Why do you mention the Scouring of the Shire when it was cut?

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Mar 30, 2015
3:16:05pm

byujacob

Why do you mention the Scouring of the Shire when it was cut?

Report problem with this ad

byujacob

New username: jacobugath
Bio page: byujacob
Joined: Apr 15, 2008
Last login: Sep 28, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I'd like to hear reasons for why ROTK is better than TT.

byujacob

3/30/15 3:04pm

It was epic!

bushy7

3/30/15 3:06pm

Or was it epic-er?

byujacob

3/30/15 3:06pm

It contains fewer heinous story changes

CoopDizz

3/30/15 3:10pm

Paths of the Dead, no Entmoot, Sam in Minas Ithil, Scouring of the Shire

GuitarGuy

3/30/15 3:10pm

Why do you mention the Scouring of the Shire when it was cut?

byujacob

3/30/15 3:16pm

Never said it was movie-only anywhere. I prefer the books.

GuitarGuy

3/30/15 5:01pm

You're right. My bad. I assumed since people saw me linking the previous thread

byujacob

3/30/15 6:23pm

Agree with GuitarGuy. Are you referring to the eagles specifically?

flavordave

3/30/15 3:12pm

No I'm referring to the Battle at Pelennor Fields and the Dead Men of Dunharrow.

byujacob

3/30/15 3:15pm

I can agree with that.

flavordave

3/30/15 3:16pm

No, no, no, no, no

CoopDizz

3/30/15 3:18pm

I'll agree to disagree with you there.

byujacob

3/30/15 3:22pm

From a storytelling standpoint, it's better to have contrasts and foils

CoopDizz

3/30/15 3:30pm

Calm down. No one said anything about knowing more than anyone else.

byujacob

3/30/15 3:36pm

I'm fine. When you're an author making a general statement about writing . . .

CoopDizz

3/30/15 3:46pm

That's fair enough, but I am not a film maker, and I was referring to the film

byujacob

3/30/15 3:52pm

'preciate the clarification

CoopDizz

3/30/15 3:55pm

Yeah I don't like how Faramir tries to take them to Gondor. It cracks me up when

ByuImaginesDragons

3/31/15 1:01am

That's a good point about the ghosts, never thought of that

ByuImaginesDragons

3/31/15 12:58am

Never underestimate Tolkien purist rage

Deadpool

3/30/15 3:15pm

True. See my response to flavordave.

byujacob

3/30/15 3:16pm

Eagles, Trees, Dead Army, Eagles, Eagles, Eagles, ManBear

Sandstone Cougar

3/30/15 3:20pm

Would've been nice to have a scene with Tauriel and Fili/Kili? holding hands and

byujacob

3/30/15 3:27pm

. . . until Jack and Sawyer show up, putting Tauriel in a dilemma spanning 110

Sandstone Cougar

3/30/15 3:34pm

They had enough of elf/dwarf love triangle in Hobbit *rolls eyes*

ByuImaginesDragons

3/31/15 1:07am

Because the TT was a bridge movie. A very good one, but still a bridge.

3/30/15 4:31pm

Interesting thoughts.

byujacob

3/30/15 6:25pm

Yeah, but Empire Strikes Back.

Shimmy

3/30/15 6:30pm

I don't know...but I liked RotK the best. Maybe had more emotions I could relate

ByuImaginesDragons

3/31/15 12:56am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad