It is questioning the accuracy of the previous comment stating Whitt was a quality member and person. So which is judgmental? Calling out someone for essentially saying someone isn’t righteous or the one calling out such people for saying such things? If its the latter then unfortunately you fall into that same category when calling me out my friend lol. So it’s one big revolving circle in that case. I’m sure most of your BYU friends, or anybody for that matter, would agree that it’s not tasteful or good for BYU to have people saying someone like Whitt isn’t a good member of the church or person, even after accounts that corroborate such, without any knowledge about his personal life. Coming to the defense of an actual person’s character is not judgmental.