Fair enough. But then, how does one judge the program?

Report problem with this ad

Sep 25, 2017
1:29:41pm

Everyman All-American

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 25, 2017 at 1:29:41pm

Message modified by Everyman on Sep 25, 2017 at 1:30:59pm

Report problem with this ad

Everyman

Previous username: Everymancoug
Bio page: Everyman
Joined: May 27, 2012
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 19,939 (105 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

G5 vs Indy conversation jumped the shark long ago. We get it, for what ever

Cougarpolis

9/25/17 9:20am

If BYU joins a G5, my interest in BYU FB will diminish significantly.

Ragnar Danneskjold

9/25/17 9:26am

BYU Losing : G5 Alarmists :: Hurricane : Global warming alarmists

Sandstone Cougar

9/25/17 9:27am

But global warming is a verifiable fact... Like 100% so

Dissenter

9/25/17 2:24pm

It's a step down in perception. Major Independent vs. G5.

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 9:28am

Last week TH said that there will be a time

Everyman

9/25/17 9:37am

The time that byu can no longer compete with the p5 is 2011.

Backcountry

9/25/17 9:39am

what kind of bull crap is this? BYU competes with P5 RIGHT NOW

Dissenter

9/25/17 2:25pm

Check our record since going indy.

Backcountry

9/25/17 2:45pm

pretty dang close to .500. That's competing

Dissenter

9/25/17 4:55pm

That statement was about money. And he's right.

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 9:42am

Ny6 access, conference championship race

Backcountry

9/25/17 10:34am

I would guess, and assume, that if BYU went back to a G5 they would be keeping

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 1:19pm

AAC won't allow it

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 2:16pm

Do you know this for sure? I sure don't. Yes it is an assumption, but

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 2:23pm

We don't know if they would but we know they didn't & don't plan on it

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 2:28pm

Again you don't know this as this scenario has never come up, to this point.

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 2:29pm

Only when Aresco invited BSU & told them they couldn't do it & probably

Bobmarleyjr

9/25/17 2:42pm

No. 100% shot down by the aac commissioner on criddles show

Backcountry

9/25/17 2:47pm

We will know more about how sustainably Indy is when the ESPN contract ends

Cougar Geek

9/25/17 9:52am

BYU/ESPN is extended though 2020

SJS

9/25/17 9:54am

Even Notre Dame makes substantially less media money than the P5

boscatar

9/25/17 10:09am

Eventually BYU has to actually beat a few P5 teams to stay in the perceived

TeeKaa

9/25/17 10:50am

Yes. Since independence, BYU is 2-15

Everyman

9/25/17 10:59am

What's our record against any FBS winning teams in that same stretch (incl. G5)?

boscatar

9/25/17 11:06am

12-8

Everyman

9/25/17 11:22am

That's not how this wirks. I get that Utes and downtrodden BYU

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 11:56am

Huge national headlines that lead to what exactly?

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 1:21pm

Fair enough. But then, how does one judge the program?

Everyman

9/25/17 1:29pm

Our schedules are tough enough that our end of season record and national ranking (if applicable) are

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 1:33pm

By W/L and rankings. That is how all programs are judged.

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 1:40pm

Out of curiosity, how many teams that we beat would have had winning seasons

cougaman

9/25/17 1:28pm

Major independent?

Cougtruth

9/25/17 12:01pm

Ask the media:

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 12:54pm

The Media?

Cougtruth

9/25/17 1:33pm

ESPN chose BYU-#10 Wisconsin over CSU-#1 Alabama, Tulane-#2Oklahoma

boscatar

9/25/17 2:33pm

Yep, they thought we were the most likely matchup to not be a blow out.

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 2:37pm

Maybe they thought that after being humiliated we would make a game of it.

Cougtruth

9/25/17 3:18pm

And it went in one ear and out the other. Great points, but the jaded few

PhilPete

9/25/17 9:35am

G5, Indy, it doesn't matter. BYU athletics are on life support.

Backcountry

9/25/17 9:37am

What about Boise, Houston, etc. then? They

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 9:43am

They aren't in a great position, but ours is worse.

Backcountry

9/25/17 10:43am

Look at the budgets. BYU is in better financial shape. We also have

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 12:58pm

Right now they would. In 20 years that won't be the case.

Backcountry

9/25/17 1:14pm

Well, that could be. One way to help that along would be for BYU to drop down to Boise's income level

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 1:17pm

What would be beneficial for BYU to do is start winning again. One thing Indy

TheLoneCougar

9/25/17 1:27pm

I agree with this: Winning would solve a lot of problems.

Gentleman Stan

9/25/17 1:31pm

In reality BYU's problems have litle to do with conference affiliation and every

Backcountry

9/25/17 1:29pm

Both options suck so why get so worked up either way?

sgriff

9/25/17 9:47am

No one would be complaining about independence if we were competitive

boscatar

9/25/17 10:02am

They need to water down the future schedules no front loaded with strong P5's

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 10:29am

I wonder what percentage of ND fans want to join a conference? granted it would

Mayor of Cougartown

9/25/17 10:04am

Notre Dame has a tremendous football tradition. 27 national championships

cowhide

9/25/17 10:54am

yes I get all this,Everyone does. the contract is with NBC (has been for decades

Mayor of Cougartown

9/25/17 11:22am

Notre Dame - NBC tv contract

Cougtruth

9/25/17 12:07pm

In addition

Cougtruth

9/25/17 1:05pm

our first year as Indy our recruiting was 66 and has been the same

franklyvulgar

9/25/17 11:30am

If everybody were on the same page there’d be nothing to discuss.

canofpicante

9/25/17 5:59pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad