Big name Notre Dame signee transferred to UCLA

Report problem with this ad

Jun 25, 2013
9:21:22am

JamesWestfall

a few weeks ago. Joe Schad tweeted that he loses a year no matter what (can't redshirt it away).

Report problem with this ad

JamesWestfall

Previous username: lawyer
New username: Not Applicable
Bio page: JamesWestfall
Joined: Mar 24, 2011
Last login: Aug 13, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Key contributor on TBS confirms Chasen Andersen rumor is true

truecoug1

6/25/13 8:58am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

6/25/13 8:59am

Well said. I agree. Cool experience to play for dad at a big school.

BYU-Texas

6/25/13 9:00am

I agree with this.

lawboy

6/25/13 9:00am

He sits and loses a year, right?

KingDave

6/25/13 9:00am

I doubt it. I could see him just getting released from the scholly by BYU

BYU-Texas

6/25/13 9:03am

I hope BYU doesn't release him. Make him sit a year.

Big Wally D

6/25/13 9:24am

No way. We aren't Chow.

BYU-Texas

6/25/13 9:26am

There's a reason for the rule and this seems to fit exactly into that rule.

Big Wally D

6/25/13 9:29am

If it wasnt for the fact that his dad is the coach, I would say "make him sit"

BE-WHY-YOU

6/25/13 9:33am

If I was his dad I would tell him to stick to his commitment.

Big Wally D

6/25/13 9:44am

Huh, kind of like the Sharp kid that plays for BYU basketball...

jt04

6/25/13 9:47am

Sharp sat out two years. It's fine if Andersen wants to sit, redshirt, or missio

Big Wally D

6/25/13 9:51am

This is an excellent point:

Finngirl

6/25/13 9:53am

Home was just up the road then.

IGlowInTheDark

6/25/13 9:57am

it would be for me but for a lot of NCAA athletes, its also

Finngirl

6/25/13 10:01am

I thought he committed to BYU after his dad left for Wisky

BYU-Texas

6/25/13 9:59am

You completely contradict yourself here.

jt04

6/25/13 10:03am

Still whining about Sharp transferring after his mission? Coach K would be proud

cougarmeister

6/25/13 10:53am

Completely different. Sharp signed a LOI then turned his back on Utah. Same thin

jt04

6/25/13 1:53pm

No scholarship issues had he come back when he said he was coming back.

cougarick

6/25/13 2:00pm

Justification is like.....

jt04

6/25/13 3:13pm

As I said, he went where he wanted. Or can you not read?

cougarick

6/25/13 3:26pm

Did BYU have a scholarship available for him?

jt04

6/25/13 5:25pm

Yep. In the fall like they agreed they would.

arek

6/25/13 5:30pm

Wrong.

jt04

6/25/13 6:04pm

Shut the crap up. BYU did no turning of its back on Murphy.

cougarick

6/26/13 6:48am

LOL. You ranting does nothing to disspell that Murphy's situation is completely

jt04

6/26/13 11:19am

Oh, you're a woman scorned. Got it.

cougarick

6/26/13 11:43am

In a world that shows no commitment to its athletes...

IGlowInTheDark

6/25/13 9:56am

I agree. Why is it that scholarships are on a year to year basis, but to leave,

jt04

6/25/13 10:04am

The only problem with that sentiment is his dad was the coach before he signed

cougarick

6/25/13 11:23am

I'm not worried that all of our recruits whose dads coach for BCS programs

Tricky

6/25/13 10:29am

If he signed a NLOI, how is he doing this?

HuskerFan2

6/25/13 9:04am

Probably. Bronco would do that for Gary. Be smart to.

lawboy

6/25/13 9:05am

It's not like Gary is taking recruits from Utah. What does Bronco owe to Gary?

Big Wally D

6/25/13 9:53am

It's not about what you owe him, it's about not looking petty. Plus scheduling.

lawboy

6/25/13 10:02am

Im sure Bronco will simply release him. Bronco just wants kids to succeed, no

BE-WHY-YOU

6/25/13 9:05am

So does this guy:

benny1982

6/25/13 9:06am

LOL

BE-WHY-YOU

6/25/13 9:06am

Big name Notre Dame signee transferred to UCLA

JamesWestfall

6/25/13 9:21am

The only way he doesn't lose a year is if he goes on a mission

Lance71

6/25/13 9:28am

I don't think it will matter.

lawboy

6/25/13 9:36am

Great points.

Zach Morris

6/25/13 9:04am

Best of luck to him.

BE-WHY-YOU

6/25/13 9:06am

Had he not enrolled? Too bad.

chago04

6/25/13 9:17am

That's too bad, but it's always easier to lose a kid who hasn't even seen the

Byron McNertney

6/25/13 9:22am

Is Auston Johnson still available?

Captain Stubing

6/25/13 9:23am

I forgot about that guy. The schollie he was hoping for went to Andersen.

BE-WHY-YOU

6/25/13 9:41am

He never actually had a FBS offer and signed with South Dakota St.

molodyets

6/25/13 12:37pm

Why? Was offseason workout culture hard to take at BYU? Cmon

Y4LYFE

6/25/13 9:44am

Personally, I would not want to play on the team where my Dad was coach

fierce16

6/25/13 9:48am

Point-in-case: Cody Hawkins

HoustonBlueCougar

6/25/13 10:00am

QB is vastly different from LB.

lawboy

6/25/13 10:09am

Talking about the situation, not the position.

HoustonBlueCougar

6/25/13 5:50pm

That's true in little league. At the college level players know who is good

RedlandsCoug

6/25/13 10:03am

Maybe we can get another H/H out of the deal. It's only fair.

JDBlue

6/25/13 10:23am

I wish him well if true... it's still just a rumor though. Having it confirmed

aTmcoug

6/25/13 10:25am

I will be more cautious from now on.

Crewblue

6/25/13 10:53am

It's simpler than that. There are a lot of weenies on an anonymous

Y'zFan

6/25/13 12:08pm

We like to crucify all our insiders-see Shoganai, New Jersey Coug, Blue Brotha

CougarPilot

6/25/13 12:11pm

Bluebrotha is the only one of those three that was ever right...

Zach Morris

6/25/13 12:33pm

I'm still undecided about Shog...but New Jersey Coug had ESPN friends

CougarPilot

6/25/13 4:13pm

Fair enough. He very well could have. Again I think

Zach Morris

6/25/13 4:23pm

No he didn't he was a Yewt Troll and got owned by CBers when they found out.

BYU-Texas

6/25/13 5:17pm

New Jersey Coug? That's surprising...do you have a link?

CougarPilot

6/26/13 8:24pm

He's been permanently deleted. No history of a single post.

BYU-Texas

6/26/13 8:31pm

The dude picked up his ball and went home because CBer's

Zach Morris

6/26/13 8:36pm

There you go...this is why I don't buy anything from salesmen

CougarPilot

6/26/13 11:19pm

It helps if you donate

KingDave

6/25/13 3:19pm

Big loss..still surprised by this however!

Desert Rat

6/25/13 11:37am

Plus be in the B 10 and see great places and teams each week.

GOBIGBLUE

6/25/13 12:04pm

Pretty hard to miss a mediocre player who has never set foot on the field.

JamesDean

6/25/13 1:06pm

Frankly, who could blame him? I wish him well, too bad it didnt work out

binghammer

6/25/13 9:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad