I agree. Steve Young's legacy is secure.

Report problem with this ad

Jun 24, 2016
12:12:43pm

shakarocks All-American

Report problem with this ad

shakarocks

Bio page: shakarocks
Joined: Dec 2, 2004
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 14,821 (399 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

RE: Tanner > Taysom

capo

6/24/16 8:24am

They're both talented. But who has picked up Detmer's new system more quickly?

WDaddy

6/24/16 8:27am

That is the funny thing - neither has ever run a pro-style system

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 8:31am

Taysom ran Doman's pro style offense his freshman year. Full spring, summer, and

pinolero

6/24/16 8:53am

I suppose. But can we classify Doman's system as a system?

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 9:22am

the one that has played

capo

6/24/16 8:31am

I'll take a senior over a sophomore.

Belboz

6/24/16 8:29am

An argument could be made that Tanner is better at killing a defense downfield

SpiffCoug

6/24/16 8:33am

We'll never know, but I think the Michigan game would look different with Hill.

Belboz

6/24/16 8:38am

The Michigan safeties would have at least had to play different. It could have

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 8:43am

It wouldn't have just been the safeties that would have had to play different.

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 8:53am

I think BYU would have been more likely to score.

Belboz

6/24/16 9:07am

Defenses can't play that tight man and turn their backs to the QB

RaggaeCoug

6/24/16 8:44am

Our WRs sure weren't ready for that game. I was impressed

mantis mutu

6/24/16 10:37am

Only if Mangum has gotten the problem of under throwing his receiver out of his

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 8:42am

RE: Only if Mangum has gotten the problem of under throwing his receiver out of

SpiffCoug

6/24/16 9:02am

Funny how stats can tell a slightly different story than what really happened

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 9:07am

The stats I showed say nothing on 50/50 throws.

SpiffCoug

6/24/16 9:31am

The 50-50 balls are a good explanation for those 2 stats. With those two stats

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 10:16am

Those looked designed to me. If you overthrow there is a 0/100 chance. But when

Ash

6/24/16 9:59am

Uhh no. Not by design.

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 10:07am

Seemed to me he was throwing the ball a teammate and put the ball in a spot

SpiffCoug

6/24/16 10:11am

Of course he knew to whom he was throwing but under throwing was not by design.

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 10:27am

Freshman Tanner was 1 read and throw deep. Just like freshman

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 10:20am

Yes many were

shakarocks

6/24/16 12:10pm

Throwing a timing route to the outside edge and asking Mitch to go up and get it

The Dude Abides

6/24/16 12:35pm

I hate to point this out

shakarocks

6/24/16 12:39pm

Another thing...

provodude84606

6/24/16 12:58pm

It isn't a half against Nebraska. Taysom was a better throwing QB against better

JamesWestfall

6/24/16 1:26pm

The latest samples???

Jeffe

6/24/16 1:41pm

I think Latest sample means Taysom's Jr and Sr years. Many point to his Soph

viper

6/24/16 2:23pm

You're relying solely on stats

shakarocks

6/25/16 11:44am

Not sure they are similar in talent right now. I think Taysom is better

Dangerous

6/24/16 8:30am

They will both play.

Blue Print

6/24/16 8:32am

It is best for the program to have

travelcoug

6/24/16 8:46am

Funny how everyone says this.

whoneedscorners?

6/24/16 9:07am

The problem with comparisons: they are best spuds

Y4LYFE

6/24/16 9:08am

Tanner's Pros

johnnycrash

6/24/16 9:29am

Also, Tanner has played in more games in 1 season than TH has in 3

Y4LYFE

6/24/16 9:50am

Yes, if you exclude half of Taysom's games, then yes, that is less than Tanners

viper

6/24/16 11:06am

Winning > anything else. Taysom gives us the best chance vs THIS schedule.

Ash

6/24/16 10:03am

That is your opinion.

Jeffe

6/24/16 10:18am

I would agree

shakarocks

6/24/16 12:11pm

Also, Tanner has won more games against a more difficult schedule than Taysom

Jeffe

6/24/16 10:39am

Agree ^^^

provodude84606

6/24/16 10:48am

RE: Tanner > Taysom

bIeedcougarblue

6/24/16 9:39am

I think Tanner has plenty of upside but I think Taysom is better right now

Jericho

6/24/16 9:41am

Agree, Tanner > Taysom

provodude84606

6/24/16 10:37am

The most athletically gifted qb to ever play at byu

webster242

6/24/16 12:03pm

I agree. Steve Young's legacy is secure.

shakarocks

6/24/16 12:12pm

Steve Young would disagree with you

webster242

6/24/16 12:27pm

Steve Young is being nice

shakarocks

6/24/16 12:32pm

Most athletically gifted QB to...

provodude84606

6/24/16 12:49pm

except they are not similar. Taysom is better.

Kerbouchard

6/24/16 11:03am

....and assuming Tanner has not improved since last season.

Jeffe

6/24/16 11:26am

"Tanner comes before Taysom alphabetically, so he should start." -Ken M

Posting on CougarBoard