Fair, but each of them approached their job similarly. All but Christian were

Aug 25, 2016
9:23:17pm

CougarPilot All-American

high ranking recruits coming into the program. As such, each could have taken their ball and left like another highly acclaimed QB, but they didn't.

Report problem with this ad

CougarPilot

New username: BYUSwoop
Bio page: CougarPilot
Joined: Jul 21, 2011
Last login: Sep 8, 2016
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Tanner Mangum, James Lark, Christian Stewart, Jason Munns; we have had a rash of

CougarPilot

8/25/16 9:02pm

None of those guys is in the same galaxy as Mangum IMO

MHOP

8/25/16 9:02pm

it is just a strange turn of events that put him in this position

Y05

8/25/16 9:05pm

Well in one way he was prepared to sit last season

Beggar

8/25/16 9:07pm

Exactly

LV Mike

8/25/16 9:11pm

Yeah, you really can't complain if you have the potential to be a 3 year starter

buffgato

8/26/16 7:26am

I agree. Those other guys wouldn't be starters on a decent d1 team and Mangum is headed to the NFL one day.

RdF3

8/25/16 9:11pm

Agree about Mangum... Disagree about Lark. Dude should have started over Nelson - Bronco blew that decision.

46in96

8/25/16 9:23pm

I guess that's what I'm basing my opinion off of, that he couldn't start of Riley. Because Riley was mediocre.

RdF3

8/25/16 9:24pm

He didn't start over Riley because Bronco had a serious man crush on Riley. Bronco's decision there wasn't talent based.

46in96

8/25/16 9:33pm

You watched the bowl game right?

ALC

8/25/16 11:26pm

You realize Lark never got first team reps, right?

flyusaf

8/26/16 8:03am

Exactly - he was never given a fair shake with the first team to get better and show what he could do... the guy had

46in96

8/26/16 3:43pm

Lark looked pretty horrible in the bowl game as a 7th year senior. Don't think he was ever very good.

mulletYno

8/25/16 9:27pm

We got to see a some good play from him and some very mediocre play (bowl game).

RebelScum

8/25/16 9:39pm

Given how poor the QB play was from 2010-12 the fact that Lark couldn't beat out Nelson or Heaps says much about Lark.

SpiffCoug

8/26/16 7:38am

Disagree about Christian (and Lark) I think he could have become a good D1 QB if

ptcougr

8/25/16 10:22pm

Fair, but each of them approached their job similarly. All but Christian were

CougarPilot

8/25/16 9:23pm

Sorensen bolted and got himself a nice NFL paycheck because of it.

Cheap Seats

8/25/16 9:54pm

I agree about QB development...it was stunted by coaching decisions.

CougarPilot

8/25/16 11:09pm

but if he had stayed wouldn't he have had s shot because of the injuries?

Y05

8/26/16 1:14pm

Christian Stewart had very comparable stats to Mangum FWIW

Dissenter

8/25/16 11:25pm

good point, but Stewart was a senior and Mangum was a Fresh-barely off mission

cougsoldier

8/25/16 11:39pm

this is true, I was merely saying Christian Stewart deserves more credit

Dissenter

8/26/16 7:26am

But Christian played a much easier schedule than Tanner?

Princess Jasmine

8/26/16 1:40am

I think Jason Beck is my favorite of all time. Came in, got beat out, and stayed. Tanner knew he would be next AFTER

indocoug

8/25/16 11:16pm

Agree with Ja. Beck. He was better than John IMO.

Big Time 55

8/26/16 7:23am

I love this thread

Richw

8/26/16 5:53am

If we're talking about respect, Brendan Gaskins gets my vote

buffgato

8/26/16 12:26pm

Didn't know his story...but we can add him to the list

Posting on CougarBoard