My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 11, 2017
9:27
:17
pm
BlueForLife
All-American
I admit that I don't get to see practices each day, and the conversations, but
all signs point back to the coaching. Using correlation and causation, one can find a lot of signs pointing his direction. Clearly, he is the one in charge.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BlueForLife
Bio page
BlueForLife
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Last login
Aug 10, 2023
Total posts
3,374 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I find it funny that most Ty Detmer apologists want others to set aside logic
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:36pm
Mike Leach
DirtyWater
10/11/17 8:38pm
What about him?
sgriff
10/11/17 8:39pm
EXACTLY! Broke the P12 passing record in his 2nd year.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:39pm
Went 9-4 last year
BYURider
10/11/17 8:39pm
1-5(6) and basically dead last in offense isn't enough for you?
sgriff
10/11/17 8:40pm
10-10 after this Saturday.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:40pm
Well finish season close to where we finished
BYURider
10/11/17 8:43pm
I doubt that. What makes you think that we are going to catch up to last year?
sgriff
10/11/17 8:46pm
And last year wasn't that great for the offense anyway.
sgriff
10/11/17 8:48pm
Schedule
BYURider
10/11/17 9:06pm
I can wait until the end of the year. I'd prefer a mid season adjustment, but
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:40pm
I thought those were "bronco's recruits" though? Now that the team is
CB4
10/11/17 8:42pm
Crowton went 12-2 with Lavell's guys and then three straight losing seasons.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:46pm
The offense wasn't good last year either
thebruce
10/11/17 8:45pm
^This^
sgriff
10/11/17 8:47pm
It's like giving the defense credit for the 11-2 record in 2001
thebruce
10/11/17 8:50pm
^^^ this ^^^
nashty
10/11/17 8:48pm
Detmer apologists don't have a monopoly on anti-logic
BlueBlood
10/11/17 8:44pm
Exactly! It's not like Detmer is sticking to the same script hoping it'll work.
ManicBlue
10/11/17 9:41pm
and some are in his control. Lets be clear that no one is disputing that.
BlueBlood
10/11/17 9:44pm
What exactly would you do differently that he hasn't tried?
ManicBlue
10/11/17 10:13pm
Well, there are a few things, mostly guesses
BlueBlood
10/11/17 10:33pm
RE: Well, there are a few things, mostly guesses
ManicBlue
10/11/17 11:03pm
sure, but an experienced OC should be better at that kind of thing
BlueBlood
10/11/17 11:07pm
RE: sure, but an experienced OC should be better at that kind of thing
ManicBlue
10/11/17 11:51pm
The passing game probably looks great in practice against this defense.
cougaman
10/12/17 2:13am
Prediction - Ty will be OC in 2018
BYURider
10/11/17 8:45pm
My Prediction: if that happens Kalani will be Fired in December 2018.
Hawk Talons
10/11/17 8:52pm
So if BYU went 11-2, theyd fire Kalani? Really?
BYURider
10/11/17 10:17pm
Predictions wont be useless if the staff stays the same
MikeDitka'sStache
10/12/17 7:59am
Our losing in Royal uniforms far predates Ty and people still try to deny that.
BYUtka
10/11/17 8:47pm
I get your point, but explain the issues. What is wrong?
Turnpike Lane
10/11/17 8:47pm
What isn't wrong would have a shorter answer.
sgriff
10/11/17 8:49pm
You didn't answer the question.
Refugee
10/12/17 6:18am
Results
BlueForLife
10/11/17 8:53pm
Those are anecdotes. What is wrong?
Turnpike Lane
10/11/17 9:17pm
Lots of things that point back to Ty.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:24pm
they knew Ula was the best back. He was injured, he COULDN'T play, and still isn't in great game shape
BlueBlood
10/11/17 9:29pm
They said nothing all off-season about Ula being number 1 if he wasn't injured.
BlueForLife
10/12/17 7:50pm
I believe they said that Burt had an injury and was just cleared by Dr's last w/
SUAVO
10/11/17 9:43pm
Yep, and when we finally get the scheme right, then...
HalftimeAdjustment
10/11/17 8:50pm
Wait, aren't you the guy who said this?
PJMort
10/11/17 8:51pm
And this is relevant how?
Hawk Talons
10/11/17 8:54pm
<< Deleted >>
PJMort
10/11/17 8:56pm
Fine, but I fail to see how it relates to this topic
Hawk Talons
10/11/17 9:00pm
It's relevant because I'm in a bad mood. Sorry. ;(
PJMort
10/11/17 9:03pm
Yep! I would argue that Tanner, an elite 11 qb, and with proper coaching, is a
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:02pm
I predict you are someone that doesn't pay a lot of attention to stats...true?
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:09pm
First you label, then you predict. You must be great with the women.
PJMort
10/11/17 9:14pm
Show me results to argue your point. You like to make personal jabs. Fight back!
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:16pm
RE: Show me results to argue your point. You like to make personal jabs. Fight
PJMort
10/11/17 9:55pm
As much as I hate the current record, I knew I'd have to be patient when they picked Ty.
DapperDan
10/11/17 8:52pm
Really? I don't remember many people saying we would have to be patient. Did
Hawk Talons
10/11/17 8:56pm
Many people were thinking it, but there were a lot of the "fire bronco" crowd
SUAVO
10/11/17 9:08pm
You should listen to what Drage said on Criddle's show this afternoon
BlueBlood
10/11/17 8:58pm
Ty is also the QB coach so poor QB play is on him too.
sgriff
10/11/17 9:02pm
Who should take the blame?
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:07pm
Ty should. I thought we agreed on that.
sgriff
10/11/17 9:09pm
Sorry! I meant to respond to the guy you responded to.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:14pm
Detmer, Taysom, Heaps, Beck (early years), Anae, etc. BYU fans are never happy.
cougsrule
10/11/17 9:13pm
I was somewhat happy with Bronco even as a regular 8-5, 9-4 coach.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:17pm
Detmer critics don't know nearly as much as they seem to think
Mises
10/11/17 9:17pm
^ what this guy said
BlueBlood
10/11/17 9:21pm
I admit that I don't get to see practices each day, and the conversations, but
BlueForLife
10/11/17 9:27pm
when you are determined to blame one guy, you can find all the evidence you want
BlueBlood
10/11/17 9:30pm
The squeaky wheel gets the grease.
BlueForLife
10/11/17 10:28pm
Yeah, what an idiot for not playing Ula when he was injured, right? Totally missed on that eval.
BlueBlood
10/11/17 10:34pm
Not arguing to play Ula. And he was not listed as the best back until a few
BlueForLife
10/11/17 10:38pm
but
BlueBlood
10/11/17 10:41pm
They didn't list him as a starter because he wasn't going to start.
BlueBlood
10/11/17 10:45pm
If detmer didn't hire the position coaches, that is the fault of tom
idacoug
10/11/17 9:39pm
Sorry, this is KS's team and his problem.
coolblue
10/12/17 6:51am
People who disagree with you don't use logic?
Abe Froman
10/11/17 10:05pm
There is truth in this. Reality is this: the best OC we've had in past 10+ years
Coug Dude
10/11/17 10:26pm
Very true!
BlueForLife
10/11/17 10:43pm
That's why he's a D1 coach and you're on a message board
Borg
10/11/17 10:50pm
How is Sitake getting away scott free?
cougarmikey
10/12/17 2:28am
I do think Sitake is also to blame, but it is highly unlikely that Sitake would
BlueForLife
10/12/17 6:39am
Don't know what you consider an apologist but I prefer patience to reaction. I'm
ImuaKahuku
10/12/17 5:20am
K, Nice move on the apology for Ty and Kalani. That was funny!
BlueForLife
10/12/17 6:53am
Go read this article, if you haven't already. My perception is that Ty is not
BlueForLife
10/12/17 7:02am
Problem is he shouldn't be trying to "figure" it out. Additionally the problem
ImuaKahuku
10/12/17 10:50am
I feel that 19 games is enough of a gauge for us to know if Ty has potential or
BlueForLife
10/12/17 4:21pm
I'm not really a Detmer apologist but I think it's dumb to draw conclusions based on a superficial analysis of things
buffgato
10/12/17 7:21am
Whats superficial about the stats I have added throughout this chat? Results
BlueForLife
10/12/17 4:22pm
I'm saying you need two things - results may be a start, but you have to know why
buffgato
10/12/17 6:16pm
Not sure you read this post I added above:
BlueForLife
10/12/17 7:44pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad