Hall and Hill were transfers who self-recruited to BYU

Report problem with this ad

Dec 30, 2013
1:38:49pm

donnerstag

Hall and Hill were transfers who self-recruited to BYU

after the Stanford coach bolted and ASU had a crowded qb position. Anae was a high injury risk recruit who doesn't belong on the list after playing a couple games. The credit for the Reynolds brothers belong to their father. There was a 3rd Reynolds brother that could be added to Crowton's list as an All-MWC center, but I will include none of those.

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Jun 2, 2024
Total posts: 39,181 (684 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Crowton versus Bronco recruits on offense

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:28pm

Big difference is oline.

RaggaeCoug

12/30/13 12:30pm

But we were in such a good position at OL that the coach felt it was fine to

foofcoug

12/30/13 12:34pm

13 signed in the previous 3 years.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:59pm

and tight end

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:45pm

At least be fair and include Max Hall, Harvy Unga, Matt & Houston Reynolds,

showmecoug

12/30/13 12:52pm

Pitta was a preferred walk on; I gave Bronco credit for Falslev

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:04pm

In other words you will use whatever criteria you want to support your argument.

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:10pm

Preferred walk-on just means he didn't believe in him enough to give him a

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:11pm

Crowton still recruited him, just like Bronco recruited Falslev and Rich

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:20pm

Yes, and Bronco still recruited the Reynolds brothers, Famika Anae, Hall, & Hill

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:25pm

Hall and Hill were transfers who self-recruited to BYU

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:38pm

I don't know that I'd call running backs a wash

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:55pm

Hine has done next to nothing at running back

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:13pm

And Brathwaite had one long run and got kicked out.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:17pm

Was it an 800 yard run?

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:19pm

No, but it was about 98 - so about 1/8 of his total yards in one run.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:49pm

Crowton made the mistake of not emphasizing the HC enough to his

Zaphod

12/30/13 12:33pm

That, and trying to force BYU personnel into an unproven & unrealistic mold.

Mantis Mutu

12/30/13 12:44pm

Difference in recruiting or development of players?

Pasadena

12/30/13 12:34pm

Both, agree on both.

Heinz57

12/30/13 12:37pm

You have a very large number of good players missing from your list . . .

viper

12/30/13 12:45pm

Which players would that be?

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:46pm

Van Noy, for one

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:52pm

Got it. You just listed offensive recruits

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 12:54pm

I may start another thread comparing the defenses

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:17pm

First of all, this was just an offensive overview

donnerstag

12/30/13 12:58pm

Even just at QB, aren't you missing Hall, Hill, Mangum?

viper

12/30/13 1:00pm

Hall and Hill don't qualify; Mangum hasn't played yet

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:01pm

Why don't they qualify?

viper

12/30/13 1:03pm

Then remove Pitta. And I don't know that you can count Harline for Crowton

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:04pm

This whole thread is about who is a better recruiter

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:14pm

A great number of Bronco's recruits...

BaYoU

12/30/13 1:02pm

Of Bronco's fourth class, I believe 7 will play next year.

SoCalCoug

12/30/13 1:08pm

Bronco peaked in years 2-5

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:16pm

Coincidentally, years 6-9 was when the No. 1 recruit in the nation didn't

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:18pm

Neither did most of the top 20 qbs of that class

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:23pm

Sorry but it is a lot more difficult for BYU to recover from a top recruit not

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:28pm

What about when Olson didn't come back from his mission?

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:34pm

Good point. I would argue that in a sense we were bailed out by Max Hall.

showmecoug

12/30/13 1:51pm

It was a blessing in disguise

donnerstag

12/30/13 1:58pm

At the end of the day

checoug

4/17/14 2:49pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad