Disagree about Christian (and Lark) I think he could have become a good D1 QB if

Aug 25, 2016
10:22:39pm

ptcougr Playmaker

he had been groomed as a Frosh and gotten good back-up reps & minutes as a Soph & Junior then started as a Junior or Senior. Maybe not great, but at least average or above average.

Report problem with this ad

ptcougr

Bio page: ptcougr
Joined: Aug 21, 2003
Last login: May 6, 2024
Total posts: 5,237 (164 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Tanner Mangum, James Lark, Christian Stewart, Jason Munns; we have had a rash of

CougarPilot

8/25/16 9:02pm

None of those guys is in the same galaxy as Mangum IMO

MHOP

8/25/16 9:02pm

it is just a strange turn of events that put him in this position

Y05

8/25/16 9:05pm

Well in one way he was prepared to sit last season

Beggar

8/25/16 9:07pm

Exactly

LV Mike

8/25/16 9:11pm

Yeah, you really can't complain if you have the potential to be a 3 year starter

buffgato

8/26/16 7:26am

I agree. Those other guys wouldn't be starters on a decent d1 team and Mangum is headed to the NFL one day.

RdF3

8/25/16 9:11pm

Agree about Mangum... Disagree about Lark. Dude should have started over Nelson - Bronco blew that decision.

46in96

8/25/16 9:23pm

I guess that's what I'm basing my opinion off of, that he couldn't start of Riley. Because Riley was mediocre.

RdF3

8/25/16 9:24pm

He didn't start over Riley because Bronco had a serious man crush on Riley. Bronco's decision there wasn't talent based.

46in96

8/25/16 9:33pm

You watched the bowl game right?

ALC

8/25/16 11:26pm

You realize Lark never got first team reps, right?

flyusaf

8/26/16 8:03am

Exactly - he was never given a fair shake with the first team to get better and show what he could do... the guy had

46in96

8/26/16 3:43pm

Lark looked pretty horrible in the bowl game as a 7th year senior. Don't think he was ever very good.

mulletYno

8/25/16 9:27pm

We got to see a some good play from him and some very mediocre play (bowl game).

RebelScum

8/25/16 9:39pm

Given how poor the QB play was from 2010-12 the fact that Lark couldn't beat out Nelson or Heaps says much about Lark.

SpiffCoug

8/26/16 7:38am

Disagree about Christian (and Lark) I think he could have become a good D1 QB if

ptcougr

8/25/16 10:22pm

Fair, but each of them approached their job similarly. All but Christian were

CougarPilot

8/25/16 9:23pm

Sorensen bolted and got himself a nice NFL paycheck because of it.

Cheap Seats

8/25/16 9:54pm

I agree about QB development...it was stunted by coaching decisions.

CougarPilot

8/25/16 11:09pm

but if he had stayed wouldn't he have had s shot because of the injuries?

Y05

8/26/16 1:14pm

Christian Stewart had very comparable stats to Mangum FWIW

Dissenter

8/25/16 11:25pm

good point, but Stewart was a senior and Mangum was a Fresh-barely off mission

cougsoldier

8/25/16 11:39pm

this is true, I was merely saying Christian Stewart deserves more credit

Dissenter

8/26/16 7:26am

But Christian played a much easier schedule than Tanner?

Princess Jasmine

8/26/16 1:40am

I think Jason Beck is my favorite of all time. Came in, got beat out, and stayed. Tanner knew he would be next AFTER

indocoug

8/25/16 11:16pm

Agree with Ja. Beck. He was better than John IMO.

Big Time 55

8/26/16 7:23am

I love this thread

Richw

8/26/16 5:53am

If we're talking about respect, Brendan Gaskins gets my vote

buffgato

8/26/16 12:26pm

Didn't know his story...but we can add him to the list

Posting on CougarBoard