Maybe rookie QBs, no matter how talented, shouldn’t be starters.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 20, 2021
9:22:23am

KingDave Plexmaster

Maybe rookie QBs, no matter how talented, shouldn’t be starters.

Report problem with this ad

KingDave

Previous username: (Private)
Bio page: KingDave
Joined: Oct 12, 2009
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 69,772 (20,806 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Yeesh. Ohio State QBs right?

-C9- *unsubscribe*

12/20/21 9:12am

Also double yeesh

-C9-

12/20/21 9:16am

Triple yeesh. That guy's basis for how bad Fields is is based on his qbr of 26.8

Pickett

12/20/21 9:19am

Maybe rookie QBs, no matter how talented, shouldn’t be starters.

KingDave

12/20/21 9:22am

It is all Nagy's fault. Fields is clearly the best QB out there

Baron

12/20/21 9:17am

That article is scary about Zach too

Indy Coug

12/20/21 9:18am

Fields, TLaw, and Wilson have all been really bad

Hotlanta

12/20/21 9:18am

A shame we'll never know how those QB's would have done w/ a real opportunity

Revolution

12/20/21 9:20am

Mac Jones has not been mediocre. He is top half of the league in pretty much

Pickett

12/20/21 9:30am

But TCuz thinks he’s fat

Revolution

12/20/21 11:01am

Maybe this year will finally prove to the NFL that their current system of starting these guys from day 1, is seriously

12/20/21 9:23am

Blame Justin Herbert, because he ruined all rookie QB expectations

Hotlanta

12/20/21 9:26am

And Burrow. Those two are the recent exceptions

bluelands

12/20/21 9:35am

Except that history shows that it isn't flawed. Here's a list of first round QB's over the past few years:

Alpi Gusto

12/20/21 10:46am

So its 50-50 at best. I wouldn’t use that as a reason to say its not flawed. What if those first few picks

12/20/21 10:53am

Every Rookie QBR since 2006

krindorr

12/20/21 11:12am

That’s a really telling list. And depressing for Bears fans

Medute

12/20/21 11:53am

Good stuff. Thanks for sharing

12/20/21 12:39pm

Id like to see the teams record the year prior and the rookie season, added to this list.

12/20/21 12:56pm

OR re-ordered by team improvement

krindorr

12/20/21 4:21pm

You got great stats, where do you get all of this data from.

Zoobieman

12/20/21 6:24pm

Honestly, I just get curious and so then look it up from various sources

krindorr

12/20/21 7:33pm

Wasn't Max Hall the first rookie QB to beat a defending Super Bowl champion that year?

Spiff

12/20/21 7:16pm

No, not sure when the first was, but it happens fairly frequently, 2003, 2004 etc

krindorr

12/20/21 7:38pm

I don't remember the specifics. Just that there was something newsworthy about Hall beating them.

Spiff

12/20/21 7:43pm

His first (and only) win was against the defending champs

krindorr

12/20/21 8:17pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad