No offense, but if someone said they turned down a full ride at Harvard for a similar scholarship at BYU...I would question their sanity. I could maybe understand it...if they really wanted to go to BYU for religious reasons or something like that...but would still think it was a poor decision.
Unless you just couldn't manage to convince yourself to leave Logan for personal reasons, why would you accept a scholarship at an inferior school? And before you jump all over me for being rude or arrogant or whatever...we can just agree that by every measurable objective criteria, and by all of the neural third party rankings....BYU is a superior school.