My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 25, 2017
2:16
:21
pm
Bobmarleyjr
Contributor
AAC won't allow it
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Bobmarleyjr
Bio page
Bobmarleyjr
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Last login
Jun 9, 2024
Total posts
6,621 (5 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
G5 vs Indy conversation jumped the shark long ago. We get it, for what ever
Cougarpolis
9/25/17 9:20am
If BYU joins a G5, my interest in BYU FB will diminish significantly.
Ragnar Danneskjold
9/25/17 9:26am
BYU Losing : G5 Alarmists :: Hurricane : Global warming alarmists
Sandstone Cougar
9/25/17 9:27am
But global warming is a verifiable fact... Like 100% so
Dissenter
9/25/17 2:24pm
It's a step down in perception. Major Independent vs. G5.
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 9:28am
Last week TH said that there will be a time
Everyman
9/25/17 9:37am
The time that byu can no longer compete with the p5 is 2011.
Backcountry
9/25/17 9:39am
what kind of bull crap is this? BYU competes with P5 RIGHT NOW
Dissenter
9/25/17 2:25pm
Check our record since going indy.
Backcountry
9/25/17 2:45pm
pretty dang close to .500. That's competing
Dissenter
9/25/17 4:55pm
That statement was about money. And he's right.
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 9:42am
Ny6 access, conference championship race
Backcountry
9/25/17 10:34am
I would guess, and assume, that if BYU went back to a G5 they would be keeping
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 1:19pm
AAC won't allow it
Bobmarleyjr
9/25/17 2:16pm
Do you know this for sure? I sure don't. Yes it is an assumption, but
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 2:23pm
We don't know if they would but we know they didn't & don't plan on it
Bobmarleyjr
9/25/17 2:28pm
Again you don't know this as this scenario has never come up, to this point.
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 2:29pm
Only when Aresco invited BSU & told them they couldn't do it & probably
Bobmarleyjr
9/25/17 2:42pm
No. 100% shot down by the aac commissioner on criddles show
Backcountry
9/25/17 2:47pm
We will know more about how sustainably Indy is when the ESPN contract ends
Cougar Geek
9/25/17 9:52am
BYU/ESPN is extended though 2020
SJS
9/25/17 9:54am
Even Notre Dame makes substantially less media money than the P5
boscatar
9/25/17 10:09am
Eventually BYU has to actually beat a few P5 teams to stay in the perceived
TeeKaa
9/25/17 10:50am
Yes. Since independence, BYU is 2-15
Everyman
9/25/17 10:59am
What's our record against any FBS winning teams in that same stretch (incl. G5)?
boscatar
9/25/17 11:06am
12-8
Everyman
9/25/17 11:22am
That's not how this wirks. I get that Utes and downtrodden BYU
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 11:56am
Huge national headlines that lead to what exactly?
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 1:21pm
Fair enough. But then, how does one judge the program?
Everyman
9/25/17 1:29pm
Our schedules are tough enough that our end of season record and national ranking (if applicable) are
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 1:33pm
By W/L and rankings. That is how all programs are judged.
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 1:40pm
Out of curiosity, how many teams that we beat would have had winning seasons
cougaman
9/25/17 1:28pm
Major independent?
Cougtruth
9/25/17 12:01pm
Ask the media:
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 12:54pm
The Media?
Cougtruth
9/25/17 1:33pm
ESPN chose BYU-#10 Wisconsin over CSU-#1 Alabama, Tulane-#2Oklahoma
boscatar
9/25/17 2:33pm
Yep, they thought we were the most likely matchup to not be a blow out.
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 2:37pm
Maybe they thought that after being humiliated we would make a game of it.
Cougtruth
9/25/17 3:18pm
And it went in one ear and out the other. Great points, but the jaded few
PhilPete
9/25/17 9:35am
G5, Indy, it doesn't matter. BYU athletics are on life support.
Backcountry
9/25/17 9:37am
What about Boise, Houston, etc. then? They
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 9:43am
They aren't in a great position, but ours is worse.
Backcountry
9/25/17 10:43am
Look at the budgets. BYU is in better financial shape. We also have
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 12:58pm
Right now they would. In 20 years that won't be the case.
Backcountry
9/25/17 1:14pm
Well, that could be. One way to help that along would be for BYU to drop down to Boise's income level
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 1:17pm
What would be beneficial for BYU to do is start winning again. One thing Indy
TheLoneCougar
9/25/17 1:27pm
I agree with this: Winning would solve a lot of problems.
Gentleman Stan
9/25/17 1:31pm
In reality BYU's problems have litle to do with conference affiliation and every
Backcountry
9/25/17 1:29pm
Both options suck so why get so worked up either way?
sgriff
9/25/17 9:47am
No one would be complaining about independence if we were competitive
boscatar
9/25/17 10:02am
They need to water down the future schedules no front loaded with strong P5's
franklyvulgar
9/25/17 10:29am
I wonder what percentage of ND fans want to join a conference? granted it would
Mayor of Cougartown
9/25/17 10:04am
Notre Dame has a tremendous football tradition. 27 national championships
cowhide
9/25/17 10:54am
yes I get all this,Everyone does. the contract is with NBC (has been for decades
Mayor of Cougartown
9/25/17 11:22am
Notre Dame - NBC tv contract
Cougtruth
9/25/17 12:07pm
In addition
Cougtruth
9/25/17 1:05pm
our first year as Indy our recruiting was 66 and has been the same
franklyvulgar
9/25/17 11:30am
If everybody were on the same page there’d be nothing to discuss.
canofpicante
9/25/17 5:59pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad