...and brought it into this discussion and attributed it to me.

Why? Because you seem stuck on this idea that I'm saying Bronco can't be questioned or that he doesn't make mistakes.

And I've repeated several times that I believe he does. You've said that I say you can't question his decisions. And I say that you can - but that there are certain things you are questioning that you will never get an answer to. And if you can't get the answer to that question, then at that point you have to decide if you lean more towards trusting or distrusting. I tend to lean more towards trusting. You seem to lean more towards distrusting. Whatever - just differing opinions.

As for Goatnapper - my take on his comment is that he gets that the honor code is and always will be an issue at BYU that drives recruitment decisions. He doesn't agree with that approach, but it isn't worth getting worked up over because it isn't going to change. The honor code isn't going anywhere.

Sorry about the use of hyperbole regarding positive versus negative. It just seems that of all the things to question about Bronco, this particular case/kid isn't the one to hang your had on. And I stand by the assertion that Bronco/BYU is never going to tell us why they aren't offering a kid - some some questions are unproductive to ask.