My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 7, 2019
9:00
:55
am
a priori
All-American
Sure. I'm holding all of those elements of the books constant (knowing their
differences) and stating my opinion as to which one was the most enjoyable.
Silmarillion is so much more than an appendix to ROTK. It builds the whole universe.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
a priori
Previous username
Random Walk
Bio page
a priori
Joined
Sep 22, 2007
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
37,093 (1,542 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Silmarillion > LoTR> The Hobbit
a priori
10/7/19 8:34am
Reading the Silmarillion is like reading the Old Testament.
Kilgore Trout
10/7/19 8:38am
Just the first 50 pages. The rest is excellent.
a priori
10/7/19 8:39am
It's been a while since I read the Silmarillion, but I remember it being a slog,
Kilgore Trout
10/7/19 8:48am
So, fun and humor are the only things that make books enjoyable?
a priori
10/7/19 8:55am
No, but it helps.
Kilgore Trout
10/7/19 8:57am
It doesn't help all the time.
a priori
10/7/19 8:58am
It has been a long time since I tried but I remember trying to read book 1 in
IceCreamButt
10/7/19 8:59am
Well you are comparing 4 adult books vs a young adult fantasy book.
JohnnyComeLately
10/7/19 8:45am
Not really.
a priori
10/7/19 8:57am
Tolkien himself has admitted to The Hobbit being a kids book. Many love both, but when you read them back to
Bert609
10/7/19 9:01am
I'm not arguing that there aren't differences. I'm arguing that the differences
a priori
10/7/19 9:04am
Are you the arbiter of what's a valid debate?
kirty
10/7/19 9:25am
This is what is called switch tracking.
a priori
10/7/19 9:35am
Are we debating anything though. I didn't argue your order of which is best, you gave your opinion, I gave mine.
Bert609
10/7/19 9:45am
Agreed--I'm responding to the argument that I can't compare the three
a priori
10/7/19 9:51am
I agree with that. I find the distinct difference in writing style a great argument to use when comparing them.
Bert609
10/7/19 9:53am
RE: I agree with that. I find the distinct difference in writing style a great
a priori
10/7/19 10:01am
I loved the Silmarillion; it has been too long since I read it to comment tho
jkccoug
10/7/19 8:50am
Children of Hurin was amazing, especially the audio book with Christopher Lee reading it.
Bert609
10/7/19 8:57am
Sure. I'm holding all of those elements of the books constant (knowing their
a priori
10/7/19 9:00am
I have no doubt I'll enjoy it when I get to it. But it makes sense why many don't, if they go in thinking it's a
Bert609
10/7/19 9:02am
I'd rather read this than the actual book. Does a great job without the wordiness and boredom:
Turnpike Lane
10/7/19 9:01am
I tried the Sim. Was like reading history-boring history. LotR is like more
ByuImaginesDragons
10/8/19 2:22am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad