Not sure of time line, but Eathyn Manumaleauna seemed to play forever.

Apr 5, 2017
9:46:03am

CosmoK All-American

He went on a mission between his sophomore and junior year, but I think there were other factors (red shirts or grey shirts) that extended his time at BYU to the point where you wondered how.

Report problem with this ad

CosmoK

New username: Madam Pattirini
Bio page: CosmoK
Joined: Jun 21, 2003
Last login: Jul 28, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Just for fun head to head personnel comparison between BYU and Utah. O-line 1st

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:00pm

Utah o-line vs BYU d-line

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:00pm

Handsome?

jkccoug

4/4/17 3:12pm

Handsome quit football

CougarBacker

4/4/17 3:16pm

Serious?

Chester Copperpot

4/4/17 3:17pm

on April 1st

dex13

4/4/17 3:17pm

Pretty sure that was a joke my friend

jkccoug

4/4/17 3:21pm

RE: Pretty sure that was a joke my friend

JohnnyComeLately

4/4/17 3:43pm

Dude!!! Sarcasm!!!!

The Dude Abides

4/4/17 3:19pm

Oh man! What would I do without you?

CougarBacker

4/4/17 3:35pm

RE: Oh man! What would I do without you?

RyneK

4/4/17 3:50pm

He's projected right now as a backup, but yeah, he adds great depth.

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:32pm

I don't think he will be backing anyone up come August.

BYUHgrad

4/4/17 5:11pm

RE: Utah o-line vs BYU d-line

BigT801

4/4/17 5:44pm

BYU D-line will have the edge against Utah's O-line that early in the year

BrutustheBrash

4/4/17 10:18pm

Hopefully we can hang onto the ball. Fumbles have killed us and lost us

conetah

4/4/17 10:40pm

I don't think you can blame turnovers for the loss last year.

Byu_1988

4/5/17 12:13am

yes you can. We started the game with Hifo batting a pass up in the air....

icecougar

4/5/17 6:18pm

(I'll post the other positions later)

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:01pm

I think your goggles are blue, but didn't know Utah OL lost so many.

CosmoK

4/4/17 3:04pm

Show me how my goggles are blue.

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:30pm

You've accounted for BYU's experience. What's still TBD is the talent

Diablo and Doc

4/4/17 3:37pm

That's comparing the old BYU staff to the the current Utah staff

cougarmanguy

4/4/17 3:40pm

Exactly, you can't extrapolate out too far with the new coaching staffs.

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:50pm

Agree to a point, but a lot of the started are Bronco's recruits and werr

Diablo and Doc

4/4/17 3:58pm

Thats fine, as long as Kalani gets a clean slate away from Bronco

cougarmanguy

4/4/17 4:10pm

Fair enough.

Diablo and Doc

4/4/17 6:00pm

The ute counterargument would be that they were so stacked at D line last year

monkeycowboy

4/4/17 3:04pm

I think you are forgetting about a couple of Utes on the D-Line

sunspot

4/4/17 3:07pm

Lowell who in fact was totally neutralized by Tejan

cougarmanguy

4/4/17 3:08pm

Injury to Lowell or not, Tejan was the third highest rated center in the country

cougarmanguy

4/4/17 3:10pm

I'm going off of what BlockU has for the depth chart.

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:31pm

One rule of advice.

JustmeintheSLC

4/4/17 4:30pm

Oh I agree. This isn't meant to be serious. It's just a fun run down of who is

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:45pm

Fitts. Tupai. Fotu.

formerly utesplease

4/4/17 11:44pm

Still trying to figure out how Fitts gets another year

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:31am

Not sure of time line, but Eathyn Manumaleauna seemed to play forever.

CosmoK

4/5/17 9:46am

He never redshirted for non medical reasons

BYU '80

4/6/17 11:01pm

RE: Still trying to figure out how Fitts gets another year

JustmeintheSLC

4/7/17 11:19pm

What about the issue of having already redshirted

BYU '80

4/8/17 8:52am

No, the issue revolves around the PAC-12's intra-conference transfer rules.

Scratch

4/8/17 9:54am

RE: What about the issue of having already redshirted

JustmeintheSLC

4/8/17 1:37pm

You still haven't addressed the fact he has had

BYU '80

4/8/17 7:48pm

RE: You still haven't addressed the fact he has had

JustmeintheSLC

4/8/17 8:04pm

No different than many other cases

BYU '80

4/8/17 8:41pm

Can you please cite to any other case where someone had only been out of high

Scratch

4/8/17 9:56pm

We get both Lowell Lotulelei and Kylie Fitts back

NarfUte

4/4/17 3:07pm

I believe Fitts will be playing with a medical waiver granted.

southernfriedcougar

4/4/17 3:10pm

Ridiculous that Fitts gets a medical waiver if true

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:33am

RE: Ridiculous that Fitts gets a medical waiver if true

JustmeintheSLC

4/5/17 7:28am

Uh, neither are ridiculous but Hill's is more "normal" than Fitts.

southernfriedcougar

4/5/17 7:40am

This is Fitts's 5th year out of high school. He played very limited snaps in

Scratch

4/5/17 8:36am

All of Hills were medical redshirt smart guy

BYU '80

4/6/17 11:03pm

You are forgetting Lotulelei and Fitts. Both coming back.

OPINIONS

4/4/17 3:12pm

Looks like everyone else has it covered.

OPINIONS

4/4/17 3:13pm

I'm just going off of the depth chart that they have at BlockU

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:49pm

I think the match up is a draw. Which is a huge improvement for BYU against Utah the last 10 games.

Turnpike Lane

4/4/17 3:14pm

Utah TE's and RB's vs BYU LB'ers

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:40pm

Utah always gets some good RBs, but I do think life was made easy for them

southernfriedcougar

4/4/17 3:45pm

You're again missing projected starters. I think you're just looking at a spring

Scratch

4/4/17 4:17pm

RE: You're again missing projected starters. I think you're just looking at a

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:46pm

BYU TE's and RB's vs Utah LB'ers

Rise Against

4/4/17 3:48pm

Moroni

Galileo5

4/5/17 10:24am

I mean, I think we should win this year but

Cougarealist

4/4/17 3:54pm

Never is such an unrealistic word

southernfriedcougar

4/4/17 3:58pm

+10000000000000

ALUF 1990

4/4/17 5:36pm

x 0

BlueNtheFace

4/4/17 9:29pm

I mean, we should have won 4 of the last 6 years but that dang deal that

LouisianaCoug

4/5/17 12:42am

<< Deleted >>

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:00pm

BYU wr's vs Utah CB's

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:05pm

Small clarification ... Norman is not a JC transfer. He was a graduate transfer.

ManicBlue

4/4/17 4:07pm

Good point.

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:08pm

Utah WR's vs BYU CB's

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:08pm

The other big factor in this match up, going back to your earlier post, is how

dilbert

4/4/17 4:18pm

Yeah, and if Takitaki and Laulile don't come back we will be seriously lacking

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:43pm

Though Corbin Kaufusi and Pili showed some promise last year.

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:44pm

I think Laulile struggled moving inside and out, but there will be

southernfriedcougar

4/4/17 4:51pm

BYU QB vs Utah safeties

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:14pm

What I'm taking away from this analysis

Diepkloof

4/4/17 4:21pm

You disagree with the analysis? Juco players are wild cards

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:33am

Utah qb vs BYU safeties

Rise Against

4/4/17 4:42pm

This is the matchup that decides the game.

jrj84105

4/13/17 5:13pm

Great breakdown. Love the new emphasis on the lines

Harrison0Yfan

4/4/17 5:24pm

I want to believe, I want to believe, I want to believe. Once the great

CougLuv1

4/4/17 5:28pm

Lol on Dline-Oline

BigT801

4/4/17 5:39pm

Utahs DL will be fantastic. Good luck with that.

ALUF 1990

4/4/17 5:43pm

One dude transfers and now it's a regular thing? Dang you guys are hot stuff.

southernfriedcougar

4/4/17 5:47pm

RE: Utahs DL will be fantastic. Good luck with that.

monkeycowboy

4/4/17 5:52pm

You were accurate until talking about regularly beating usc for kids.

Backcountry

4/4/17 8:07pm

Like that one time you beat USC for Jay Tufele?

BrutustheBrash

4/4/17 10:13pm

RE: Like that one time you beat USC for Jay Tufele?

JustmeintheSLC

4/5/17 12:26am

So twice in the same year is now regularly with no history beyond that

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:37am

You mean like Lauaki, Jaylon Johnson, and Darrin Paulo? That's three years in a

Scratch

4/5/17 8:25am

That's like BYU saying we regularly win recruiting battles with stanford

BrutustheBrash

4/5/17 10:02am

He said "let's see you do that with a Cali kid." I just named 3. That's all I

Scratch

4/5/17 5:45pm

I apologize. It was more in response to previous comments

BrutustheBrash

4/5/17 7:39pm

Yep. Utah will beat out USC occasionally for a recruit, but obviously USC will

Scratch

4/5/17 7:42pm

Regularly do that with USC? You mean once right?

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:35am

Last Category: BYU fans vs Utah fans

BamaCoug

4/4/17 6:30pm

RE: Last Category: BYU fans vs Utah fans

JustmeintheSLC

4/4/17 7:09pm

None of those players are playing this year

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:39am

See attached. 2,684 days and counting

ALUF 1990

4/4/17 7:27pm

Doesn't change the one key factor in my decision tree...

BamaCoug

4/4/17 7:37pm

Must be tough losing over and over to a team that consistently sucks.

cav73

4/5/17 7:42am

Was talking about their fans ...

BamaCoug

4/5/17 1:19pm

Lolz...

cav73

4/6/17 8:28am

Says the guy trying to pick fights on cougarboard lolz

BYU '80

4/6/17 11:04pm

Not trying to pick a fight with you...

cav73

4/11/17 3:30pm

Yeah we shouldn't let yewts on here

BYU '80

4/12/17 9:10pm

RE: Yeah we shouldn't let yewts on here

cav73

4/13/17 4:03pm

You're the one whining about casting pearls before swine

BYU '80

4/13/17 5:25pm

"Utes suck" and always will. #TruthIsTruth

YSeattle

4/5/17 8:54am

If there's one thing I've learned in the last 20 some-odd years of this rivalry

Byu_1988

4/4/17 10:09pm

If you watched you'd know that Anae is teed up for a breakout year

formerly utesplease

4/4/17 11:42pm

Yeah, it was a little off base

BrutustheBrash

4/5/17 12:02am

Two of those guys have never played and a third is

BYU '80

4/5/17 6:41am

We shall see..

formerly utesplease

4/5/17 2:59pm

Anae was a boy last year. He's a big boy this year.

jrj84105

4/5/17 4:47pm

Hype train. Choo choo

BYU '80

4/6/17 11:05pm

Anae manhandled in the run game? Highly unlikely. Think of Anae as a Van Noy

ALUF 1990

4/8/17 1:15pm

But can he do it more than a few downs? That's a big adjustment

BYU '80

4/8/17 10:14pm

Yes

jrj84105

4/13/17 12:39pm

Still doesn't address doing it down after down

BYU '80

4/13/17 1:13pm

He won't play every down.

jrj84105

4/13/17 5:10pm

<< Deleted >>

jrj84105

4/13/17 12:38pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad