, it stems from Whittingham's

CameronG

3/30/23 2:38pm

ARod’s offense has always had a mobile QB.

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 2:51pm

As long as Slovis is agile enough to roll out and run for 3 yards on a 3rd

LeonMarek

3/30/23 2:56pm

Yes but Zach and Jaren were good passers

CameronG

3/30/23 3:11pm

Slovis can move if needed

1984coug

3/30/23 4:10pm

He’s moved twice already. Should be ok.

Stalwartbob

3/30/23 5:22pm

Hall and Wilson rarely ran. Not sure what point you’re making

BYU '80

3/30/23 10:45pm

But neither ran much. They were mobile in the pocket and good on the run

BYU '80

3/30/23 10:45pm

Note: Brewer wasn't nearly as bad as they say.

Benfica1

3/30/23 2:14pm

Brewer was 0-2 against two end-of-season ranked teams

akbarishiwatsu

3/30/23 4:15pm

Slovis will be good, much better than Brewer was. Your system is great for a

kos

3/30/23 2:20pm

RE: Slovis will be good, much better than Brewer was. Your system is great for a

Atmospheric_Cougar

3/30/23 4:41pm

Brewer transferred to Utah because he lost his job at Baylor.

rcbyufan

3/30/23 3:00pm

Brewer never had a year like Slovis in his freshman year.

Lance71

3/30/23 3:04pm

Slovis did pretty well his second year too, except he was in Kalifornia for the pandemic.

PJMort

3/30/23 3:18pm

Retzlaff is gonna be one of the BYU greats, I have a feeling

RGGeemer

3/30/23 3:24pm

Bentley and Brewer stats were in gradual decline over the course of

CallSign

3/30/23 3:34pm

RE: Bentley and Brewer stats were in gradual decline over the course of

RGGeemer

3/30/23 3:44pm

Not sure why I'm engaging but Brewer cratered from 2019 to 2020. Cratered.

rcbyufan

3/30/23 4:19pm

Slovis stats

CallSign

3/30/23 6:29pm

Brewer was the fall guy for Utah getting handled by BYU and SDSU.

slatecoug

3/30/23 4:35pm

This is my thought too. Brewer could have been just fine but Whittingham

byusage

3/30/23 5:49pm

If Slovis went to the U, a stumble like Brewer's = plausible - at QBU, no way

jtm0001

3/30/23 5:36pm

Then how did Rising thrive?

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 5:38pm

Innate ability. Little to do with coaching

jtm0001

3/30/23 5:42pm

So does Retzlaff and Finnegan have that innate ability?

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 5:49pm

They probably both have some, but not as good as Rising...but what does that

jtm0001

3/30/23 5:57pm

The OP mentions if Slovis doesn’t pan out

BYUJazzKicks

3/30/23 6:03pm

Retzlaff could be a product of the Riverside CC offensive system.

Stalwartbob

3/30/23 6:50pm

He’s a runner. There’s a reason he’s not an nfl prospect

BYU '80

3/30/23 10:47pm

You haven’t had a legit NFL starter since Steve Young. QBU once upon a time.

CallSign

3/30/23 6:25pm

Utah hasn't produced anything near Steve Young or Jim McMahon

CameronG

3/31/23 9:40am

Utah calls it the throw game

Ecslc55

3/30/23 8:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad