My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 11, 2019
10:20
:30
am
displacedute
All-American
Wilson's SOS was harder?
You may want to check your numbers again.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
displacedute
Bio page
displacedute
Joined
May 30, 2005
Last login
Jun 20, 2024
Total posts
10,989 (29 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Athlon ranks Wilson the 46th-best QB in the country
Gustav
6/11/19 9:54am
That's a fair evaluation now
newbie
6/11/19 9:55am
#1 in the state of Utah, imo.
Heinz57
6/11/19 9:59am
And #1 in our hearts
pink22
6/11/19 10:04am
Athlon disagrees. By about 30 slots.
ironman1315
6/11/19 10:05am
They would be wrong
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 10:06am
Wilson's SOS was harder?
displacedute
6/11/19 10:20am
Thought we were discussing love. But Wilson is way better than Huntley
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 10:29am
Athlon disagrees
displacedute
6/11/19 10:30am
And they would be wrong
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 1:10pm
I understand that one could make an argument that he is better, especially
Jdoc
6/11/19 12:23pm
Yes, he already had better numbers as a freshmen
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 1:11pm
The comparison is where they are now. You say Wilson is "way better". I don't
Jdoc
6/11/19 1:27pm
Alright - fair response. Where are they now? Wilson seems a slightly better by the numbers qb. As to
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 1:37pm
I agree with that. As a Utah fan, if I had my choice right now I would take
Jdoc
6/11/19 1:42pm
For 2019 I'd much rather have Huntley.
displacedute
6/11/19 4:22pm
I hope he can stay healthy, but I doubt he will.
Jdoc
6/11/19 4:25pm
So I get that...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 4:35pm
You're biased (and so am I), but I think Huntley's very dynamic.
displacedute
6/11/19 5:10pm
RE: You're biased (and so am I), but I think Huntley's very dynamic.
BrobaFett
6/11/19 5:19pm
Against a terrible usc team. Wilson is better
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 5:33pm
RE: Against a terrible usc team. Wilson is better
BrobaFett
6/11/19 5:47pm
Stats prove my point. Data is in favor of wilson
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 6:14pm
Not it isn't.
displacedute
6/11/19 10:54pm
RE: So I get that...
BrobaFett
6/11/19 5:18pm
You apparently haven’t read all of my posts...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 6:44pm
Oh and no coach would rank Huntley “most desirable”...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 6:48pm
Wait, Utah has a top 3 Pac 12 QB? Who?
Lip Gallagher
6/11/19 8:42pm
RE: Alright - fair response. Where are they now? Wilson seems a slightly better
BrobaFett
6/11/19 5:48pm
Sure
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 6:57pm
I mean if you want to compare apples and cucumbers it’s fine but Huntley
ironman1315
6/11/19 7:28pm
Right. Because he wasn’t good enough.
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 7:38pm
If mangum was a good qb instead of abjectly terrible, would Wilson have seen
ironman1315
6/11/19 8:31pm
yes
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 10:19pm
Then why did your coaches have a bad QB in Mangum starting the year?
ironman1315
6/11/19 10:25pm
True, but isn’t that a mark against him?
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 7:46pm
I definitely wouldn't trade him for Huntley
cougarnw
6/11/19 10:20am
Nor would I...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 10:23am
What if you only got them for this year?
displacedute
6/11/19 10:24am
Wilson. By far
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 10:30am
Interesting. Did you feel the same way about Mangum and Heaps?
displacedute
6/11/19 10:53am
No
cougarmanguy
6/11/19 10:54am
Wilson...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 10:34am
Huntley is a much more dynamic player at this point
LifelongAP
6/11/19 10:14pm
RE: They would be wrong
Jacob4thejazz
6/11/19 11:10pm
You missed the part, where I said IMO.... 🙂
Heinz57
6/11/19 8:24pm
I think Love and Huntley would rate higher now just based on
Dangerous
6/11/19 10:08am
RE: #1 in the state of Utah, imo.
Solomon Levi
6/11/19 10:21am
Darn right....got to stick up with my boy Zach
Heinz57
6/11/19 10:26am
I get it!
Solomon Levi
6/11/19 10:30am
#3 in the state in Athlon's opinion
displacedute
6/11/19 10:22am
And you are a Ute, so that doesn't count 🙂
Heinz57
6/11/19 10:25am
RE: And you are a Ute, so that doesn't count 🙂
displacedute
6/11/19 10:54am
First game will be fun
Heinz57
6/11/19 11:10am
And they are probably correct based off of what each has done so far...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 10:31am
PFF disagrees on the whole accuracy thing.
ironman1315
6/11/19 10:53am
They obviously didn't watch him play live much...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 11:02am
They watched every passing down. (Or so they claim)
ironman1315
6/11/19 11:11am
Meh...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 11:16am
NM
Scratch
6/11/19 11:43am
He's the Marriott Bonvoy of Utah QBs
Epileptic Beagle
6/11/19 10:22am
I think thats a good start, but I think he'll be top 25 by the end of the year.
AlphaCoug
6/11/19 10:00am
If he is that would bode well for BYU's season...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 11:11am
Seems about right. CB has an over-inflated view of him because of his
Dangerous
6/11/19 10:07am
Why are you only posting his yards thrown? In those games (and all season up
Ash
6/11/19 1:19pm
Didn't BYU run more in the bowl game than they passed?
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 1:25pm
Correct. Which is why we were down 10-7 at the half in a game where we
Ash
6/11/19 1:33pm
I can't see any justification to rank him any higher at this point...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 10:10am
Given how their list is created, I think it would be easy or at least arguable
Lip Gallagher
6/11/19 1:28pm
I also saw some rankings there I thought were to high...
CoachSpeak
6/11/19 1:40pm
Top 50 recruit! Awesome!
BYUALWAYSNUM1
6/11/19 10:11am
Wilson hasn't proven himself...
Yergensen
6/11/19 10:35am
I disagree. I think he proved that he has what it takes to be a big time QB.
DadBod
6/11/19 2:39pm
Trevor Lawrence, Clemson should be #1 and Tyler Huntley #16 is a joke!
blackshirts
6/11/19 2:15pm
Yeah I don't get the love for Huntley... 2:1 TD to INT ratio and 0 great wins.
DadBod
6/11/19 2:50pm
Tagovailoa's numbers were significantly better.
ochobeeguy
6/11/19 3:25pm
TL didn't start the season as the starter. Really, all you have to do is watch
blackshirts
6/11/19 6:35pm
Ranking of projected starting QBs for our scheduled opponents
CougarThug
6/11/19 2:22pm
Love is #12
displacedute
6/11/19 4:27pm
If coaches played the best QB earlier in season he would be higher
Y4LYFE
6/11/19 2:35pm
Bryce Perkins (UVA) #21
run26
6/11/19 3:33pm
How many sophomores ahead of him on the list? Too hard to figure out
Idahofallsblue
6/11/19 10:28pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad