This died off yesterday.

Apr 15, 2014
10:19:42am

southernfriedcougar

This is all from a fan's perspective and not worth it. We shouldn't pretend to know what is best for the coaches. The only thing ridiculous is that we pretend to know why they make the decisions they make, and that our choices are better.

Report problem with this ad

southernfriedcougar

Previous username: cougidaho
New username: Lip Gallagher
Bio page: southernfriedcougar
Joined: Apr 26, 2013
Last login: Apr 10, 2017
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It's ridiculous that BYU never offered Porter Gustin when he was theirs.

BYU81

4/15/14 10:11am

It is ridiculous that Gustin's dad lies about New Port being ready to committ...

Goatnapper'96

4/15/14 10:12am

This again. How are you related?

coolblue

4/15/14 11:10am

Sorry, Meant for BYU 81

coolblue

4/15/14 11:11am

How do you KNOW this?

choppercoug

4/15/14 12:01pm

He obviously has insider info. I'd trust it.

Mantis Mutu

4/15/14 2:36pm

Well, his "insider" info is wrong then.

choppercoug

4/15/14 11:16pm

Seems accurate to me. Maybe Gustin's family should stop the public campaign.

kccougar

4/16/14 9:08am

How are the Gustin's doing any sort of public campaign? By Porter

choppercoug

4/16/14 2:00pm

Read this:

icecougar

4/15/14 3:00pm

Out of curiosity, where do you come by this info?

Real Men Wear Blue

4/15/14 3:29pm

I agree. BYU absolutely needs more kids and parents who throw a fit when they

byubyu

4/15/14 10:13am

what do you know about the situation that everyone else doesn't?

riboflavin

4/15/14 10:14am

Maybe Bronco and staff think he is overrated

Dr T-bone

4/15/14 10:14am

I miss the Crowton years too.

kccougar

4/15/14 10:14am

He is a LB prospect, right? We already have sedgwick, kaufusi and tafua, with

michacoug

4/15/14 10:18am

We don't have a chance with Masina, unfortunately.

JDBlue

4/15/14 10:21am

Trust me.....

Goatnapper'96

4/15/14 10:24am

Not to speculate, but did Van Noy had off-field issues also.

BYU81

4/15/14 10:28am

No, in this case you are pretty much blind.

kccougar

4/15/14 10:30am

You're also just a fan. Let the coaches be the coaches. You actually

southernfriedcougar

4/15/14 10:31am

And KVN had to delay his enrollment a year because of those issues....

BengalCougar

4/15/14 10:31am

And he was willing to delay his enrollment which shows his humility and his

bvfcr

4/15/14 11:44am

He did.

Goatnapper'96

4/15/14 10:40am

Please don't be so arrogant to assume that you tipped anyone off, Did you...

BengalCougar

4/15/14 10:51am

No.

Goatnapper'96

4/15/14 10:57am

What is his posse thinking? Nobody breaks Bronco by intimidation, but by

HoustonCougar

4/15/14 10:53am

Anyone who puts yewtah on a level with notre dame, Wisconsin and Washington

travelcoug

4/15/14 11:04am

RE: Not to speculate, but did Van Noy had off-field issues also.

Paysoncoug88

4/15/14 11:40am

not an apples to apples comparison...

icecougar

4/15/14 3:11pm

It's ridiculous that some people don't realize BYU might have very good....

BengalCougar

4/15/14 10:18am

Too late, his widdow tushie got hurt, it was either that or his fee-fees.

ByuMba90

4/15/14 10:21am

In the recruiting game, timing is everything

donnerstag

4/15/14 10:33am

That might be the case. But if Gustin wants an offer from BYU he probably...

BengalCougar

4/15/14 10:37am

No, it's not everything. In some cases it matters. In most, it doesn't.

Freddie Cougar

4/15/14 10:46am

This died off yesterday.

southernfriedcougar

4/15/14 10:19am

<< Deleted >>

UCB Coug

4/15/14 10:33am

Don't raise the question if you don't want to hear the defenses.

QuinneyCoug

4/15/14 10:39am

When people post stuff like this based on incomplete information and lots

QuinneyCoug

4/15/14 10:22am

BYU just felt like Gustin was coming on too strong, we like to be courted a

John Chiara

4/15/14 10:25am

What is ridiculous is that BYU hasn't offered Keiffer Longson yet.

flavordave

4/15/14 10:34am

I agree, though it may be too late. He has some great offers. He is a perfect

michacoug

4/15/14 10:52am

So, your assumption is our staff are idiots? incompentent, don't know how to

bald man

4/15/14 10:40am

We've all heard how Bronco doesn't care about recruiting stars. How is

BYU81

4/15/14 10:44am

He doesn't, and neither does any other coach in College Football. But they all..

BengalCougar

4/15/14 10:47am

I don't understand the bitterness so many have here.

bald man

4/15/14 11:07am

You have selective vision and/or selective comprehension

HoustonCougar

4/15/14 10:47am

This situation is way too convoluted for this kind of reaction.

Shimmy

4/15/14 11:27am

Has it really been a decade since BYU71 signed up for CB?

UneducatedFan

4/15/14 11:35am

Wit the defenses Bronco has put on the table the last few years, Ill trust his

BE-WHY-YOU

4/16/14 2:07pm

Not if he wasn't good enough to beat the other guys signed or being recruited.

Posting on CougarBoard