Here, bold indicates someone with an above-average QB season, so anything over 50.

1. Dak Prescott, +9 wins, 77.6 QBR (13-3 in 2016, 4-12 in previous)
2. Andrew Luck, +9 wins, 65.6 QBR (11-5 in 2012, 2-14 in previous)
3. Baker Mayfield, +7.5 wins, 51.2 QBR (7.5-8.5 in 2018, 0-16 in 2017)
4. Matt Ryan, +7 wins, 68.8 QBR (11-5 in 2008, 4-12 in previous)
5. Joe Flacco, +6 wins, 47.1 QBR (11-5 in 2008, 5-11 in previous)
6. Sam Bradford, +6 wins, 46.9 QBR (7-9 in 2010, 1-15 in previous)
7. Robert Griffin III, +5 wins, 69.4 QBR (10-6 in 2012, 5-11 in previous)
8. Andy Dalton, +5 wins, 49.5 QBR (9-7 in 2011, 4-12 in previous)
9. Tua Tagovailoa, +5 wins, 44.8 QBR (10-6 in 2020, 5-11 in previous)
10. Russell Wilson, +4 wins, 72.7 QBR (11-5 in 2012, 7-9 previous)
11. Jameis Winston, +4 wins, 57.2 QBR (6-10 in 2015, 2-14 in previous)
12. Cam Newton, +4 wins, 56.6 QBR (6-10 in 2011, 2-14 in previous)
13. Vince Young, +4 wins, 56.1 QBR (8-8 in 2006, 4-12 in previous)
14. Mac Jones, +3 wins, 52.3 QBR (9-5 in 2021*, 7-9 in previous)
15. Kyler Murray, +2.5 wins, 57.7 QBR (5.5-10.5 in 2019, 3-13 in previous)
16. Joe Burrow, +2.5 wins, 48.5 QBR (4.5-11.5 in 2020, 2-14 in previous)
17. Justin Herbert, +2 wins, 62.6 QBR (7-9 in 2020, 5-11 in previous)
18. Geno Smith, +2 wins, 41.0 QBR (8-8 in 2013, 6-10 in previous)
19. Matt Stafford, +2 wins, 37.1 QBR (2-14 in 2009, 0-16 in previous)
20. Mitch Trubisky, +2 wings, 32.4 QBR (5-11 in 2017, 3-13 in previous)
21. Trevor Lawrence, +2 wins, 31.7 QBR (2-12 in 2021*, 1-15 in previous)
22. Zach Wilson, +2 win, 22.6 QBR (3-11 in 2021*, 2-14 in previous)
23. Teddy Bridgewater, +1.5 wins, 54.4 QBR (7-9 in 2014, 5.5-10.5 in previous)
24. Marcus Mariota, +1 win, 48.4 QBR (3-13 in 2015, 2-14 in previous)
25. Ryan Tannehill, +1 win, 48.4 QBR (7-9 in 2012, 6-10 in previous)
26. Brandon Weeden, +1 win, 33.9 QBR (5-11 in 2012, 4-12 in previous)
27. Josh Rosen, +1 win, 24.1 QBR (7-9 in 2018, 6-10 in previous)
28. Matt Leinart, +0 wins, 60.5 QBR (5-11 in 2006, 5-11 in previous)
29. Colt McCoy, +0 wins, 52.8 QBR (5-11 in 2010, 5-11 in previous)
30. Carson Wentz, +0 wins, 46.7 QBR (7-9 in 2016, 7-9 in previous)
31. EJ Manuel, +0 wins, 38.2 QBR (6-10 in 2013, 6-10 in previous)
32. Trent Edwards, +0 wins, 36.3 QBR (7-9 in 2007, 7-9 in previous)
33. Mark Sanchez, +0 wins, 32.8 QBR (9-7 in 2009, 9-7 in previous)
34. Davis Mills, +0 wins, 27.9 QBR (3-11 in 2021*, 4-12 in previous)
35. Blake Bortles, -1 win, 69.5 QBR (3-13 in 2014, 4-12 in previous)
36. Daniel Jones, -1 win, 55.7 QBR (4-12 in 2019, 5-11 in previous)
37. Sam Darnold, -1 win, 45.9 QBR (4-12 in 2018, 5-11 in previous)
38. Derek Carr, -1 win, 40.1 QBR (3-13 in 2014, 4-12 in previous)
39. DeShone Kizer, -1 win, 32.6 QBR (0-16 in 2017, 1-15 in previous)
40. Cody Kessler, -2 wins, 43.4 QBR (1-15 in 2016, 3-13 in previous)
41. Justin Fields, -2.5 win, 26.8 QBR (4-9 in 2021*, 8-8 in previous)
42. Blaine Gabbert, -3 wins, 65.4 QBR (5-11 in 2011, 8-8 in previous)
43. Mike Glennon, -3 wins, 55.2 QBR (4-12 in 2013, 7-9 in previous)
44. Josh Allen, -3 wins, 49.8 QBR (6-10 in 2018, 9-7 in previous)
45. Christian Ponder, -3 wins, 32.4 QBR (3-13 in 2011, 6-10 in previous)
46. Jared Goff, -3 wins, 18.3 QBR (4-12 in 2016, 7-9 in previous)
47. Dwayne Haskins, -4 wins, 28.0 QBR (3-13 in 2019, 7-9 in previous)
48. John Beck, -5 wins, 13.3 QBR (1-15 in 2007, 6-10 in previous) - 4 starts
49. Max Hall, -5 wins, 8.8 QBR (5-11 in 2010, 10-6 in previous) - 3 starts
50. Josh Freeman, -6 wins, 37.0 QBR (3-13 in 2009, 9-7 in previous)
51. Jimmy Clausen, -6 wins, 13.8 QBR (2-14 in 2010, 8-8 in previous)
52. Zach Mettenberger, -7 wins, 30.8 QBR (2-14 in 2014, 7-9 in previous)

Based on just these values, it seems like the most similar seasons for each rookie are:

Trevor Lawrence: Mitch Trubisky
Zach Wilson: Josh Rosen
Justin Fields: Christian Ponder
Mac Jones: Kyler Murray (couldn't be more different stylistically obviously)
Davis Mills: Josh Rosen, Mark Sanchez or DeShone Kizer