I may start another thread comparing the defenses

Dec 30, 2013
1:17:55pm

donnerstag

although I'll likely save it for another day. Bronco's defenses are vastly superior, but Bronco delegated the offense recruiting to the wrong coaches IMO.

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 39,196 (684 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Crowton versus Bronco recruits on offense

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:28pm

Big difference is oline.

RaggaeCoug

12/30/13 12:30pm

But we were in such a good position at OL that the coach felt it was fine to

foofcoug

12/30/13 12:34pm

13 signed in the previous 3 years.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:59pm

and tight end

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:45pm

At least be fair and include Max Hall, Harvy Unga, Matt & Houston Reynolds,

showmecoug

12/30/13 12:52pm

Pitta was a preferred walk on; I gave Bronco credit for Falslev

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:04pm

In other words you will use whatever criteria you want to support your argument.

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:10pm

Preferred walk-on just means he didn't believe in him enough to give him a

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:11pm

Crowton still recruited him, just like Bronco recruited Falslev and Rich

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:20pm

Yes, and Bronco still recruited the Reynolds brothers, Famika Anae, Hall, & Hill

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:25pm

Hall and Hill were transfers who self-recruited to BYU

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:38pm

I don't know that I'd call running backs a wash

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:55pm

Hine has done next to nothing at running back

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:13pm

And Brathwaite had one long run and got kicked out.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:17pm

Was it an 800 yard run?

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:19pm

No, but it was about 98 - so about 1/8 of his total yards in one run.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:49pm

Crowton made the mistake of not emphasizing the HC enough to his

Zaphod

12/30/13 12:33pm

That, and trying to force BYU personnel into an unproven & unrealistic mold.

Mantis Mutu

12/30/13 12:44pm

Difference in recruiting or development of players?

Pasadena

12/30/13 12:34pm

Both, agree on both.

Heinz57

12/30/13 12:37pm

You have a very large number of good players missing from your list . . .

viper

12/30/13 12:45pm

Which players would that be?

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:46pm

Van Noy, for one

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:52pm

Got it. You just listed offensive recruits

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:54pm

I may start another thread comparing the defenses

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:17pm

First of all, this was just an offensive overview

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:58pm

Even just at QB, aren't you missing Hall, Hill, Mangum?

viper

12/30/13 1:00pm

Hall and Hill don't qualify; Mangum hasn't played yet

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:01pm

Why don't they qualify?

viper

12/30/13 1:03pm

Then remove Pitta. And I don't know that you can count Harline for Crowton

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:04pm

This whole thread is about who is a better recruiter

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:14pm

A great number of Bronco's recruits...

BaYoU

12/30/13 1:02pm

Of Bronco's fourth class, I believe 7 will play next year.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:08pm

Bronco peaked in years 2-5

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:16pm

Coincidentally, years 6-9 was when the No. 1 recruit in the nation didn't

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:18pm

Neither did most of the top 20 qbs of that class

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:23pm

Sorry but it is a lot more difficult for BYU to recover from a top recruit not

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:28pm

What about when Olson didn't come back from his mission?

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:34pm

Good point. I would argue that in a sense we were bailed out by Max Hall.

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:51pm

It was a blessing in disguise

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:58pm

At the end of the day

Posting on CougarBoard