Wow

Oct 24, 2016
6:05:13pm

Coug-Ida 3rd String

Wow

That's quite a history! You must be even older than me. Haha! I only remember starting with Wilson.

Very good history review, I enjoyed reading it.

Report problem with this ad

Coug-Ida

Previous username: bden
Bio page: Coug-Ida
Joined: May 28, 2014
Last login: May 3, 2024
Total posts: 1,126 (11 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I'm worried that some of the Tanner practice rumors might be true.

mudpupper

10/24/16 10:38am

If so, Ty better dumb down the O by next year

Hinta

10/24/16 10:40am

"Keep it simple stupid." Great words by coach Edwards about his offenses.

Holy Driver

10/24/16 12:06pm

I thought that was Michael Scott that said that?

Circaman12

10/24/16 2:23pm

Why be worried about it? There's still a ton of practice/development

Indy Coug

10/24/16 10:42am

Agree and I have said sitting helps Tanner

blucoug18

10/24/16 10:58am

here's what we know. Taysom has struggled mightily. Ty Detmer knows

smokymountainrain

10/24/16 10:44am

Or they're sticking with Taysom out of loyalty... that's my hope

Ulysses14

10/24/16 2:31pm

I doubt they are true. And even if they are true, I think that gives us even more reason to play Tanner...

BengalCougar

10/24/16 10:50am

and some guys are just gamers.

smokymountainrain

10/24/16 10:52am

True.

BengalCougar

10/24/16 11:03am

Have to recruit to your system

Gibbcoug

10/24/16 10:55am

Rolled right and threw jump balls.....

shakarocks

10/24/16 10:56am

You're both right IMO

Mises

10/24/16 11:53am

They were very very common but yes he did do a lot of other really good things.

Dillinger

10/24/16 11:54am

I'm not going to believe any "rumors" until I see it on the field... Rumors

crm48

10/24/16 10:57am

Even if true, he had a few games he'll get reps and an entire offseason to learn

cougaman

10/24/16 10:59am

"Tanner is probably a much better pure passer than Taysom." If this were true

mantis mutu

10/24/16 11:06am

Tanner has the benefit of having more time to learn the system and

mellomike

10/24/16 11:06am

Anyone that says it is better to stand on the sidelines to learn a new offense

OGSuperfan

10/24/16 11:16am

That approach worked wonderfully for decades for BYU in the past

Indy Coug

10/24/16 11:17am

When you had a QB in front that was performing admirably and the waiting QB

OGSuperfan

10/24/16 11:19am

Until he gets hurt. Season is over anyway. Sit him.

Ktar

10/24/16 12:55pm

This happens all the time in the NFL.

Blue for Life

10/24/16 3:22pm

I don't put a lot of credence into that; Tanner played great last year

OGSuperfan

10/24/16 11:12am

How about that pass to Kurtz during Boise? He catches that, touchdown.

Linkcoug

10/24/16 7:12pm

Some of Taysom's problems have been because the WRs haven't grasped the offense.

El Jefe

10/24/16 11:24am

Not sure I agree with that.

Jeffe

10/24/16 1:42pm

The coaches have repeatedly said it.

Mises

10/24/16 4:27pm

Coaches have said that the WR's aren't grasping the system?

Jeffe

10/24/16 7:13pm

Who knows what is true, but no QB is going to come into his first year in this

Freddie Cougar

10/24/16 11:27am

Which is even more of a reason we should have Tanner start getting game reps

crm48

10/24/16 11:33am

We have been told what a complete gym rat Tanner is. Are we to now

coastcat

10/24/16 3:42pm

I don't know what that has to do with whether he's grasping the offense

Freddie Cougar

10/24/16 3:49pm

Tanner is an elite quarterback. Trust the process.

Heath Squashwell

10/24/16 11:54am

I don't believe those rumors for 1 second. Coming into the season both QBs were

Super Chicken

10/24/16 12:00pm

I struggle to think of other reasons why Tanner wouldn't be playing right now

BYU Fan

10/24/16 1:28pm

It's likely as simple as coaches not thinking TH is playing as poorly as you do.

Super Chicken

10/24/16 5:50pm

Haven't read all the other responses, so I'm sure some of this ground is covered. However, this worry is greatly

CalGTR

10/24/16 12:02pm

Aaron Rodgers vs Andrew Luck

BoilerCoug

10/24/16 12:31pm

Meant to respond to OP

BoilerCoug

10/24/16 12:32pm

That's OK - you help bolster one of my points.

CalGTR

10/24/16 12:39pm

It also helps when you have a hall of famer that is starting in front of you...

crm48

10/24/16 12:46pm

Not comparable

Shteve

10/24/16 2:08pm

They're not true or accurate- just flimsy rumors

ZooBlue

10/24/16 12:45pm

Some of this sounds like TH? no?

Cougstreak

10/24/16 12:55pm

I've read detmers O is simpler. We can make all troupes of arguments

zerome4sooners

10/24/16 1:08pm

I'm much more worried about O-line improvement than I am

QBarrister

10/24/16 1:20pm

I also want to see our wide open WRs catch the ball every time.

Yunit

10/24/16 7:04pm

In what universe would Tanner struggle more than Taysom with a passing scheme?

jomo

10/24/16 1:08pm

In the Crappy OL Universe. Of course we've never heard of that universe.

CougarThug

10/24/16 4:22pm

nope, make pre-snap read, hit quick-slant or out, flaring back, TE... try again

jomo

10/24/16 6:09pm

Who cares about practice reports.

Jeffe

10/24/16 1:31pm

I mostly agree

Coug-Ida

10/24/16 2:29pm

I don't think the separation was for the reasons many suggest.

Jeffe

10/24/16 7:20pm

Total Bunk!

Elvis

10/24/16 1:34pm

Insiders have also posted BYU to Big 12 is going to happen

jes2332

10/24/16 1:36pm

Recent practice observation.

Coug-Ida

10/24/16 1:37pm

Well duh. Taysom is running the first team offense.

Jeffe

10/24/16 1:47pm

<< Deleted >>

Coug-Ida

10/24/16 2:20pm

Obviously

Coug-Ida

10/24/16 2:23pm

Rolled right and threw jump balls over and over??? LOL

chazen

10/24/16 1:51pm

Guys on the Royal Blue Podcast w/Brian Logan and crew confirmed this on

Frank Left

10/24/16 2:45pm

I call BS. Tanner will be awesome...

BYU4eVeR

10/24/16 3:31pm

For those that remember in the heyday of BYU passing offense - it took years for

Zenoch

10/24/16 3:57pm

Actually that's not really true

CougarThug

10/24/16 5:01pm

Wow

Coug-Ida

10/24/16 6:05pm

Excellent,, Thug. Thanks for bringing facts, history and perspective. Throw in

coastcat

10/24/16 8:32pm

Let's see now...

CougarThug

10/24/16 4:13pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

10/24/16 4:19pm

These rumors strike me as attempts at revisionist history. Taysom just had to be named the starter and coaches just had

SpiffCoug

10/24/16 4:27pm

He is going to declare early to can't understand the offense?

Cougstreak

10/24/16 4:38pm

Perhaps he can't understand the offense as it is currently being executed.

CougarThug

10/24/16 5:02pm

Others QB's can but Tanner can't?

Cougstreak

10/24/16 5:12pm

Great post...it just needed a few small changes. Done. Much better...Enjoy

LumberCoug

10/24/16 5:16pm

I'm so sick of this narrative...TANNER STARTED 12 GAMES LAST YEAR and did well

palangi

10/24/16 5:43pm

Just like insiders said BYU was in the Big 12. I don't believe anyone who gives

TutumTeRoboreReddam

10/24/16 8:42pm

I heard last year he struggled with telling right from left. Kept rolling out

JoeMamaBesser

10/24/16 9:31pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad